Live data from Hacker News

São Paulo resident transforms degraded area into urban forest

saopaulosecreto.com

21–30 of 129 posts

Re: São Paulo resident transforms degraded area into urban forest

#21

I find the idea of planting trees ironic. It would seem to me the better aim would be identifying the issue as to why native plants are not already reproducing successfully, and then fix it. Plants are quite good at reproducing themselves, even if not in the immediate area.

What? No. Plants colonize new areas in complex succession sequences that require hundreds of years to play out. It might start with grasses, then shrubs, then dense stands of trees that die off and are replaced by stands of other trees... maybe there's a fire that needs to happen in between... and let me remind you that a "city park" is not exactly a natural formation anyway. If you want a park in 30-50 years, you ne…

Agreed and I think ecological succession is often underappreciated. In secondary succession an ecosystem typically has a deep soil seed bank[0] to draw from. If a plot of land has been ravaged by human development and then abandoned, that may be absent and some human intervention can totally speed things along

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Soil_seed_bank

Re: São Paulo resident transforms degraded area into urban forest

#22
post #5

It's slightly annoying that it literally says in the article that he has a photo album showing the growth of the area over time, yet the article chooses to use an AI-generated image at the top instead to depict that. An AI-generated image that looks like shit. What a way to represent this man's incredible accomplishment.

This!!!

I notice it ALL the time. Do people really find it nice to use an AI generated image instead of using a real picture in reporting? Our taste is going down every single day it feels like.

Re: São Paulo resident transforms degraded area into urban forest

#23

Time of India is such a shit news source that it should be banned from HN. The ToI article is dated: 2026-08-01 In the article it says: > According to Forbes India, in 2003, Helio da Silva... I Google searched for "Forbes India, in 2003, Helio da Silva" and found the original here: https://www.forbesindia.com/article/lifes/crazy-tree-planter... Date? 2024-09-30 I guess ToI is having summer interns use LLMs to summari…

I wanted to copy and paste the name of the park from the Times of India article so I could see the location in Google Maps, but the Times of India injects their URL into anything you try to copy. Such antisocial behavior. And I can't believe that browsers (Firefox in my case) even permit this. Is there ever a legitimate web-design reason to override copy or Ctrl^C?

Re: São Paulo resident transforms degraded area into urban forest

#24
post #6
post #5

It's slightly annoying that it literally says in the article that he has a photo album showing the growth of the area over time, yet the article chooses to use an AI-generated image at the top instead to depict that. An AI-generated image that looks like shit. What a way to represent this man's incredible accomplishment.

You might like https://saopaulosecreto.com/en/tiquatira-linear-park-en/ better.

Mods should replace the OP link from India times with this saopaulosecreto link instead

Re: São Paulo resident transforms degraded area into urban forest

#25
post #5

It's slightly annoying that it literally says in the article that he has a photo album showing the growth of the area over time, yet the article chooses to use an AI-generated image at the top instead to depict that. An AI-generated image that looks like shit. What a way to represent this man's incredible accomplishment.

Now I remember why I have the site in my adblock list. AI Illustrations are an immediate block for me.

Re: São Paulo resident transforms degraded area into urban forest

#26
post #6
post #5

It's slightly annoying that it literally says in the article that he has a photo album showing the growth of the area over time, yet the article chooses to use an AI-generated image at the top instead to depict that. An AI-generated image that looks like shit. What a way to represent this man's incredible accomplishment.

You might like https://saopaulosecreto.com/en/tiquatira-linear-park-en/ better.

I am happy I always read some HN comments before clicking on the OP link. I can save time. We should plant trees everywhere in the world, that's one of the great thing we can do for this planet and thus for us.

Re: São Paulo resident transforms degraded area into urban forest

#28
post #5

It's slightly annoying that it literally says in the article that he has a photo album showing the growth of the area over time, yet the article chooses to use an AI-generated image at the top instead to depict that. An AI-generated image that looks like shit. What a way to represent this man's incredible accomplishment.

This is Times of India. Shortened as "ToI," and we here in India gracefully append "let" to it (well earned and established moniker). (And no, the printed edition's paper quality isn't suitable for "that" purpose.)

Re: São Paulo resident transforms degraded area into urban forest

#29
post #5

It's slightly annoying that it literally says in the article that he has a photo album showing the growth of the area over time, yet the article chooses to use an AI-generated image at the top instead to depict that. An AI-generated image that looks like shit. What a way to represent this man's incredible accomplishment.

This!!! I notice it ALL the time. Do people really find it nice to use an AI generated image instead of using a real picture in reporting? Our taste is going down every single day it feels like.

High tech, low life.

Re: São Paulo resident transforms degraded area into urban forest

#30
I often speak to people online who look at society and want to tear it down and start again. I've never understood that attitude.

Growth out of decay takes work, but it takes considerably less work than accelerated decay and then trying to start again when there is nothing fertile left to build on.

I like this article because it demonstrates that there is always fertile land and opportunities where people are not looking.

Post reply on HN