If you thought you could have AI "reorganize a paragraph" and not have anyone know, you're probably wrong. You can't because Claude can't fucking write even a paragraph without ruining it half the time. But apparently, a lot of people are either literally blind to writing style, or just don't care, because even most "Show HN" posts these days are extremely clearly AI slop with little care, marked and sometimes not marked. If you are fortunate enough to be blind to this (trust me it's not particularly fun, the style is truly grating) next time you're on a cool new project, just search/grep for "load bearing" and have a good laugh. or cry.
Of course, not everyone is necessarily trying to be misleading, but:
- I find this writing style to be truly miserable. It's like equivalently annoying to if the entire world started talking and typing in a slick quick-witted cynical way like we were all living in a Marvel movie script or something. Not exactly like that, but it's an analogy. I now realize some people may not notice if they got swapped into such a world and their parents and friends all just started talking like this out of nowhere.
- I find it disappointing when people don't seem to think they could do better, and would prefer to have an LLM speak in their own voice rather than them. It almost makes me wonder if people are even still alive behind the keyboard. Am I utterly insane or is it weird that people are deciding to have something else speak in their voice? For anything short of a speech or PR it just feels weirdly inappropriate. Even if your English isn't great, I probably prefer your English over Claude's. At worst... I'd probably prefer its direct translation attempt over its own attempt to write something.
I've been having a great time with LLMs but seeing the way people use them has introduced me to the fact that my taste is a lot higher above average than I realized. I'm not really thrilled about that realization, because all it really means is the bar is a lot lower than I thought it was, not that I'm going to win an award for having good taste. (It's not that good anyways. It's just that the depths you can go are apparently deeper than I thought.)
Whenever people respond with "well how do I know you're not just dumping out AI outputs" I just sigh. I've definitely seen evidence that people will accuse things of being AI output when they're not, yet I am completely unworried about either false negatives or false positives. If you really can't tell the difference between "the load-bearing smoking gun" and natural human prose, its embarassing for you, not me.
LLMs in this way deepen my already existing dispair, because they're yet again increasing the disconnect between me and the rest of the world.