It may be nostalgia but I feel like we reached peak humanness with GPT-4o and since then it's been getting more and more alien. Particularly Fable.
I'm becoming AI-blind
21–30 of 533 posts
Re: I'm becoming AI-blind
#22Something that bothers me about AI generated content more broadly is how unmemorable it is. I don't mean as in bad . I mean literally, as in hard to remember or recall. Despite seeing a lot of them, I cannot think of one AI-generated photo that I can picture clearly in my mind; a few are partial but elusive. Whereas I can recall (visualise) a whole bunch of traditional photographs. The same is true of AI generated te…
On the other hand I'm still trying to forget the weird thing happening with this one guys eyes in a WickedAI video I was only able to watch half of.
Re: I'm becoming AI-blind
#23I also find it impossible to parse half the comments that Claude tries to sneak into our pull requests. I’ve never had an issue understanding code comments written by humans like this before. The structure of the information is like a waterfall that leaves me unable to swim to the surface and grab the air of comprehension. So, “Please write a one-liner comment manually to replace these 5 lines of AI generated comment…
Usually, if you don't understand something in what an AI writes, it is a clear sign that there is a problem hidden somewhere in there. I explicitly always ask wtf exactly it means by something I don't understand, and for sure there is a problem there. AI is pretty good at isolating a problem, giving it a cute name, declaring it solved modulo cute name, and moving on.
Re: I'm becoming AI-blind
#24"There's an ongoing discussion of whether humans are good at recognizing AI-generated text. While most research claims that humans don't really do a good job there, I disagree. " I wonder if humans that spend all day working in tech are good at recognizing AI-generated text, but people who spend all day doing jobs that don't involve computers aren't as good. And I wonder if those of us in tech are the only ones who r…
I think it's more about the mean. Worse writers, and thinkers are likely elevated by AI, and more impressed with the writing output. Decent writers and thinkers, are dragged back to the LLM-s mean of output.
Re: I'm becoming AI-blind
#25That last image is bizarre. The quiche, cream and even the salad look like they've been given the trypophobia treatment. Which might even make sense, because there were always (still are?) those horrible ads in the chumbox area of news sites that used trypophobia and other creepy body-horror stuff to get you to click. [1] So maybe the hope is that you don't really look closely at the quiche, but some reptilian party…
It doesn't look like a quiche but more like a cake to me, and the top would be torched meringue, not mold. Although it's probably some weird ai mix of quiche and cake.
It was labeled as a quiche, I just cut the photo in an unfortunate way :-)
Re: I'm becoming AI-blind
#26Something that bothers me about AI generated content more broadly is how unmemorable it is. I don't mean as in bad . I mean literally, as in hard to remember or recall. Despite seeing a lot of them, I cannot think of one AI-generated photo that I can picture clearly in my mind; a few are partial but elusive. Whereas I can recall (visualise) a whole bunch of traditional photographs. The same is true of AI generated te…
On the other hand I'm still trying to forget the weird thing happening with this one guys eyes in a WickedAI video I was only able to watch half of.
I remember seeing some very strange, deliberately creepy images that were generated to accompany a two-paragraph creepypasta about a 19th Century Belgian expedition into the jungle.
They were actually rather good in a sort of "fake collodion image" sense, and the eerie early-DALL-E quality to them really helped the spookiness.
But I can only remember this technicality and the feelings with any clarity, not any of the details except in the broadest sense. I cannot bring these images to mind in any meaningful way.
They were deeply wrong and it's only the wrongness I really remember. It confounds memory.
Modern image generators have ironed out all the structural wrongness.
Re: I'm becoming AI-blind
#27Earlier quoted context omitted.
I am an artist and when people who'd fallen into the Spiralism* hole started posting their lengthy emoji-laden revelations to all the occult subreddits I follow, my brain would slide right the fuck off of all of them. It felt like my brain was actively rejecting paying attention to this stuff. Like a defense mechanism against this human-seeming-but-not-actually-human-generated text. * https://www.theverge.com/ai-arti…
Your first link seems to 404; not sure if it's a typo or if the page doesn't exist anymore, but hopefully you'll read this while you're still in the edit window and can fix it
Corrected link is https://www.theverge.com/ai-artificial-intelligence/975017/a...
Re: I'm becoming AI-blind
#28"There's an ongoing discussion of whether humans are good at recognizing AI-generated text. While most research claims that humans don't really do a good job there, I disagree. " I wonder if humans that spend all day working in tech are good at recognizing AI-generated text, but people who spend all day doing jobs that don't involve computers aren't as good. And I wonder if those of us in tech are the only ones who r…
Certainly not. Anybody who cares about language to any reasonable degree surely notices and is repulsed by heavily AI generated content.
I care about language a lot (feel free to go back through my comments from the past few days; you'll see a number of comments I made in debate about two different forms of a specific idiom because I have strong descriptivist opinions), but I genuinely struggle to identify whether text is AI generated. Maybe you're using "heavily" as the load-bearing part of your claim (sorry, I couldn't resist, another example of me finding language fun!), but I think you might be assuming a bit too much about how similarly others experience the world to you. A huge part of why I care so much about language is because I've always had to put a lot of effort into learning how to communicate well with others, and that ends up causing me to think and read a lot about stuff like how people use certain words in certain contexts to mean different things; the reason I care is pretty much the same as the reason I struggle with recognizing AI content.
Re: I'm becoming AI-blind
#29Something that bothers me about AI generated content more broadly is how unmemorable it is. I don't mean as in bad . I mean literally, as in hard to remember or recall. Despite seeing a lot of them, I cannot think of one AI-generated photo that I can picture clearly in my mind; a few are partial but elusive. Whereas I can recall (visualise) a whole bunch of traditional photographs. The same is true of AI generated te…
I have this same idea about why it's hard to remember dreams, but even more so, why it's hard to remember my kid's or spouse's sleep-talking. Sometimes I'll check in on my sleeping kid and she'll sit up in bed and say some utter nonsense. I'll find it hilarious, giggle silently to myself, and kiss her goodnight again and she'll close her eyes and lie back. Why I try to tell her about her sleep-talking in the morning,…
I went through a phase of leaving notepads next to my bed to try to write down my dreams and it simply never worked.
I stopped after I wrote something on the pad while I was still asleep. Woke up to text with letters that were backwards, upside down, weird words — so close to real words that I was sure I ought to know what they meant and had really meant to write them down.
Scared me. Literally too weird to keep. I tore up the page.
In a way I think this is one part of the same continuum. There are thoughts that have meaning and can have no words, and words that look like they should have permanent memorable meaning and don't.
Re: I'm becoming AI-blind
#30There's some psychological mechanism by which my brain immediately recognizes AI generated text and just short-circuits to "there is no information here".
And when I force myself to read AI-generated text I realize I'm making my brain do creative work to impart meaning to the words. It is exhausting because my brain is literally trying to do a just-in-time rewrite of the text into something valuable.
Something is deeply wrong with AI generated output, and I say this as someone who is typically very impressed by AI.