Live data from Hacker News

What is a product?

roge.onwrite.app

31–40 of 73 posts

Re: What is a product?

#31
post #16

I don't disagree but for some of the examples given (YouTube, Instagram, X.com) a huge entry barrier is the network effect. Even if AI could perfectly clone these products in a day, that still doesn't translate to instant market share.

And the resource you need to host so much data

Re: What is a product?

#34

My office has cut down SaaS costs by a couple of tens of grand a year, simply by making our own versions using LLMs. It is not that we didn't have the expertise to do so to begin with, but it would simply have been too expensive and time consuming. That was solved once the models became good enough. There's a lot of money in the SaaS world, where the products are both unglamorous and one-trick pony-ish. Making your p…

Do you mind sharing the SaaS you were able to replace? If you don’t want to share the name, category would be interesting as well.

Re: What is a product?

#35
What is a product? So you take two natural numbers `a` and `b`, and you want to sum `a` for `b` times, or vice versa. Then things become complicated if you want to do that quickly...

Re: What is a product?

#37
I think a product should answer a specific need, it cannot be fully defined internally, it is an expression of some need in the environment which makes it a legitimate product. A product with no viability soon ceases to be a product. Generating code is not the same with answering a need, it is orthogonal. Good products have market fit, not necessarily are themselves well written apps.

The vibe-coded demos everyone's tired of are code with no environmental need pulling on them.

Re: What is a product?

#39
post #28

The issue is most of these demo are created by developers. Most of the developers don't have interests or skills in product and design. So they use AI to write code, not build product. Another mistake everyone making is not building better and bigger products. What is used to take a month to develop is now possible in few days but most don't put the same effort as before to make bigger and better products. They just…

> developers don't have interests or skills in product and design

I've found the opposite to be trie very often.

Re: What is a product?

#40
post #28

The issue is most of these demo are created by developers. Most of the developers don't have interests or skills in product and design. So they use AI to write code, not build product. Another mistake everyone making is not building better and bigger products. What is used to take a month to develop is now possible in few days but most don't put the same effort as before to make bigger and better products. They just…

> developers don't have interests or skills in product and design I've found the opposite to be trie very often.

That is actually a good thing. There is a term for this - https://blog.pragmaticengineer.com/the-product-minded-engine... Before that this is optional but now that coding is automated, this is becoming an essential skill.
Post reply on HN