Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: Do you know of any company that went back to hand-written code?

news.ycombinator.com

31–40 of 136 posts

Re: Ask HN: Do you know of any company that went back to hand-written code?

#31

In what context would generating code faster not be a desired outcome? Assuming of course everything else stays the same (quality, etc.)

Lines-of-code has long been accepted as a terrible measure for code quality, and I believe it has been strongly correlated with poorer code quality.

Re: Ask HN: Do you know of any company that went back to hand-written code?

#32
post #2

Although code quality may sometimes suffer, no one can deny the productivity gains AI brings to software development.

I do. I deny the "gains". The "gains" will turn out to be a mirage in the medium to long term. The technical and cognitive debt incurred will be too extreme.

Re: Ask HN: Do you know of any company that went back to hand-written code?

#33

In my startup, I am currently in consideration for doing this exact thing. The interesting part is it's not really the AI that's causing the issue. It's the ease of my developer to make a mess, either with messy code or feature bloat. After figuring out the exact product we need with some very quick development cycles with AI, we now have some problems that I can't keep under control because of AI. So, currently unde…

> The interesting part is that AI could do this, but managing developers with AI has become very difficult to get them to slow down and build stable simple things.

That is mutually incoherent. If AI can reliably do it, developers who reliably did it before AI would reliably did it again.

Sounds like AI cant reliably do it and your developers struggle to control its outputs.

Re: Ask HN: Do you know of any company that went back to hand-written code?

#34
post #14

Do you know of any company that banned IDEs and went back to plain text only editing? Do you know of any company that banned compilers and went back to hand written assembly? Do you know of any company that banned stack overflow and went back to figuring everything out?

Those things don't hallucinate. (Of course, stackoverflow can be wrong but at least its peer reviewed)

Re: Ask HN: Do you know of any company that went back to hand-written code?

#35
post #2

Although code quality may sometimes suffer, no one can deny the productivity gains AI brings to software development.

Neither can anyone deny that 'productivity gains' are worthless if what's being produced is worthless.

If you are producing worthless code, you are choosing that outcome either by choosing to work on worthless projects, or by failing to provide the direction and constraints that cause the model to create performant, maintainable code. You can’t just yolo everything, it’s still software development, but with LLMs it’s more of an engineering and management role.

Re: Ask HN: Do you know of any company that went back to hand-written code?

#36
post #13

Ford did: https://www.forbes.com/sites/joetoscano1/2026/06/30/ford-hir... So did Commonwealth Bank of Australia and IBM: https://www.cnbc.com/2026/07/01/employers-who-laid-off-worke... And I'm sure many others who didn't publicize it because they have to keep this circular economy going.

> circular economy

I get what you mean, but in general circular economy means something different, positive in my opinion. Here is what wikipedia has to say:

> a model of resource production and consumption that involves sharing, leasing, reusing, repairing, refurbishing, and recycling materials and products, to extend product life cycle for as long as possible

In the EU it is a hot topic for a lot of non-profit and social innovation work

Re: Ask HN: Do you know of any company that went back to hand-written code?

#37
post #25

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yeah I cant imagine my job without it anymore, in my hobby projects I dont really use it because its more about learning new stuff but for work I dont really care

The key part is “but for work I don’t really care”

No! the key part is "they dont't care why should I" ?

Re: Ask HN: Do you know of any company that went back to hand-written code?

#38

In my startup, I am currently in consideration for doing this exact thing. The interesting part is it's not really the AI that's causing the issue. It's the ease of my developer to make a mess, either with messy code or feature bloat. After figuring out the exact product we need with some very quick development cycles with AI, we now have some problems that I can't keep under control because of AI. So, currently unde…

It just sounds like accumulated tech debt? And the faster you ship new features, the faster it accumulates.

Re: Ask HN: Do you know of any company that went back to hand-written code?

#39
post #14

Do you know of any company that banned IDEs and went back to plain text only editing? Do you know of any company that banned compilers and went back to hand written assembly? Do you know of any company that banned stack overflow and went back to figuring everything out?

Someone answered the question with some actual examples. Please refrain from the hyperbole

Exactly. It's quite scary that some people are reacting viciously to this type of question. There's real insecurity here...

Re: Ask HN: Do you know of any company that went back to hand-written code?

#40

In what context would generating code faster not be a desired outcome? Assuming of course everything else stays the same (quality, etc.)

Lines-of-code has long been accepted as a terrible measure for code quality, and I believe it has been strongly correlated with poorer code quality.

It's correlates directly with business objectives.
Post reply on HN