Live data from Hacker News

Collections (YC S12) is remaking the most basic part of the OS: The Finder

pandodaily.com

11–17 of 17 posts

Re: Collections (YC S12) is remaking the most basic part of the OS: The Finder

#11
post #6

OS X has become "the OS" now?

Is Finder meaningfully different from the Windows Explorer, the BeOS Tracker, GNOME's Nautilus or KDE's Dolphin, or is it actually clear from context that every desktop OS has something like this that does the same work?

Re: Collections (YC S12) is remaking the most basic part of the OS: The Finder

#12
I am not sure how iOS or Android handles the file system (officially), but I do know that Windows 8 could use a clean, simple, touch-friendly File Explorer replacement.

I don't believe that the growing scheme of ignoring the file system, especially on mobile devices, and in some cases even forcing you to use cloud storage (to share data between apps, for instance) is an effective solution in the short-term.

Re: Collections (YC S12) is remaking the most basic part of the OS: The Finder

#13
post #6

OS X has become "the OS" now?

Is Finder meaningfully different from the Windows Explorer, the BeOS Tracker, GNOME's Nautilus or KDE's Dolphin, or is it actually clear from context that every desktop OS has something like this that does the same work?

The real question is are they replacing Finder, or the file manager?

If file manager, then they may have a Windows version too. If not, this becomes a Mac-focused article.

Terminology matters.

Re: Collections (YC S12) is remaking the most basic part of the OS: The Finder

#14

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Is Finder meaningfully different from the Windows Explorer, the BeOS Tracker, GNOME's Nautilus or KDE's Dolphin, or is it actually clear from context that every desktop OS has something like this that does the same work?

The real question is are they replacing Finder, or the file manager? If file manager, then they may have a Windows version too. If not, this becomes a Mac-focused article. Terminology matters.

Right - they are referencing Finder which makes me think of the Mac OS. But then showing all the other services on their site makes me think this is something closer to what was Greplin (now CueUp).

Re: Collections (YC S12) is remaking the most basic part of the OS: The Finder

#17
post #8

Earlier quoted context omitted.

To a developer maybe not but to the average consumer the os is the layer where their files and software are, both of which are displayed through the desktop and the "finder" windows. They don't care and almost allways don't know about the drivers or kernel.

I'd argue that many (perhaps, most) people use the browser more often than the file browser to access content they're interested in. Orders of magnitude more, I'd think. I don't think this app is competing against Finder as much as it is with Chrome/Firefox/Safari.

It's not like there is a shortage of file management programs out there. They're basically creating one more, and layering on a bunch of hype about how they're doing something revolutionary
Post reply on HN