Live data from Hacker News

Digging the grave of my skills: Hollywood creatives training AI to do their jobs

theguardian.com

51–60 of 74 posts

Re: Digging the grave of my skills: Hollywood creatives training AI to do their jobs

#51
The movie "Singing in the rain" was about the job Apocalypse of sound technology that threw silent film actors and workers into the street, unemployed and hungry.

All those silent film era jobs were lost to the "talkies".

Hollywood not only survived, it expanded.

It is a truism in Hollywood that people always see good movies in any economy. If the industry is contracting maybe they're making bad movies no one wants to see.

AI won't change that at all.

Re: Digging the grave of my skills: Hollywood creatives training AI to do their jobs

#52
post #33

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> I have no doubt in my mind that right now [...] an amateur with a high-end last-gen GPU or somebody with maybe a thousand bucks worth of AI credits [...] can crank out a high quality 1h+ feature film with only minor uncanny artifacts. Then why are there no examples of this? There aren't even examples of steps towards it--the half hour film that's nearly production quality, etc.

Very few of these people are doing this on home rigs. That's way too slow for getting any real work done. I work in this industry. I've dealt with major studios and up-and-coming studios quite extensively. (I was a filmmaker before AI, which helps a lot.) If your exposure to AI video is ComfyUI, that's the consumer / hobbyist segment and you're missing out on where all the action is actually concentrating. There are…

> Pomegranate, one of the best AI films

I sat through 10 minutes of this and it is some of the most mind-numbing garbage I've ever witnessed in my life. The technology is undoubtedly cool and it's pretty insane the progress we've made, but my god was it a slog to actually watch. Utterly soulless, incoherent, godawful pacing, grating dialogue. I could feel my brain actively rejecting this garbage a few minutes in, but I guess I'm just not the target audience.

Re: Digging the grave of my skills: Hollywood creatives training AI to do their jobs

#53
post #12

Earlier quoted context omitted.

no it will be uncanny slop just like all the AI slop I've already had forced on me > there are millions of other people who will yeah millions of people like all kinds of dreck. sure, you probably liked The Big Bang Theory but some of us have taste

I'm not a fan, but it's a massive insult to compare a show written by a team of writers like The Big Bang Theory to AI generated TV slop for illiterate retards.

AI-cloned shows will suffer on day #1 what the original show suffered after the 5th year or so -- the plausible and original plot lines have been used up. So the AI-gen story lines will be implausible or derivative copies of familiar plots from the original series or other shows.

Re: Digging the grave of my skills: Hollywood creatives training AI to do their jobs

#54
post #17

If you haven't been following the current explosion of video gen models, including all the content you see on social media, you should pay attention. I have no doubt in my mind that right now, in August of 2026, given a couple of weeks, an amateur with a high-end last-gen GPU or somebody with maybe a thousand bucks worth of AI credits, given a good amount of exploration/tinkering to fill the gaps that GenAI cannot cu…

Good luck finding the gems under all the rubish

Re: Digging the grave of my skills: Hollywood creatives training AI to do their jobs

#55
post #17

If you haven't been following the current explosion of video gen models, including all the content you see on social media, you should pay attention. I have no doubt in my mind that right now, in August of 2026, given a couple of weeks, an amateur with a high-end last-gen GPU or somebody with maybe a thousand bucks worth of AI credits, given a good amount of exploration/tinkering to fill the gaps that GenAI cannot cu…

All I want is Seinfeld Forever

Cool. When it finally shows up, and someone says "No one asked for this..." I'll refer them to you.

Re: Digging the grave of my skills: Hollywood creatives training AI to do their jobs

#56
post #2

What I am curious to learn is how many episodes of a TV series made by real actors it will take for an "AI" to eventually make perfect extensions ie. feed it every episode of the original Star Trek series, at some point "AI" is going to be advanced enough to write a new episode and simulate all the characters perfectly anime and animation in theory will be even easier to do perfectly? the question is can it do it per…

Example see the Pine Drama shorts on Tim Tok. 5 sec shots with inconsistencies strong together into a 30 sec clip that is 1 part of 56.

Re: Digging the grave of my skills: Hollywood creatives training AI to do their jobs

#57

The movie "Singing in the rain" was about the job Apocalypse of sound technology that threw silent film actors and workers into the street, unemployed and hungry. All those silent film era jobs were lost to the "talkies". Hollywood not only survived, it expanded. It is a truism in Hollywood that people always see good movies in any economy. If the industry is contracting maybe they're making bad movies no one wants t…

I think you are saying people whose jobs AI can do are the silent film actors... Who are the "talkie" actors in this analogy; the people whose jobs AI won't take over?

Re: Digging the grave of my skills: Hollywood creatives training AI to do their jobs

#58
post #57

The movie "Singing in the rain" was about the job Apocalypse of sound technology that threw silent film actors and workers into the street, unemployed and hungry. All those silent film era jobs were lost to the "talkies". Hollywood not only survived, it expanded. It is a truism in Hollywood that people always see good movies in any economy. If the industry is contracting maybe they're making bad movies no one wants t…

I think you are saying people whose jobs AI can do are the silent film actors... Who are the "talkie" actors in this analogy; the people whose jobs AI won't take over?

I'm saying the "tech = job loss" scenario is somewhat false.

Teamsters were horse carriage drivers and then drove trucks. The horse driver job was "destroyed by technology"? Or was it changed?

Jobs are not static entities to be defended or lost. They are dynamic opportunities shaped by technology.

Every technology creates different opportunities.

No one cries for silent movie era job losses or horse driver jobs. If AI transforms jobs that's what technology has always done.

How it will actually play out is unknown and unknowable. That its just negative is sheer science fiction.

Re: Digging the grave of my skills: Hollywood creatives training AI to do their jobs

#59
post #57

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I think you are saying people whose jobs AI can do are the silent film actors... Who are the "talkie" actors in this analogy; the people whose jobs AI won't take over?

I'm saying the "tech = job loss" scenario is somewhat false. Teamsters were horse carriage drivers and then drove trucks. The horse driver job was "destroyed by technology"? Or was it changed? Jobs are not static entities to be defended or lost. They are dynamic opportunities shaped by technology. Every technology creates different opportunities. No one cries for silent movie era job losses or horse driver jobs. If A…

> How it will actually play out is unknown and unknowable.

I don't think that's a fair claim to make, either. AI music, AI art and even AI television is all fairly proliferate right now: https://www.polygon.com/23767640/ai-mcu-secret-invasion-open...

We're not seeing a radical reconsideration of how art is made, nor a rising watermark in content quality. The chart-topping AI songs are transient and forgettable, the finest AI artwork is low-cost and generally effortless. AI television and video content is mostly just a self-loathing piss-take, the stuff that takes itself seriously ends up embarrassing itself. The only people using this tech unironically is the White House, at this point.

Re: Digging the grave of my skills: Hollywood creatives training AI to do their jobs

#60
post #17

If you haven't been following the current explosion of video gen models, including all the content you see on social media, you should pay attention. I have no doubt in my mind that right now, in August of 2026, given a couple of weeks, an amateur with a high-end last-gen GPU or somebody with maybe a thousand bucks worth of AI credits, given a good amount of exploration/tinkering to fill the gaps that GenAI cannot cu…

I for one greatly enjoy the youtube channel THE ARCHIVE INBETWEEN ... Mind bending stuff
Post reply on HN