Live data from Hacker News

New Mexico court orders Meta to pay $567m over harms to children’s mental health

theguardian.com

161–170 of 454 posts

Re: New Mexico court orders Meta to pay $567m over harms to children’s mental health

#161

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That's why phone are banned in school in France. And you can still regulate what your kid does when he's not at school.

Are you helicoptering your children 24/7 when their out of school?

Don't need to. There is parental control and much more interesting things to do. The problem with school is that it's boring and it doesn't tire them enough.

Re: New Mexico court orders Meta to pay $567m over harms to children’s mental health

#162
Parent your kids.

There are countless services to block content you don't want.

There are dedicated ISPs and cell phone providers that block content you don't want.

Quit thinking that government regulation & registration are the only ways to prevent children from accessing objectionable content.

Removing internet anonymity as a rule will do far more harm than good. Just because the people you agree with are driving the boat right now, there is no guarantee they will be in charge for long.

Edit: once again the government nanny staters get upset when someone brings up personal responsibilities. Just because it's hard doesn't mean you have to have a government (under the threat of violence) make it easier for you. Has everyone forgotten that social media isn't a right or a requirement for existence? You and your family can just not engage with it.

Re: New Mexico court orders Meta to pay $567m over harms to children’s mental health

#163

Parent your kids. There are countless services to block content you don't want. There are dedicated ISPs and cell phone providers that block content you don't want. Quit thinking that government regulation & registration are the only ways to prevent children from accessing objectionable content. Removing internet anonymity as a rule will do far more harm than good. Just because the people you agree with are driving t…

[dead]

Re: New Mexico court orders Meta to pay $567m over harms to children’s mental health

#164
post #18

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The world would almost assuredly be a better place if 14 year olds were looking at playboy magazines instead of having easy access to every fetish under the sun. It has distorted many a young man’s ideas of intimacy and sexual relations.

In what aspect is Playboy magazines superior?

There’s a single naked woman in it. No hard bum, oral, every cavity sex. Have you ever held a Playboy magazine in your hand?

Re: New Mexico court orders Meta to pay $567m over harms to children’s mental health

#165

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm pretty sure Meta will drag the case in appeals for many years until the order becomes irrelevant. Cheaper than paying $942m.

A corporation will shift the capital loss to a tax write off like any other firm. The taxpayer just takes a dollar out of their pocket, and pays a dollar in tax revenue short fall. This fine changes nothing, punishes tax payers, and Meta will just lobby more politicians. =3

LOL. Yes, let's do absolutely nothing, that always works well.

This fine also sets a precedent that some will follow. When New Mexico does it, ok, avoidable. If NY, California, etc start doing it, at some point there is no place left to run to.

Also, what's the "=3" supposed to mean?

Re: New Mexico court orders Meta to pay $567m over harms to children’s mental health

#166

A lot of people on this story are making the usual snarky remarks that, oh, this is just a slap on the wrist—some trivial proportion of Meta’s global revenue. And that is true, but unlike the EU, for example, New Mexico is a tiny jurisdiction. It only has a little bit more than 2 million people. So actually, a fine—or a judgment—of $942 million that applies just to New Mexico is enormous. If you look at Meta’s revenu…

Some people tend to forget that you got to start somewhere, and a lot of huge undertakings started this way. Such as Linux ;-

Must have missed the part of the linux story where a company was extorted for millions of dollars by a government.

Re: New Mexico court orders Meta to pay $567m over harms to children’s mental health

#167

Parent your kids. There are countless services to block content you don't want. There are dedicated ISPs and cell phone providers that block content you don't want. Quit thinking that government regulation & registration are the only ways to prevent children from accessing objectionable content. Removing internet anonymity as a rule will do far more harm than good. Just because the people you agree with are driving t…

I agree, but also in fairness it has taken this whole mess for Google to finally get off its arse and add proper age gating to Android (the Play Age Signals API).

Re: New Mexico court orders Meta to pay $567m over harms to children’s mental health

#168

Parent your kids. There are countless services to block content you don't want. There are dedicated ISPs and cell phone providers that block content you don't want. Quit thinking that government regulation & registration are the only ways to prevent children from accessing objectionable content. Removing internet anonymity as a rule will do far more harm than good. Just because the people you agree with are driving t…

> Parent your kids.

Ok...

> There are countless services to block content you don't want.

How easily will a motivated 10 year old work around them?

> There are dedicated ISPs and cell phone providers that block content you don't want.

Fairly sure there aren't any of these where I live. People cannot and will not move for a different ISP (WTF :-) ).

> Removing internet anonymity as a rule will do far more harm than good.

Most likely, and the true legal solution is to turn social media into actual media. It's killed newspapers, so it should replace them. Social media should be legally liable for everything ANY user posts unless they can prove they have active protection measures. I don't care how they do it, but they should do it. Yes, this will probably kill all social media. Burn it all down and let's build something better.

Re: New Mexico court orders Meta to pay $567m over harms to children’s mental health

#169
Instagram (reels) and tiktok are truly online version of Heroine equivalent. I remember during pandemic time downloading tiktok just to see what's all the hype was about and next thing, I was wasting hours mindlessly scrolling through it. Later on same happened with reels as well. I would open the app thinking maybe just check for 15mins and time just goes by so fast and I would end-up wasting hours on it.

Also, the comment sections are the worst. Total brainrot repetitive comments by people just seeking for more likes. Last year I finally deleted tiktok and few weeks ago I've deactivated my instagram account. Since then, I have actually been sleeping much better and also less negativity and stress in my life.

Re: New Mexico court orders Meta to pay $567m over harms to children’s mental health

#170

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm pretty sure Meta will drag the case in appeals for many years until the order becomes irrelevant. Cheaper than paying $942m.

A corporation will shift the capital loss to a tax write off like any other firm. The taxpayer just takes a dollar out of their pocket, and pays a dollar in tax revenue short fall. This fine changes nothing, punishes tax payers, and Meta will just lobby more politicians. =3

Sometimes I wonder if these comments are about lamenting the state of big corporations, about defending big corporations, [1] or about lamenting how fungible value exchange were even the Rule of Law can be reduced to an expense makes everyone except for conentrated wealth into losers.

[1] “They won this battle and the last one. But the other side has millions of soldiers. They will just replace them.”

Post reply on HN