Live data from Hacker News

Don't be a meat proxy

gruhn.me

111–120 of 786 posts

Re: Don't be a meat proxy

#111
post #18

Earlier quoted context omitted.

i’m not doubting this, but do you know if there are any studies on this already?

https://phys.org/news/2023-03-online-iq-scores-century.html https://doi.org/10.1016/j.intell.2023.101734

US centric data, absolutely useless. This is just measuring american decline, not civilisation changes.

Re: Don't be a meat proxy

#112
When "ai slop" became a concept, it mostly came into spaces where "human slop" had already been firmly established.

Obvious ones like content scroll fodder. But also, there's slop everywhere. Even things like longform journalism or trade publications... these are often "slop." A string of platitudes and generalizations that superficially seem serious.

That is true in work culture too. A lot of people jump in on emails, superficially seem to be working... but contribute little of value. Now they do this, but with ai.

Re: Don't be a meat proxy

#113
post #2

If you create a machine for laziness you're going to get lazy people. It's only going to get worse I'm afraid. Do you guys think we're going to see a de-evolution of human beings due to technology?

Similar to physical exercise and machines replacing it, I think we're going to see extremes on both ends.

Re: Don't be a meat proxy

#114

Earlier quoted context omitted.

it's already happening. IQ is already stagnating or even going down

IQ is calibrated so that the average IQ is 100. If the average IQ is going down, something has gone very wrong somewhere

IQ gets manually recalibrated downwards when people get stupider so it's mean 100 by construction.

Re: Don't be a meat proxy

#115
post #56

Earlier quoted context omitted.

At my dayjob there is a person spearheading ai across the enterprise. They generated lots of documentation across the whole stack and now makes all PO/BAs read it if it's correct. So not just 300 lines - he unironically generated thousands of lines of "documentation" and is now making hundreds of people review it for him Complete brainrot Au psychosis is getting seriously outrageous at this point Thankfully I'm a dev…

> Au psychosis is getting seriously outrageous at this point So... back to a currency backed by gold?

Aren't you clever knowing the periodic table symbol for gold! Actual Intelligence could grasp this was a simple keytranspose typo...

Re: Don't be a meat proxy

#116
I read this a couple weeks back and its appeal really stuck with me: if you expect someone to give their attention to something you made, make sure you've given your own attention and effort first.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48497609 https://tombedor.dev/human-attention-and-human-effort/

Re: Don't be a meat proxy

#118
post #91

At my last job, a coworker did this to me. The first time it happened, I ignored it. The second time, I responded in public saying “thanks but I can ask Claude myself.” Nobody ever pasted me an LLM response again. YMMV with team size and seniority though

[flagged]

This smells an awful like a post-hoc justification of why you can’t answer it yourself.

If you _could_ do that and hand the information to Claude, you could also just…give the person that information directly, and avoid wasting their time and the tokens.

Re: Don't be a meat proxy

#119
Someone should have sent Claude's output, which spotted the trivial bug behind the recent bitcoin heist, to the Coldcard developers.

It might be rude to send LLM output. It's also rude not to check basic things with an LLM before wasting someone's time.

Re: Don't be a meat proxy

#120
post #91

At my last job, a coworker did this to me. The first time it happened, I ignored it. The second time, I responded in public saying “thanks but I can ask Claude myself.” Nobody ever pasted me an LLM response again. YMMV with team size and seniority though

[flagged]

If someone asked you a question, it's most likely because they value you. Whether it's your skills, your domain knowledge, or something else, people ask you questions because they know you can provide some value. When you give them a Claude response, not only are you being rude, but you're devaluing yourself in the eyes of those around you. They learn that you can't be relied upon any more, and so they stop asking you questions.
Post reply on HN