Live data from Hacker News

Investors are having doubts about Elon Musk's grandiose ambitions

economist.com

11–20 of 26 posts

Re: Investors are having doubts about Elon Musk's grandiose ambitions

#11

Yet Mr Musk does appear to have lunar ambitions for Tesla’s humanoids. He outlined a “super sci-fi” future in which they would operate factories on the Moon building solar panels and radiators for SpaceX’s satellites. Humans may be the advanced guard. Ms Shotwell said SpaceX’s aim was to put “boots on the Moon” as early as 2028. Do company executives really make these sort of claims with a straight face? More importa…

> > Ms Shotwell said SpaceX’s aim was to put “boots on the Moon” as early as 2028. > Do company executives really make these sort of claims with a straight face? More importantly, does anybody in the "public" really believe them? Why do you think this is far-fetched?

I’m sitting here in my driveway in my Tesla Roadster after it autonomously drove me from Boston back home to NYC. My robot servants are folding the laundry

I agree, totally not far fetched

Re: Investors are having doubts about Elon Musk's grandiose ambitions

#12
post #9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Seems like Starship has a ways to go before carrying human passengers?

> a ways to go before carrying human passengers? SpaceX has safely flown 78 crewmembers from 20 countries across 20 human spaceflight missions using its Crew Dragon spacecraft since May 2020.

Yes I know, but how do they plan to get to the moon?

Re: Investors are having doubts about Elon Musk's grandiose ambitions

#13
post #9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Seems like Starship has a ways to go before carrying human passengers?

> a ways to go before carrying human passengers? SpaceX has safely flown 78 crewmembers from 20 countries across 20 human spaceflight missions using its Crew Dragon spacecraft since May 2020.

SpaceX, not Starship. While I don't agree with the “starship will never orbit” haters, the viewpoint itself is coherent.

Re: Investors are having doubts about Elon Musk's grandiose ambitions

#14

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> a ways to go before carrying human passengers? SpaceX has safely flown 78 crewmembers from 20 countries across 20 human spaceflight missions using its Crew Dragon spacecraft since May 2020.

Yes I know, but how do they plan to get to the moon?

On a rocket?

They make and launch them. More, in fact than the rest of the world combined.

At this point, anyone claiming "SpaceX can't do " is either 1) claiming that no one can or 2) blinded by some sort of ideological bias.

Re: Investors are having doubts about Elon Musk's grandiose ambitions

#15

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> a ways to go before carrying human passengers? SpaceX has safely flown 78 crewmembers from 20 countries across 20 human spaceflight missions using its Crew Dragon spacecraft since May 2020.

Yes I know, but how do they plan to get to the moon?

> how do they plan to get to the moon?

With Starship. Is that a trick question?

Re: Investors are having doubts about Elon Musk's grandiose ambitions

#16
post #9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Seems like Starship has a ways to go before carrying human passengers?

> a ways to go before carrying human passengers? SpaceX has safely flown 78 crewmembers from 20 countries across 20 human spaceflight missions using its Crew Dragon spacecraft since May 2020.

Crew dragon was designed by smart minds.

Those smart minds have mostly left spacex now, since musk changed political sides and became much less 'cool' for the brightest to work at.

That's why the company is struggling now - few smart minds means little progress.

Re: Investors are having doubts about Elon Musk's grandiose ambitions

#17

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> a ways to go before carrying human passengers? SpaceX has safely flown 78 crewmembers from 20 countries across 20 human spaceflight missions using its Crew Dragon spacecraft since May 2020.

Crew dragon was designed by smart minds. Those smart minds have mostly left spacex now, since musk changed political sides and became much less 'cool' for the brightest to work at. That's why the company is struggling now - few smart minds means little progress.

> Those smart minds have mostly left spacex now since musk changed political sides

Care to name a few?

Re: Investors are having doubts about Elon Musk's grandiose ambitions

#18

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Crew dragon was designed by smart minds. Those smart minds have mostly left spacex now, since musk changed political sides and became much less 'cool' for the brightest to work at. That's why the company is struggling now - few smart minds means little progress.

> Those smart minds have mostly left spacex now since musk changed political sides Care to name a few?

Tom Mueller, Chris Thompson, Hans Koenigsmann, Tim Buzza etc have all left.

Makes sense - they had been there ~20 years and must have a huge pile of stock.

But due to musks political aura (mostly right leaning), the smart minds from universities(which are mostly left leaning) are no longer joining spacex en-mass.

In turn, that means the companies are merely ticking along, not racing ahead.

Re: Investors are having doubts about Elon Musk's grandiose ambitions

#19

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Those smart minds have mostly left spacex now since musk changed political sides Care to name a few?

Tom Mueller, Chris Thompson, Hans Koenigsmann, Tim Buzza etc have all left. Makes sense - they had been there ~20 years and must have a huge pile of stock. But due to musks political aura (mostly right leaning), the smart minds from universities(which are mostly left leaning) are no longer joining spacex en-mass. In turn, that means the companies are merely ticking along, not racing ahead.

> the smart minds from universities are no longer joining spacex

What data do you have to convince someone who is skeptical and suspicious of your claim?

Post reply on HN