Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: How are you using AI to learn?

news.ycombinator.com

21–30 of 34 posts

Re: Ask HN: How are you using AI to learn?

#21

AI, when used in an organized and structured way, is excellent for learning a language. For example: 1. Ask AI for the 10 most commonly used verbs in ordinary daily speech in language X. 2. Prompt AI: generate 4 short sentences for each of the 10 verbs at the A1 (beginner) level. Provide the sentences in .csv format compatible with the Anki flash card program. 3. Import .csv into Anki. Study your 40 cards. As you adv…

If you want to skip the clunky csv step, you can utilize https://github.com/jasperket/clanki and push directly from AI to Anki.

Re: Ask HN: How are you using AI to learn?

#23
post #13
post #4

I had Claude research and synthesize as much as it could from published curriculums and then design its own undergrad Philosophy degree. Then I asked it to split it into lessons, and I am consuming these lessons, delivered dialogically, at the rate of about 1 a week at the moment. It's fun, it's engaging, and I really feel like I am learning and making progress. Could all be an illusion.

Do you trust everything you read or how do you verify that the LLM is not hallucinating and giving you erroneus content?

How do you verify that books and websites and videos are not giving you erroneous content?

You trust some and distrust others at face value based on prior experience and what you want to believe. Sometimes you check after the fact and sometimes you don’t.

It’s the same exact thing with LLMs.

Re: Ask HN: How are you using AI to learn?

#25
I learned by building instead of studying. I'm a mechanical engineer working in finance, zero software background, and over the last couple of months I shipped a browser extension with an AI assistant writing the code while I made the product decisions.

The surprise was a) it has been much harder than I expected b) I ended up learning a lot. I thought it would may be pick up a bit of programming. But it was mostly everything around programming: how OAuth works, why my sign in kept expiring after an hour (a code deletion took out the token refresh route with it), how Stripe webhooks fail silently, why emails land in the Promotions tab, how Google decides what to crawl. Each broken thing forced me to understand a system I didn't know existed the week before. Learning to work with the AI model has also been a huge lesson on its own:)

Re: Ask HN: How are you using AI to learn?

#26
Nothing has changed wrt learning new things since LLM. We are the ones who still have to do the learning.

And the speed of learning is still limited by the individual's constraints: ability to focus for an extended time and chance to apply the new knowledge so the learning is reinforced.

Even before LLM's there was no shortage of knowledge and also the organization of them.

So I resort to same method I've been using ever since: reading books, writing code by hand, and sometimes, writing a blog post so I could refer things later.

Actually, I've added a further constraint on myself once I realised the above: to never learn anything from videos. Youtube is simply too distracting. Books are great, and coding by hand the stuff I'm trying to learn... I feel I need that experience to imprint things in my brain.

Re: Ask HN: How are you using AI to learn?

#27
I use it like a pokedex. Yesterday I was using it to know if I see swifts or swallows in the evening, and learned a bit more about them. For low-stakes questions that blogs cover well, it’s great. The stakes are low and it gives me a better starting point than shallow content.

It’s also good as a fuzzy dictionary/thesaurus/expression finder. It’s good for refining my writing skills.

I use it to learn German by writing the texts myself then comparing it with the AI’s version. It highlights subtle mistakes I make.

Re: Ask HN: How are you using AI to learn?

#28

AI, when used in an organized and structured way, is excellent for learning a language. For example: 1. Ask AI for the 10 most commonly used verbs in ordinary daily speech in language X. 2. Prompt AI: generate 4 short sentences for each of the 10 verbs at the A1 (beginner) level. Provide the sentences in .csv format compatible with the Anki flash card program. 3. Import .csv into Anki. Study your 40 cards. As you adv…

You can also use it to write and see the corrected version of your sentences. This got me to practice a lot more.

Re: Ask HN: How are you using AI to learn?

#29
I really want an AI tutor (ai learning harness) that I can give it a topic, it can synthesize information from sources, gauge my level, create lessons that I can read, give me exercises, track repetition optimal timings and track my progress.

I've noticed that for me it's much faster to learn by doing exercises targeting the exact thing you need than just trying to apply that to a much bigger chunk of work directly, especially for someone that's a bit of a failing perfectionist.

I was just looking for that and I saw https://github.com/THU-MAIC/OpenMAIC. I haven't tried it as I'm trying a few small experiments to see if I can create a curriculum for a framework with no docs.

The first naive one failed for multiple reasons but mostly because many guardrails are needed and we need a proper process that tracks too many things.

Re: Ask HN: How are you using AI to learn?

#30
post #29

I really want an AI tutor (ai learning harness) that I can give it a topic, it can synthesize information from sources, gauge my level, create lessons that I can read, give me exercises, track repetition optimal timings and track my progress. I've noticed that for me it's much faster to learn by doing exercises targeting the exact thing you need than just trying to apply that to a much bigger chunk of work directly,…

Maybe the new company from Andrew Ng is for you, though it doesn’t operate publicly yet: https://learnvector.ai/
Post reply on HN