Live data from Hacker News

Microsoft Edge is about to lock out older ad blockers, just like Chrome did

theverge.com

121–130 of 166 posts

Re: Microsoft Edge is about to lock out older ad blockers, just like Chrome did

#121

time for everyone using Chromium-based crap xD

Chromium is a solid browser, Firefox is second atleast in every aspect, but their companies "politics" is what make the difference, it's hard to swallow pill but Chromium is popular for a reason

Re: Microsoft Edge is about to lock out older ad blockers, just like Chrome did

#122
post #106

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It always feels weird to see so much more complaining about Firefox than Chrome and Edge, while it's still so very much far ahead in terms of respecting user choices. All AI features can easily be turned off (and I am assuming those respect user privacy better than the ones of Chrome/Edge). When you say no to Firefox, it remembers it. Chrome keeps asking me every few days / weeks to become the default browser. If we…

I feel a lot of the "complaints" about Firefox are misinformed opinions from a decade ago or more. I hear falsehoods such as "it's slower" or "it takes up more RAM" which are both patently false in modern times. That was all fixed up years ago.

It had a pretty annoying bug on Mac (which I ass-u-me was a memory leak) up until a couple of years ago. Every time you'd try and tab back to it, there would be a delay that would very, very slowly get longer over time until you closed and opened it again. I switched over to Arc at the time but after The Browser Company so epicly dropped the ball, I switched back to FF and it's been really great ever since.

Re: Microsoft Edge is about to lock out older ad blockers, just like Chrome did

#123

Earlier quoted context omitted.

So no youtube?

YouTube is tolerable with ads. If I found it intolerable, I would pay. Or not visit.

Lately without an ad blocker YouTube will give me an ad every minute. Basically unusable.

Re: Microsoft Edge is about to lock out older ad blockers, just like Chrome did

#124
post #106

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It always feels weird to see so much more complaining about Firefox than Chrome and Edge, while it's still so very much far ahead in terms of respecting user choices. All AI features can easily be turned off (and I am assuming those respect user privacy better than the ones of Chrome/Edge). When you say no to Firefox, it remembers it. Chrome keeps asking me every few days / weeks to become the default browser. If we…

I feel a lot of the "complaints" about Firefox are misinformed opinions from a decade ago or more. I hear falsehoods such as "it's slower" or "it takes up more RAM" which are both patently false in modern times. That was all fixed up years ago.

Sadly, I suspect there are also a lot of culture war aspects driving some of the most vocal Firefox hatred.

(There's a steelmanned form of their argument - that Mozilla ought to be held to a higher standard than their commercial competitors - which you might think would speak in favour of LibreWolf and the like. But those who complain most forcefully about Firefox often turn out to be Chrome / Opera / Brave users)

Re: Microsoft Edge is about to lock out older ad blockers, just like Chrome did

#125
post #121

time for everyone using Chromium-based crap xD

Chromium is a solid browser, Firefox is second atleast in every aspect, but their companies "politics" is what make the difference, it's hard to swallow pill but Chromium is popular for a reason

What is better about it? I switched back to FireFox several years ago (with a very brief stint on Arc in there) after using Chrome for years and I couldn't describe a single hit I took in QOL. I remember, at the time at least, that FF's dev tooling had more useful things, at least for me (I couldn't tell you what those were at this point... I think I remember nicer flex/grid inspecting tools). From what I can tell, Chromium is popular because so many apps don't test on anything else, but I don't use a lot of web apps so I guess I probably don't run into this as much.

Re: Microsoft Edge is about to lock out older ad blockers, just like Chrome did

#126

This is why we all need to rally around Firefox (or Librewolf, or Waterfox, or whatever fork you prefer) and make sure that sacred goose is never tampered with.

Ladybird is the future. Firefox is a joke at this point

Re: Microsoft Edge is about to lock out older ad blockers, just like Chrome did

#127

This is ultimately the endpoint of all Chromium-based browsers. Even the most stalwart will throw in the towel on MV2 support sooner or later, because the effort required to maintain non-trivial patches against mainline becomes too great for the team to keep up with. It's a great demonstration of how Chromium's open source nature is something of a technicality. Unless you have an army of software engineers on par wit…

> Unless you have an army of software engineers on par with that of Google

The main thing that is affecting adblockers with this MV2/MV3 change is the ability to dynamically block requests themselves rather than have to give a pre-computed list of patterns to the browser.

We're talking about hooking into right before http requests go out and make them fail here. Let's not pretend that maintaining this capability is out of reach for any serious fork if they actually cared. Let's also not pretend it's more than a few hours per month of dev time per month to maintain it (and most months it will be 0 hours).

And before you ask: Yes, I have worked extensively with chromium's codebase when I worked for a kiosk company.

Re: Microsoft Edge is about to lock out older ad blockers, just like Chrome did

#128

Google is an ad company, ad blockers are bad. Why are you using a browser from an advertising company and expecting different results? Microsoft repurposed Google's adware in Chrome into Edge telemetry/spyware to feed your browsing directly into windows telemetry to watch everything you do, they wanted that back when IE lost the war. Google already went evil and set the precedent removing adblocking capabilities, now…

Hey now, I use Edge on macOS.

Re: Microsoft Edge is about to lock out older ad blockers, just like Chrome did

#129

This is why we all need to rally around Firefox (or Librewolf, or Waterfox, or whatever fork you prefer) and make sure that sacred goose is never tampered with.

Ladybird is the future. Firefox is a joke at this point

Ladybird may be the future, but for us non-time-travelers, Firefox is currently the best option.

Re: Microsoft Edge is about to lock out older ad blockers, just like Chrome did

#130

Earlier quoted context omitted.

If an ad isn't blocked, I fast forward through it. If I can't fast forward, I mute it. If I can't mute it, I'll mute my computer and change tabs for the duration. If it's a page in a magazine, I flip it quickly. If it's a billboard I'll avert my gaze. If it's in an airplane I take out my headphones and cover the screen. I find being advertised to so annoying there's no way in hell I will spend my limited time on this…

Or you could not consume the content.

I'd rather do all the stuff I said.
Post reply on HN