Live data from Hacker News

Meta Ran Ads That Contained AI-Generated Child Sexual Abuse Imagery

wired.com

191–200 of 294 posts

Re: Meta Ran Ads That Contained AI-Generated Child Sexual Abuse Imagery

#191
post #144

Earlier quoted context omitted.

There are basically always filters of some kind, though not necessarily the ones we want. The bigger the target that filter represents, the more effort is spent breaking it.

The filter you want is named 'uBlock Origin' :)

Without ublock origin internet is so dirty.

Re: Meta Ran Ads That Contained AI-Generated Child Sexual Abuse Imagery

#192

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This is so true. When you have a billion users, you can literally lose hundreds of millions of users and it wouldn't make a dent. The only way is to get the government involved and regulate this and just keep hammering them with massive fines that really make a dent in their bottom line. For a lot of people, government regulation of this sort is not desirable, but at what point does someone need to drop the hammer to…

Something like three strikes and the CEO, top executives, and three primary share holders go to jail while forcing the company to dissolve seems to be the only solution to removing bad actors in corporate settings.

Ah, what a pleasure to imagine that scenario, however unlikely, for just a few seconds. People profiting from running unethical ads and child sexual abuse material, for whom financial gain is more important than any ethics, laws or health of others, who frankly speaking don't give a fuck about anyone else but themselves amassing more money, being held responsible and being moved to a new, very different kind of home behind bars. It would be as if angels started to sing and cleanse planet Earth just a tiny little bit. We would have reason to rejoice and celebrate. On the streets! On the roofs! Everywhere! Celebrate that the law still has teeth, and is upheld. It would also be a nice measure to heal other businesses from many bad practices.

Re: Meta Ran Ads That Contained AI-Generated Child Sexual Abuse Imagery

#193

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I guess you're used to standard billions (a million millions). A US billion would certainly suffer from losing hundreds of millions, you're talking about a double-digit percent.

10^9 is the standard definition of a billion, it's very wrong to call 10^12 a "standard billion." You can say "long scale billion" if you want to refer to the definitively non-standard 10^12 billion.

To quibble/add-nuance: The words have diverged into a false-friend [0] situation. It looks like the same word, but the correct/standard meaning depends on which language is being used at the time.

If someone is writing English and puts "billion" for 10^12, that's a translation error, much like writing "my grandfather became pregnant when he realized he'd locked the keys inside the car." (Instead of "embarrassed.")

Conversely, if I wrote a French or German sentence and put "billion" for 10^9, then I'd be the one making the translation mistake.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/False_friend

Re: Meta Ran Ads That Contained AI-Generated Child Sexual Abuse Imagery

#194
post #144

Earlier quoted context omitted.

There are basically always filters of some kind, though not necessarily the ones we want. The bigger the target that filter represents, the more effort is spent breaking it.

The filter you want is named 'uBlock Origin' :)

Indeed, and the Revanced apk customisation on Android, and SmartTube on Google TV.

I've not seen an ad from Youtube for probably 10+ years on my devices (since whenever Vanced made the apk customisations popular).

Re: Meta Ran Ads That Contained AI-Generated Child Sexual Abuse Imagery

#195
post #189

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yes it's meaningful, and the fine amount should reflect that. But hypothetically, if it's (just throwing a random number out there) 1 image in 50 billion, and Facebook gets more benefit from the 50 billion good images than society loses from the 1 bad one, and society recovers its loss from Facebook via a fine, but the fine isn't big enough to make them change their behavior, how exactly is that a problem?

The problem is equating profitability with what societies want and don’t want. Morality exists outside of the business world (and it should inside as well). Further, it is a societies’ right to enforce the boundaries of what business are allow to do / not do. For example: banning ads along roads and scenic areas. Idk, the whole idea of “how much fines will I get doing X shitty business practice” is just gross. I’d ra…

Pretty sure this isn't what they are teaching at the best business schools.

Re: Meta Ran Ads That Contained AI-Generated Child Sexual Abuse Imagery

#196
post #57

I'm wondering what people expect these companies to do? Human moderators? Sure, but Meta products have approximately half the worlds population using them. At this scale it's pretty mind bogglingly difficult to moderate down everything. The ads/posts served per second is an astronomical number. This truly is a case where AI is the solution. There's no way to automate this at scale with humans. As AI gets better hopef…

Facebook is a pox on civilization, so one possibility is just firing it into the sun.

Re: Meta Ran Ads That Contained AI-Generated Child Sexual Abuse Imagery

#197

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It’s mostly on her tv so I don’t really know how to get around that, at least not in a way that’s easier and more reliable than paying. I tell myself at least it’s cheaper than cable haha.

yeah have been struggling w that myself. Good luck!

If you have a Google TV try SmartTube. It's an independently developed app with a custom interface, so that might put some people off. For just watching videos without obnoxious ads its great though.

Re: Meta Ran Ads That Contained AI-Generated Child Sexual Abuse Imagery

#198
post #77

36 million CSAM media removed in 2025? Why aren't millions of people in jail? Wtf?

media without abuse is labelled csam

Seems they've mistaken child pornography (as per the US legal definition) as CSAM.

Re: Meta Ran Ads That Contained AI-Generated Child Sexual Abuse Imagery

#199
post #57

I'm wondering what people expect these companies to do? Human moderators? Sure, but Meta products have approximately half the worlds population using them. At this scale it's pretty mind bogglingly difficult to moderate down everything. The ads/posts served per second is an astronomical number. This truly is a case where AI is the solution. There's no way to automate this at scale with humans. As AI gets better hopef…

tbf they generally don't even try with moderation. A few years back they made a multimillion pound settlement with a UK consumer finance guru who was sick his face being used to fake endorsements of scam products promoted mainly via Facebook ads So you'd think that a sophisticated tech company that had paid that financial penalty would find it pretty easy to have a simple text filter for "Martin Lewis" and perhaps ev…

FB can't even be absolved for Myanmar, first off because they try to actively be a monopoly https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10791198 (not restricted to India; multiple countries) and second, per Careless People https://www.amazon.com/Careless-People-Cautionary-Power-Idea... they were told about it and nothing got done about it

Re: Meta Ran Ads That Contained AI-Generated Child Sexual Abuse Imagery

#200
Metas ads are all over the place. Thomas Kehl, one of the founders of "Finanzfluss" (a german site/content creation company about finance) is currently suing meta because scammers keep using his picture.

There really needs to be some harder punishments for this kind of behavior, after all meta profits by selling scammy ads.

Post reply on HN