Live data from Hacker News

Don't paste the AI, please

dontpastetheai.com

291–300 of 632 posts

Re: Don't paste the AI, please

#291

I don't really seem to be sent very much unfiltered AI output - do other people? I'd love to hear horror stories.

> AI output - do other people?

I've seen it on HN, such as comments where someone asked a question about some animal's habitat, and someone else responded back with Claude's answer (labeling it as such). Personally, I thought the AI answer was helpful in the absence of anyone else providing a better source link (which would have been better, sure, but apparently me and everyone else who saw the question couldn't be bothered to go research it/report back).

I agree that AI text 1) should always be labeled, 2) can sometimes be bad, and 3) real sources/writing are better.

A common retort is "If we wanted an AI answer we could have asked the AI" - maybe, but A) realistically most of us aren't even going to switch contexts in a case like that to go ask an AI about the animal's habitat (even easier than googling), even if we may be interested in the answer, and B) Instead of having every user use a tiny bit of electricity, etc. to generate duplicate AI answers, we can do it once.

Re: Don't paste the AI, please

#292
post #249
post #234

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Maybe you’re defending something that nobody here has a problem with. Using AI to rephrase things is perfectly fine.

What? This entire thread and the OP and comment I originally replied to is people saying that Ai shouldn't be used for writing...

> What? This entire thread and the OP and comment I originally replied to is people saying that Ai shouldn't be used for writing...

No, the entire thread is literally called "Don't Paste the AI, please".

That's not the same as "Never use AI on your way to writing what you need conveyed".

Re: Don't paste the AI, please

#293

Here's what Claude said: There's a delicious irony in pasting dontpastetheai.com into an AI chat, and I choose to believe that's deliberate. It's well written though. The parody answer in the middle is the sharpest part — "this mild Google search you could've done in 3 seconds" — because it nails the exact texture of unedited model output: the fake enthusiasm, the numbered scaffolding, the conclusion that concludes n…

Sure, here's a reply you can use.

Nobody is reading that

Is there anything you would like me to add?

Re: Don't paste the AI, please

#294

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Tangentially I also hate if someone answers with a voice message. I can understand that there are situations where you just can't type out the answer and those exceptions are of course fine, but if you post a voice message or god forbid a video message in a group chat you are forcing everyone to take the time and sit through it.

Literacy is dying. I suspect that's part of the reason some people hate AI. To the semi-literate a few paragraphs of text represent a significant investment of their time.

I think this is a pretty unfair takeaway when AI generated text is often so wordy, flowery, and full of jargon and abstract nouns. People are never going to read East of Eden or academic dissertations as quickly as direct, simple language either

Re: Don't paste the AI, please

#295

Heh. Just got done writing (by hand!) a Principles of AI Use document for my (ironically) AI enablement firm, the first of which is: Write as yourself. You’re being paid for your expertise and insights. Communicate them directly to us. Copying and pasting Claude responses into Slack or an email directly shifts the burden of comprehension and understanding to everyone else, and worse, risks skipping that step for your…

That's a good formalization of it. I will think you are a bit of a fool if you dont use AI but you guarantee you'll be a fool if you only use AI with no value added by yourself.

Re: Don't paste the AI, please

#296
post #35

I’m not convinced tbh, a lot of my colleagues messages are “x broken” or “I do y” … no context whatsoever, and then I have to coax their context for making these decisions. Since people started using Claude now I get full context of everything… might be too much sure, but to be honest over-communicating seems better than under-communicating - sure it’s boring and tedious but that shifts the blockage to me. Otherwise…

Points to the future where my bots talk to your bots. I think that’s healthy. Context is everything. Btw, Claude code sent my first accidental AI email yesterday. I guess permissions changed? Before it could only draft. Uhoh, waiting for the onslop.

> Points to the future where my bots talk to your bots.

Relevant comic from 2014: https://www.smbc-comics.com/index.php?id=3576

Re: Don't paste the AI, please

#299
post #287

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Tangentially I also hate if someone answers with a voice message. I can understand that there are situations where you just can't type out the answer and those exceptions are of course fine, but if you post a voice message or god forbid a video message in a group chat you are forcing everyone to take the time and sit through it.

The WhatsApp voice message is very common in Spain. I always find it jarring when I'm there, mostly because I'm not used to it, but also because it seems to defeat the purpose of the messaging app: I can't listen to your voice message on the bus, for instance. It's so normalized there that I wonder whether this is a particularly Spanish habit. Maybe there are a bunch of countries where people routinely leave each oth…

Was just in south America, everyone uses it.

Re: Don't paste the AI, please

#300

Heh. Just got done writing (by hand!) a Principles of AI Use document for my (ironically) AI enablement firm, the first of which is: Write as yourself. You’re being paid for your expertise and insights. Communicate them directly to us. Copying and pasting Claude responses into Slack or an email directly shifts the burden of comprehension and understanding to everyone else, and worse, risks skipping that step for your…

It's sad that there is a chance people put your guide into AI and ask it to "summarize"

Summarize 9 short sentences?
Post reply on HN