Live data from Hacker News

Mozilla says stricter antitrust measures against Google 'threaten Firefox'

techcentral.ie

11–20 of 108 posts

Re: Mozilla says stricter antitrust measures against Google 'threaten Firefox'

#11
post #7
post #6

Earlier quoted context omitted.

EU should heavily subsidize Mozilla, so that this is not necessary.

Why Mozilla in particular ? Or its that just what you like ?

Gecko is the only semi-mainstream browser engine that isn't controlled by Google.

Re: Mozilla says stricter antitrust measures against Google 'threaten Firefox'

#12
I love Firefox but feel little pity for Mozilla which receives $400+ million a year on search placement in their browser but spends only a tiny fraction on its development. The rest is wasted on greedy management and frivolous projects to give that same management an excuse to give themselves multi-million dollar payouts.

Everyone's only in it for the money. There are no good or bad people anymore, only...unfortunates. (that last line I stole from The Equalizer 2).

Re: Mozilla says stricter antitrust measures against Google 'threaten Firefox'

#14
post #6
post #3

TLDR: Mozilla makes money from Google paying it to be the default search engine on Firefox. If that practice is outlawed, Mozilla will not have any income stream even close to replacing that.

EU should heavily subsidize Mozilla, so that this is not necessary.

They definitely shouldn’t. Mozilla has talented engineers, but it’s been catastrophically mismanaged for almost 20 years at this point. Keep Firefox, but let Mozilla finally die.

Re: Mozilla says stricter antitrust measures against Google 'threaten Firefox'

#15

It may kill Mozilla, no reason to say it will kill Firefox itself. Perhaps Firefox would flourish a lot more if it is finally released from Mozilla's clutches.

That's extremely unlikely. Keeping up with modern browser features takes a very large amount of work.

Re: Mozilla says stricter antitrust measures against Google 'threaten Firefox'

#16

It may kill Mozilla, no reason to say it will kill Firefox itself. Perhaps Firefox would flourish a lot more if it is finally released from Mozilla's clutches.

That's extremely unlikely. Keeping up with modern browser features takes a very large amount of work.

That’s true but I think most people’s beef is that most of the funding for Mozilla isn’t going to that work. Wethers that’s the case or no I have no idea, but that’s the general sentiment

Re: Mozilla says stricter antitrust measures against Google 'threaten Firefox'

#17

I love Firefox but feel little pity for Mozilla which receives $400+ million a year on search placement in their browser but spends only a tiny fraction on its development. The rest is wasted on greedy management and frivolous projects to give that same management an excuse to give themselves multi-million dollar payouts. Everyone's only in it for the money. There are no good or bad people anymore, only...unfortunate…

They also could have used those payments to build up an endowment that makes them not dependent on others.

Re: Mozilla says stricter antitrust measures against Google 'threaten Firefox'

#18
post #6
post #3

TLDR: Mozilla makes money from Google paying it to be the default search engine on Firefox. If that practice is outlawed, Mozilla will not have any income stream even close to replacing that.

EU should heavily subsidize Mozilla, so that this is not necessary.

Nope. Why should my money (taxes) fund a US corporation?

Re: Mozilla says stricter antitrust measures against Google 'threaten Firefox'

#19

Judge Mehta's reasoning is obviously correct. > US federal and state competition authorities recently asked the court of appeals to overturn the part of Mehta’s ruling that permits these payments. You get the "competition authorities" you pay for. Decades of government-bashing, bureaucrat-bashing, sidelining and shit pay give you this level of institutional competence.

Strong disagree. These payments are clearly massive tent pole of maintaining the monopoly and I think it was right for competition authorities to appeal them. In fact, IMO, Metha ruling was way to favorable for Google. Basically like, well, they did the crime but it's too much to disrupt so I guess we will nibble at the edges accomplishing little.

Re: Mozilla says stricter antitrust measures against Google 'threaten Firefox'

#20

It may kill Mozilla, no reason to say it will kill Firefox itself. Perhaps Firefox would flourish a lot more if it is finally released from Mozilla's clutches.

Who would possibly take it over? Redhat maybe?

I don’t think Firefox survives as a community based project.

Post reply on HN