Live data from Hacker News

Meta Ran Ads That Contained AI-Generated Child Sexual Abuse Imagery

wired.com

11–20 of 294 posts

Re: Meta Ran Ads That Contained AI-Generated Child Sexual Abuse Imagery

#12

36 million CSAM media removed in 2025? Why aren't millions of people in jail? Wtf?

it can take awhile for things to work their way from NCMEC (national center for missing & exploited children) to the appropriate local agency, then have that agency do their investigation, get a warrant (if they can), etc. and that is assuming that there is even a cooperative jurisdiction for NCMEC to send the initial report to.

but, plenty of people do end up in prison, especially if its facebook/dropbox/gmail/etc... they just dont make the headlines (especially nationally) unless its especially heinous.

Re: Meta Ran Ads That Contained AI-Generated Child Sexual Abuse Imagery

#13

> but as Wired notes, it relies on "automated tools" as part of the process, which may have been how the more than 50 ads TTP discovered made it through. Again, and again, and again, these technologies have proven ineffective to moderate content. User posted and otherwise. Until we have a legal mechanism in place to hold these companies meaningfully liable for this, it will not stop. Every single one of these has the…

Yeah and/but also the case it's not bidirectional enough

The eternal question of tech platforms - should we be responsible for what users post? (Ads are not user posted, so we can eliminated that factor. Even if posted by 'users' it's a separate pipeline) But with companies like Meta it doesn't even have to go that far - the philosophical conversation - because it's so hostile to users. People get banned for mild things all the time (apparently extra the case, since the 'pivot' to AI) while the absolutely horrible things you report never get taken down

Re: Meta Ran Ads That Contained AI-Generated Child Sexual Abuse Imagery

#18
post #10

> but as Wired notes, it relies on "automated tools" as part of the process, which may have been how the more than 50 ads TTP discovered made it through. Again, and again, and again, these technologies have proven ineffective to moderate content. User posted and otherwise. Until we have a legal mechanism in place to hold these companies meaningfully liable for this, it will not stop. Every single one of these has the…

But they couldn't possibly do it at that the scale they're operating at. They couldn't hire enough people in the countries they operate, or know the language, or trust that who they do hire aren't corrupt or working against their interest. And they can't manually approve every ad, or make sure targeting isn't illegal or otherwise harmful. --- This is sarcasm, by the way. Most decent people make sure what they're abou…

>But they couldn't possibly do it at that the scale they're operating at. They couldn't hire enough people in the countries they operate, or know the language, or trust that who they do hire aren't corrupt or working against their interest. And they can't manually approve every ad, or make sure targeting isn't illegal or otherwise harmful.

you say sarcasm, but i think this is literally true.

this isn't a defense of facebook, i think that their scale makes it actually impossible (while remaining a going concern). the result should be that they arent allowed to operate at a scale that they cant handle, instead of being able to brush it under the rug every ~6 months when an incident hits the news cycle.

Re: Meta Ran Ads That Contained AI-Generated Child Sexual Abuse Imagery

#19

[flagged]

So according to you 60% of Americans are all pedophiles and “retarded” because they use AI. Glad to have such constructive discourse with you bud.

Saying X if for A and B, implies a non exclusive logical or.

Income is for daily necessities and long term investment.

Re: Meta Ran Ads That Contained AI-Generated Child Sexual Abuse Imagery

#20

36 million CSAM media removed in 2025? Why aren't millions of people in jail? Wtf?

That's a really common reaction to people first hearing about the delta between how society talks about the subject vs what they actually do about it. Its a bit like the fiction of the social safety net or strong institutions.

The truth is impunity is the rule, victims especially of CSA and CSAM, or revenge porn, or of Mark or Musk's companies generating naked images of their body have basically no power, and its an exception when someone who is an abuser AND has any amount of social standing is put away.

Post reply on HN