Live data from Hacker News

US Military asks troops for 'creative and unconventional' ideas to punish Iran

cnn.com

41–50 of 68 posts

Re: US Military asks troops for 'creative and unconventional' ideas to punish Iran

#41

Here is an idea: the only way to win is a large and extremely costly invasion, actual troops on the ground for probably a decade. Nobody wants to pay that price. It was insane to start this war, and everybody knew it but Netanyahu and Trump. I can't believe Rubio was stupid enough to go along with it.

What every admin in this century has done is to avoid declaring what construes "winning" -- which is rather convenient to them as far as how they are to be judged on waging that war.

Re: US Military asks troops for 'creative and unconventional' ideas to punish Iran

#42
post #6

Turn all the under-mountain missile cities into super-mega-mall-cities with Whole Foods, McDonalds, indoor shooting ranges, nail salons, super-walmarts, hotels, apartments, casinos, mega strip clubs and free e-bikes to get from business to business as the tunnels go on for miles. Free unlimited, uncensored WiFi, everywhere. Air conditioning, everywhere. Make each section walking-friendly. Import millions of tourists.…

There would be much time for breeding prodigiously, with a ratio of say 10 females to each male. Could be selected by a computer.

Re: US Military asks troops for 'creative and unconventional' ideas to punish Iran

#43

To punish them for being invaded by us? The abuser saying "Why did you make me hit you?"

Even if one is against bombing Iran on account of its civilians, one shouldn't act like Iran under its current rulers is a peace-loving nation that keeps to itself. I'll join the chorus if Trump bombs Greenland or Canada.

Re: US Military asks troops for 'creative and unconventional' ideas to punish Iran

#44
post #8
post #5

Could be deliberate theater. The real plan is a containment and a slow economic collapse of Iran anyway. If the EU and Japan pay higher energy costs, that is an added bonus for Trump.

Because isolation totally works, looks at Cuba and North Korea

And Iran, for that matter

Re: US Military asks troops for 'creative and unconventional' ideas to punish Iran

#46
post #18

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Uh the problem is Iranians have no purchasing power because of runaway inflation due to crushing US-imposed sanctions. None of the above would be possible without first ending sanctions.

Ending sanctions would be part of the deal and of course required to sell the boring equipment and to get oil revenue fully back online.

I should add, maybe give each family $100k. $500k to each family that lost kids in that school.

Re: US Military asks troops for 'creative and unconventional' ideas to punish Iran

#47

To punish them for being invaded by us? The abuser saying "Why did you make me hit you?"

Even if one is against bombing Iran on account of its civilians, one shouldn't act like Iran under its current rulers is a peace-loving nation that keeps to itself. I'll join the chorus if Trump bombs Greenland or Canada.

> one shouldn't act like Iran under its current rulers is a peace-loving nation that keeps to itself.

I guess the US should be bombed too by that logic.

Re: US Military asks troops for 'creative and unconventional' ideas to punish Iran

#48

To punish them for being invaded by us? The abuser saying "Why did you make me hit you?"

Even if one is against bombing Iran on account of its civilians, one shouldn't act like Iran under its current rulers is a peace-loving nation that keeps to itself. I'll join the chorus if Trump bombs Greenland or Canada.

You can say that about most US allies in the middle-east. I don't see the US waging war on them.

Re: US Military asks troops for 'creative and unconventional' ideas to punish Iran

#50
post #5

Could be deliberate theater. The real plan is a containment and a slow economic collapse of Iran anyway. If the EU and Japan pay higher energy costs, that is an added bonus for Trump.

The only two people here still defending Trump's Iran war are doing it from fresh throwaway accounts. It's not looking good.
Post reply on HN