Live data from Hacker News

Git at any scale

cursor.com

81–90 of 128 posts

Re: Git at any scale

#81

It doesn't matter how many technical blog posts they put out, I will still never host my code with Elon Musk.

I really wish someone would make a version of the opencode desktop application that's as responsive and well-made as Cursor so I can promptly move over.

Re: Git at any scale

#82
post #6

It’s hard to overstate the reputation of the author of this post. Everything good about GitHub’s internal systems seemed to have his name all over it (I realize that today this statement hits different than a few years ago). Our times at GH didn’t overlap much but hearing the fact that he’s working at cursor increases my estimation of their engineering org by leaps and bounds.

The biggest, richest companies in the world are hiring top talent. Who woulda guessed.

Re: Git at any scale

#83

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The product is proprietary, but the interface and semantics are documented and freely available. "S3-compatible object store" is a commodity at this point, so it makes sense to treat it as a primitive building block for a distributed system. Of course, each implementation will have its own set of idiosyncrasies and limitations, so you'll still have to make sure that any such divergent behavior doesn't interfere with…

Less of a commodity at this point than a few years ago, what with Minio immolating itself to be reborn as, excuse my French, AIStor. Which is not to say that TFA’s approach is invalid or uninteresting, but the mechanics of how “an S3” works are really obscure to those of us not in the know.

If you're looking specifically for self hosted S3-compatible object stores, then yes, the selection of available options is smaller. But an object store's ability to self-host is orthogonal to its compatibility with S3's interface and semantics.

Re: Git at any scale

#85
post #33

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Just like with climate change, the problems Elon creates don’t go away just because people are reminded of them. He still pushes his agenda, he still has lots of followers who believe his nonsense

[flagged]

[dead]

Re: Git at any scale

#87
post #33

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Just like with climate change, the problems Elon creates don’t go away just because people are reminded of them. He still pushes his agenda, he still has lots of followers who believe his nonsense

[flagged]

In what way does it improve humanity's future to contribute to the dismantling of USAID and cause the deaths of thousands?

In what way does it improve humanity's future to promote a racist film by Uwe Boll while claiming it is banned in Germany, when it actually isn't?

How low do you have to sink to promote a Uwe Boll film?

Re: Git at any scale

#88
post #62
post #52

There's nothing Cursor can do that GitHub/Microsoft can't in 2026... And vice versa... after several years of Cursor vibecoding a GitHub clone while catching up with GitHub's new features. Git's performance it's not the issue; it's GitHub Actions, PRs, etc. The moment Cursors steals paid GitHub customers and gets the same workloads, they will start having similar issues! Stealing engineers who couldn't fix this at Gi…

Perhaps you didn't read the article, but the implementation they describe is interesting and perhaps easier implemented in a new project from scratch. It can't be any worse than current github, and since we've heard plenty of people express their dissatisfaction with github recently, this is actually a good direction for Cursor. A product people may want. We'll see.

I am just too old, you know. I remember Bitbucket, GitLab, and the plethora of other GitHub killers. GitHub is an ecosystem, not a product. Cursor needs at least a decade to beat that! Maybe more!

Re: Git at any scale

#89
It wasn't that long ago that S3 didn't have read-after-write consistency. Crazy to see the explosion in cool stuff built on top after that change. This is a really well written article and definitely changes my perception about Cursor's capability to host a reliable Github replacement. But I could never bring myself to use it because of whose leadership they're under now. It's such a shame.

Re: Git at any scale

#90
I have to say, when I first heard about Origin, I was skeptical. But now I do believe that the team behind it is capable of pulling it off and shipping something truly incredible.

This is one of the best technical articles I’ve read. And I came away a lot more knowledgable about a technology I have used daily for over a decade and consider myself adept at. Kudos to the author.

Post reply on HN