11–20 of 48 posts
Did you come across Well in your research? http://well.io/
I'd like to throw another social list-agregation service in the pool: https://getamen.com
I like it. Clicking on "Create New List", when I am not logged in, should ideally show the overlay without taking me to a different page. At least thats what I think.
how is this different from https://bagcheck.com/ ?
You're using Which means mobile devices will not zoom out to display the screen as it appears on a desktop, which is what you do when you're using a responsive design. But you aren't using a responsive design, so on a phone it appears only showing 320px of the page, rendering it unviewable and unusable. Take that out OR implement a responsive design. Sorry not to give feedback about the idea, I don't really have any,…
Here's the problem with crowdsourced lists: 100 Greatest presidents: #1 is Richard Nixon http://www.listnerd.com/list/top-presidents-of-the-usa You don't get serious lists. There's always trolls, or people that are uninformed adding their 2-cents.
It's well designed and does a lot of the marketing, web-design-y stuff right, but I can't see any reason why I'd be motivated to start using your service.
You're using Which means mobile devices will not zoom out to display the screen as it appears on a desktop, which is what you do when you're using a responsive design. But you aren't using a responsive design, so on a phone it appears only showing 320px of the page, rendering it unviewable and unusable. Take that out OR implement a responsive design. Sorry not to give feedback about the idea, I don't really have any,…
Thanks for the input! We're hard at work with a mobile version (should have went mobile first...), but it's on its way - 2-3 weeks shy of a release. We're doing a responsive theme, but right now, everything just sucks. Sorry :(
how is this different from https://bagcheck.com/ ?
As I also answered for Amen and Well.io, their site is quite one-dimensional - as it only offers "likes" (upvotes). There's no granularity in the rating scale. We offer up- and down-votes, in addition to a 0-10 scale. I think that's quite important for a social list site, atleast if you want to be serious about rating and ranking stuff.
Feedback: Since your intention is to recommend relevant items you might want to optimize the referrer experience. It took a lot of clicks to go selecting a list to accessing the relevant content. E.g it took me 3 clicks to find http://www.listnerd.com/item/savant-1, and then I gave up on finding the artists music or a link to it on that page. On bagcheck it takes 1 click to access the relevant referral link.
Sorry if this sounds harsh, but why would anyone ever use your site? It's well designed and does a lot of the marketing, web-design-y stuff right, but I can't see any reason why I'd be motivated to start using your service.