Live data from Hacker News

GitHub Actions and Pages are experiencing degraded availability

githubstatus.com

111–120 of 446 posts

Re: GitHub Actions and Pages are experiencing degraded availability

#111
post #57

Have there ever been a comprehensive account from a GitHub insider on why their reliability tanked so hard since the MSFT acquisition? I'm genuinely curious what changed, what their processes are and how they internally think about their reputation being in the gutter with all these incidents.

I don't know why you've been flagged. This is a perfectly reasonable request presented politely that many of us are also wondering!!

Re: GitHub Actions and Pages are experiencing degraded availability

#116

Given the recent history of outages, I wonder how many are seriously considering moving off GitHub for anything other than code hosting. I mean actions / workflows.

To offer a data point (not a tribalist argument): GitHub Actions being down this often is still less expensive than the cost of switching everything somewhere else. Would rather have my team walk away from the PRs and do other tasks than have engineering effort, meetings, design pages, scheduling, etc. for switching over. This is annoying and I'm here because it's down. But it would have to be far worse to come close…

[deleted]

Re: GitHub Actions and Pages are experiencing degraded availability

#117

Self-hosting is king.

Except anything I'd self host would be down much more often. I've hardly ever actually experienced down time issues with github when I needed it.

I've never understood this argument. Even if self-hosted things were offline more often (which I've never found to be the case, I've had Forgejo + runners running for a year now with no downtime), the real benefit is that you yourself can work to bring it back online when it does, rather than waiting on a large, slow-moving organization to figure out what slopped PR caused their global service serving ungodly amounts of RPS to go offline again.

Re: GitHub Actions and Pages are experiencing degraded availability

#118

Given the recent history of outages, I wonder how many are seriously considering moving off GitHub for anything other than code hosting. I mean actions / workflows.

What would you guys recommend as an alternative? Both hosted and/or self hosted

Re: GitHub Actions and Pages are experiencing degraded availability

#120

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I believe Pages uses Actions under the hood for publishing, so in my head it sort of makes sense for these things to be affected in the same outage

You are right, didn’t know that. Seems like the only reliable way to run GHA jobs is to not use their runners. Hope they at least didn’t break self-hosted runners operations

they did.

> Customers using self-hosted runners may see errors or rate limiting when runners register.

Post reply on HN