Is there something like this for Windows/Linux?
"This is a Linux-native reimplementation inspired by darrylmorley/whatcable" https://github.com/nedrichards/whatcable-linux But (hazard guess) it comes with a headless CLI binary (no GUI libraries needed) so probably could be ported to Linux (easily with an LLM?) https://github.com/darrylmorley/whatcable
WhatCable: Know what your USB-C cable can do
31–40 of 82 posts
Re: WhatCable: Know what your USB-C cable can do
#32Earlier quoted context omitted.
Huh? Decent quality cable testers can be had for like $20,000. There's a difference between a general-purpose oscilloscope or logic analyzer and a purpose-built domain-specific appliance. I probably could've saved up for one in just a few months back when I had a job earlier this year.
> Decent quality cable testers can be had for like $20,000. See the discusison linked to. Trust me, my interest was piqued by that thread and I went down the rabbit warren with Mr Google and spent far too much time on the subject. I looked at the various manufacturers and the setups required. TL;DR: To start with, you need fancy harness assemblies. Then you need to plug those harnesses into very, very expensive equip…
You need a six figure wallet to want to spend $20k on a tester :)
Re: WhatCable: Know what your USB-C cable can do
#33I'm using the hardware tester from Treedix in which you have to plug both ends of the cable and which tests a lot of things, I'm quite fond of it. I have a basket with a lot of USB-c cables and without the tester I can't remember (nor guess) which one does what.
> I'm using the hardware tester from $INSERT_NAME_HERE Oh god not again... before everyone starts naming their favourite brand, here's a 265 comment HN thread[1] (from last week !) on why these cheap USB-cable "testers" are not worth anything. TL;DR You need a six-figure wallet to seriously call anything a "hardware tester" for USB cables. User ChrisMarshallNY has a one-liner summary buried in that thread: Think abou…
Re: WhatCable: Know what your USB-C cable can do
#34I'm curious if this also works for USB-A to USB-C. The use case: My Suburu has USB-A inputs and only allows wired Carplay. When I upgraded my iPhone and ditched Lightning, I had to try 6 different cables from my cable drawer to find one that supported data transfer. I have so many cables I've accumulated over the years, I should either purge or at least categorize the functionality of each.
I'd recommend a wireless CarPlay adapter. I bought one for my car, and it's a game-changer.
Re: WhatCable: Know what your USB-C cable can do
#35Something that keeps needing to be pointed out every thread this stuff appears on: What these tools report are not functionally different from just believing "what's on the packaging", despite the misleading marketing claims. These tools read a chip called an "eMarker". These eMarkers are programmed to say whatever the manufacturer wants them to say - there's no requirement that the information be based in reality. P…
As for testing power delivery, its not that electrically complicated to put a few amps through a wire for a few minutes. That said, the user must be aware if the cable isn't up to the standards that the chip states you could have some serious issues on your hands, but I guess better to find out on the tester at the workbench or desk than at your bedside.
Re: WhatCable: Know what your USB-C cable can do
#36Something that keeps needing to be pointed out every thread this stuff appears on: What these tools report are not functionally different from just believing "what's on the packaging", despite the misleading marketing claims. These tools read a chip called an "eMarker". These eMarkers are programmed to say whatever the manufacturer wants them to say - there's no requirement that the information be based in reality. P…
Couldn't you just do a data transfer test over the cable and check the error rate? At least in theory, the controller might not report enough I guess.
Re: WhatCable: Know what your USB-C cable can do
#37Earlier quoted context omitted.
Would this tell me if a cable is close to the end of it's life? I like to travel light and I've had cables (mostly phone/pad power) go out on trips after working as expected when I packed.
I think you would need something that tracks relevant per cable metrics over time to see if it is degrading. That one just says yes/no, but maybe yes/no starts to flicker around its end of life?
> Cable history
> Add a cable, give it a name, and WhatCable records how it performs over time, with a verdict per cable.
Re: WhatCable: Know what your USB-C cable can do
#38Earlier quoted context omitted.
"This is a Linux-native reimplementation inspired by darrylmorley/whatcable" https://github.com/nedrichards/whatcable-linux But (hazard guess) it comes with a headless CLI binary (no GUI libraries needed) so probably could be ported to Linux (easily with an LLM?) https://github.com/darrylmorley/whatcable
There is also https://github.com/Zetaphor/whatcable-linux (if you want a KDE UI rather than Gnome) and https://github.com/vzaliva/whatcable-linux-cli (a fork of the KDE repo, but only leaves the CLI tool).
Re: WhatCable: Know what your USB-C cable can do
#39Re: WhatCable: Know what your USB-C cable can do
#40Something that keeps needing to be pointed out every thread this stuff appears on: What these tools report are not functionally different from just believing "what's on the packaging", despite the misleading marketing claims. These tools read a chip called an "eMarker". These eMarkers are programmed to say whatever the manufacturer wants them to say - there's no requirement that the information be based in reality. P…
> Actual maximum data throughput is very hard to know. The only way to really "know" how much data can flow through a cable is with an expensive oscilloscope or cable tester. Couldn't you just do a data transfer test over the cable and check the error rate? At least in theory, the controller might not report enough I guess.
IT interconnect closet vs. air vehicle.