Live data from Hacker News

Microsoft Edge is about to lock out older ad blockers, just like Chrome did

theverge.com

31–40 of 160 posts

Re: Microsoft Edge is about to lock out older ad blockers, just like Chrome did

#31

Welp, the biggest reason that I use Edge just got thrown out, time to switch to Firefox.

The telemetry and ads (on start page) didn't bother you? I'm surprised there's seemingly a contingent of people who are too lazy to install any other chrome fork (eg. Brave), but are motivated enough to up sticks and switch to firefox the moment ublock is removed.

Re: Microsoft Edge is about to lock out older ad blockers, just like Chrome did

#33
post #27

Earlier quoted context omitted.

YouTube premium is one of the best subs you can buy if you watch a lot of YouTube. Plus you get Music.

YT Music would be be better if I did not have to double check every of its suggestion for AI generation. Some accounts to make their AI use public which is nice but there's no way to see their channel info in YT Music to look for that.

Cant say I've ever heard any AI generated music on YTM before

Re: Microsoft Edge is about to lock out older ad blockers, just like Chrome did

#34

Running Unbound on my gateway with a curated adblock list. Easy setup, network-wide ad blocking on every device / browser.

DNS based adblockers have strictly worse adblocking capabilities than manifest v3 adblockers. I mean, sure they have their uses (eg. blocking ads/telemetry in apps or whatever), but bringing them up in this context doesn't really make sense.

Re: Microsoft Edge is about to lock out older ad blockers, just like Chrome did

#35
post #30

Advertising companies shouldn’t be in the browser business. It’s a really bad conflict of interest. Chromium is a mistake. Firefox is pretty great. But IMO they have some poor ux defaults that make it unappealing to random people who simply want a browser.

Right. For example, Firefox Mobile doesn't support hitting ctrl+T to open a new tab, completely breaking flow for anyone on a tablet with a keyboard or their phone docked to a monitor.

Re: Microsoft Edge is about to lock out older ad blockers, just like Chrome did

#36

Running Unbound on my gateway with a curated adblock list. Easy setup, network-wide ad blocking on every device / browser.

Some ads (e.g. I know YT ads used to be this way, haven't looked recently) can't be blocked at the network level because they are served from the same domain/servers as the content.

Sure, but have YT Premium for the family. Don't know how anyone can use YT without it. And it blocks 90% of ads, the rest are tolerable / go mostly unnoticed.

Re: Microsoft Edge is about to lock out older ad blockers, just like Chrome did

#37
post #21

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Isn't the main issue that for MV3 you can't have a dynamic blocklist ? And so you have to update it with an extension update ?

There is a dynamic API too that allows extensions to modify the blocklist at runtime. I’ve been using UBlock Origin Lite on my iPhone for a while, and that works great, keeping itself updated from EasyList and allowing for custom rules. In some ways it’s better, in some ways it’s worse. Sometimes you have to flip it into “complete mode” (and give it full access to modify the current site) to get good blocking.

>In some ways it’s better, in some ways it’s worse. Sometimes you have to flip it into “complete mode” (and give it full access to modify the current site) to get good blocking.

I don't how this is supposed to be a demerit given that the v2 version had full access to every site you visit. Safari just made that more explicit.

Re: Microsoft Edge is about to lock out older ad blockers, just like Chrome did

#38

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Brave's adblock isn't as powerful as ublock.

In what sense? As a normie-tier user of Brave’s internal and blocker, it’s worked great. I never became a power-user of uBlock.

+1, works well enough

Re: Microsoft Edge is about to lock out older ad blockers, just like Chrome did

#39

I honestly don't know how people do without ad blockers. Even with being ok with ads, they are so overwhelming that I could not use internet without blocking them

In case your assumption here is that TFA is about Edge disabling adblockers: it's not. It's just removing ManifestV2 support. ManifestV3 is still supported. Despite what one might assume, MV3 does not seem to measurably diminish the effectiveness of adblockers; if anything, it improves it. (Source: https://petsymposium.org/popets/2026/popets-2026-0027.php )

The only reason anyone knows about the switch between manifest 2 and 3 is that the only meaningful difference is the crippled ad blocking ability. Nobody knows any other difference unless they are an extension developers or worked on making the Internet a worse place.

Re: Microsoft Edge is about to lock out older ad blockers, just like Chrome did

#40
post #32

It's ending manifest V2, not just adblockers. uBlock Origin lite is V3 and is still supported

Inferior alternative

Serious question: which sites have you encountered where ublock lite doesn't do the job? Even tricky sites (eg. youtube) are defeated with scriptlets, not by intercepting network responses.
Post reply on HN