Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: textlog – A quiet, text-only microblogging platform, open-source, no JS

textlog.cc

51–60 of 81 posts

Re: Show HN: textlog – A quiet, text-only microblogging platform, open-source, no JS

#51
post #45

Earlier quoted context omitted.

For perspective: you just commented 404 chars. Your first paragraph alone was 346. My comment on the about page was that it needed more than 280 chars to communicate what the app is about - even the title + intro exceeds the limit. If it is truly believed that 280 chars is enough to communicate an idea, then the about page should follow that philosophy.

I'm considering raising to 500. Care enough to open an issue[0] so that maybe there is a discussion we can track? [0]: https://github.com/stagas/textlog/issues

Honestly, I don't really care that much. The project looks like fun, and I wish you the best with it, but I don't really post on microblogging platforms myself.

I just wanted to give a bit of feedback as someone who reads them - and point out that on almost every twitter/bluesky submission to HN they are using ways to work around the 280/300 char limitations.

To play devils advocate - 500 also seems a bit arbitrary ;) If I were making a platform like this myself, I would go for a power of 2 that makes sense for storage/buffering. Maybe 1KiB including all meta, etc. You could comfortably fit a post the size of your about page, and all associated meta in that - even when serialised as JSON or something. I'd go from there and work backwards to come up with a size that has a real technical purpose.

Re: Show HN: textlog – A quiet, text-only microblogging platform, open-source, no JS

#53
post #37

Earlier quoted context omitted.

But clearly not the microbloggers on twitter/x, Bluesky, etc, who use the patterns I mentioned.

Those are definitionally not microbloggers. It's ok for a platform explicitly for microblogging to not cater to their macroblogging desires.

Definitionally not?

"Microblogs, for example on Twitter..." https://dictionary.cambridge.org/dictionary/english/microblo...

"Some popular social networks such as X (formerly Twitter), Threads, Tumblr, Mastodon, and Bluesky can be viewed as collections of microblogs." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Microblogging

Re: Show HN: textlog – A quiet, text-only microblogging platform, open-source, no JS

#54
post #4
post #3

Reminds me of org-social ( https://github.com/tanrax/org-social ) > Notes are limited to 280 characters. The constraint keeps them quick to write and read, making room for one thought at a time. No thanks.

Hi, I'm sorry you don't like the limitation :( this is for short thoughts you want to share, not really huge conversations, there are better places for that IMO.

The character limit is, in my opinion, the primary reason Twitter became so bad. It encourages absolute language (qualifiers take up characters!) It discourages any level of nuance.

I use Mastodon which has a 500 limit, and even that sometimes is not enough.

Re: Show HN: textlog – A quiet, text-only microblogging platform, open-source, no JS

#57
post #50

See also https://github.com/buckket/twtxt https://indieweb.org/twtxt

I would like to invite you to read this article: https://en.andros.dev/blog/ba142044/twtxt-vs-org-social-the-... What do you think?

Interesting! My biggest reaction is I don't use Emacs. Is Emacs a requirement? You're right that Org adds features but it also shrinks the pool of people who will try this.
Post reply on HN