Live data from Hacker News

Aristotle quotes on virtue, knowledge, and happiness

campion.edu.au

31–40 of 104 posts

Re: Aristotle quotes on virtue, knowledge, and happiness

#31

“We are what we repeatedly do. Excellence, then, is not an act, but a habit.” Aristotle never said this. It's Will Durant. https://medium.com/the-mission/my-favourite-quote-of-all-tim... https://old.reddit.com/r/askphilosophy/comments/s2n3s/source... This invalidates the post for me, it takes it from academic research to fanboy posting.

Funnily enough, people attributing "smart sounding" quotes to Aristotle has been a headache for historians for as long as Aristotle's writing has been around. The more things change...

Re: Aristotle quotes on virtue, knowledge, and happiness

#32
post #24

Actually reading Aristotle's Nichomachean Ethics is worth it. Not because he's right about everything (he has some pretty messed up and weird views), but because it's challenging and good to think on, and chances are you'll take something away for yourself that you wouldn't have gotten from some webpage that took one-liners out of context, some of which aren't even by Aristotle.

It’s weird and messed up because Aristotle’s audience isn’t Christian or even Abrahamic the slightest. He’s right about rejecting abstract definitions that aren’t grounded in the elements of a situation however.

Re: Aristotle quotes on virtue, knowledge, and happiness

#34

FWIW, I got a lot more about virtue ethics from reading Plato's works, the Stoics, and Cicero. Aristotle is somewhat dry and tedious to read. Go for him if you're into formal logic and related technical systems. But if you're truly interested in virtue ethics and have some reading discipline, try Seneca, Epictetus, and Marcus Aurelius. On Marcus Aurelius: he's often recommended mindlessly (especially in tech circles)…

Plato is delightfully weird and engaging and way more fun to read than Aristotle, agreed.

Re: Aristotle quotes on virtue, knowledge, and happiness

#35
post #12

Much of this is either simply not Aristotle, or a paraphrase from one of his works incorrectly attributed to another. My slop meter is pinging. Edit: Between the misattributions, fabricated quotes, listicle format, thin explanatory paragraphs, and use of “delve” (posted Nov 2024 - during ChatGPT’s Delve Era), this is a pretty embarrassing thing for a Liberal Arts college to post.

Thanks for delving, I hadn't picked up on the misattributions. But I'm looking to read some of those books now given the comments here.

Re: Aristotle quotes on virtue, knowledge, and happiness

#38
post #24

Actually reading Aristotle's Nichomachean Ethics is worth it. Not because he's right about everything (he has some pretty messed up and weird views), but because it's challenging and good to think on, and chances are you'll take something away for yourself that you wouldn't have gotten from some webpage that took one-liners out of context, some of which aren't even by Aristotle.

> he has some pretty messed up and weird views

What’s an example?

Re: Aristotle quotes on virtue, knowledge, and happiness

#39

The first quote is not even a quote from Aristotle but from Will Durant’s book, The Story of Philosophy (1926)

The saying is a paraphrase of Aristotle's ideas on virtue.

Technically the words are that of Durant but the core idea is Aristotle.

Re: Aristotle quotes on virtue, knowledge, and happiness

#40

“We are what we repeatedly do. Excellence, then, is not an act, but a habit.” Aristotle never said this. It's Will Durant. https://medium.com/the-mission/my-favourite-quote-of-all-tim... https://old.reddit.com/r/askphilosophy/comments/s2n3s/source... This invalidates the post for me, it takes it from academic research to fanboy posting.

The saying is a paraphrase of Aristotle's ideas on virtue.

Technically the words are that of Durant but the core idea is Aristotle.

Post reply on HN