Live data from Hacker News

Why OpenPhoto will defeat Picasa and Flickr

benjaminkerensa.com

41–50 of 79 posts

Re: Why OpenPhoto will defeat Picasa and Flickr

#41

OpenPhoto who? I had never heard of OpenPhoto until now, so I guess that kind of weakens the point of this article by about 50% straight up. Flickr in my opinion while having failed to stay relevant in a world of Instagrams and Facebook, it's still the best place to store your photos and from what I hear Marissa is focusing on Flickr quite heavily recently. Free might seem better than $25 per month, but $25 per month…

Flickr Pro costs $25 per year not per month.

Re: Why OpenPhoto will defeat Picasa and Flickr

#42

Even though it would be cool, I think that the situation is similar to Diaspora/Facebook, i.e. end users won't run their own servers and it would not be profitable for third parties to run them either.

This comment tugs at me. "end users won't run their own servers" The reason it tugs at me is because I can't tell if it is because they don't want to, or that they can't .

They can't. To so many people, the phrase "run a server" doesn't make sense. They don't even know how to start running a server

Re: Why OpenPhoto will defeat Picasa and Flickr

#43
This article has an asterisk at the beginning which leads to a footnote "Note: I’m currently a member of the OpenPhoto Team". This should be at the beginning, it sets the articles tone. I'd take it seriously if it was an outside source but being written by a developer on the project, for me it's a cute introduction to the software and it doesn't tell me whether this software is actually good.

What I do learn from this is that it would probably be a good solution for hack-it-yourself enthusiasts from the Linux community who always look for the open source solution.

Re: Why OpenPhoto will defeat Picasa and Flickr

#44
Here is a hypothesis to examine - given the first computing revolution involved people determining how to use their computers by purchasing and installing software with the needed functionality, is a second such revolution where completely controllable personal storage and compute resources reside in the cloud, with individuals deciding how to put them to use by installing various server sofware components?

I'm personally sick of lockins and wouldnt mind a "desktop like" interface to installing and using software on servers. There were some startups that seemed to start down this path. Know of any that's moved further along in this direction?

Re: Why OpenPhoto will defeat Picasa and Flickr

#45

>"OpenPhoto is Free Open Source Software that anyone can download at no cost and run on their own servers" So, back to the 1990s? Not that it's a bad thing, but aren't php scripts and wordpress plugins to do this kind of thing old hat and pre-date flickr, picasa, skydrive et all? A well-designed 2013-era take on the problem may be interesting to see, but the mere existence of software to store, present and manage pho…

No.

Openphoto works like this (among other ways):

You can get [name].openphoto.me account and link it with your dropbox. You upload photos to your openphoto account by dragging them into a window - but the files actually go to folders on your dropbox account. Hence - full control, backup ability and everything. Anybody (you, the FBI, a hacker) can delete your openphoto account tomorrow but you don't lose a single photo.

Re: Why OpenPhoto will defeat Picasa and Flickr

#46
I've used it since summer now. It's mostly ok, but it sucks for actually viewing any photos as they are really really small and most of the screen estate is just navigation stuff.

I hope at some point in the future it will be useful for its intended purpose: viewing photos.

Seems to be down at the moment as well...

Re: Why OpenPhoto will defeat Picasa and Flickr

#47

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This comment tugs at me. "end users won't run their own servers" The reason it tugs at me is because I can't tell if it is because they don't want to, or that they can't .

I mean can you imagine say a high schooler having to maintain a server running their facebook profile?

[deleted]

Re: Why OpenPhoto will defeat Picasa and Flickr

#48

>"OpenPhoto is Free Open Source Software that anyone can download at no cost and run on their own servers" So, back to the 1990s? Not that it's a bad thing, but aren't php scripts and wordpress plugins to do this kind of thing old hat and pre-date flickr, picasa, skydrive et all? A well-designed 2013-era take on the problem may be interesting to see, but the mere existence of software to store, present and manage pho…

No. Openphoto works like this (among other ways): You can get [name].openphoto.me account and link it with your dropbox. You upload photos to your openphoto account by dragging them into a window - but the files actually go to folders on your dropbox account. Hence - full control, backup ability and everything. Anybody (you, the FBI, a hacker) can delete your openphoto account tomorrow but you don't lose a single pho…

But, on the other hand anyone (you, the FBI, a hacker) can delete your dropbox account tomorrow and you'll lose all your photos. This just moves the problem.

Re: Why OpenPhoto will defeat Picasa and Flickr

#49
post #35

I hope I don't come off as cynical, but there's no way this project will ever 'defeat' Picasa or Flickr. It could very well end up being a successful project, but it will never be on top. Also drop the whole 'Open' and 'Free' thing when it comes to naming. No one outside of the dev community cares about or even acknowledges the existence of FOSS. This project sounds great, it just doesn't seem tailored or marketed to…

The name of the hosted version is changing in a couple weeks. There will always be multiple players in the photo space but Facebook proved me wrong with that in regards to sharing.

Here's a graphic that depicts just how dominant Facebook is. http://www.pocket-lint.com/news/42150/facebook-digital-photo...

Re: Why OpenPhoto will defeat Picasa and Flickr

#50

The problem with things like this is that it's doubtful whether this product will be ten times better than the alternatives, which is how much better it needs to be if it wants to displace the entrenched players, which already enjoy some lock-in through 3rd party integration. Simply offering a cheaper and open source alternative or a free alternative that requires somebody to link it up with Dropbox doesn't cut it. T…

Completely agree. We are enabling users to import from multiple sources. This seems to be the feature that resonates most with people - to get all their photos into one location.
Post reply on HN