Live data from Hacker News

Australia's social media ban has failed

reuters.com

11–20 of 134 posts

Re: Australia's social media ban has failed

#11
It has been banned for a few months. Hardly a failure.

It will be a failure if 10 year olds continue to join social media at the rate they have done so in the past.

It’s not likely to get 15 year olds who have been addicted for 5 years off it, anymore than smoking bans have any impact on teens who have been smoking or vaping for years.

Re: Australia's social media ban has failed

#12
I've said this to every single person who pushed for this.

"Imagine you're a teenager, and your parents and government tell you to not do something... What will happen?"

The answer is of course that they keep doing it anyhow. But hide it.

As an Aussie, and a parent. What I wanted was that the government mandate that in order for your website or app to launch in Australia, that if you want to allow kids between certain ages on the website/app. Then you need to have robust parental controls. Create family accounts where you can link parents and children, share whatever tracking/tracing you have with said parents and make it as good as you can. Mandate specific minimum controls based on what kind of type of app/website it is.

Put the control in the hands of the parents, and not this stupid one size fits all approach.

Re: Australia's social media ban has failed

#13
post #8
post #3

I wish I can promote this to the whole internet. this is not the way to control the internet :)

Anecdotally, all the parents I know and have discussed this with are desperate for this to work. How it should work I'm unsure in the big scheme of it, but we limit access to various things until age 18 here in Australia, and I think this is one long term battle that I believe the tech sector will lose.

I got bullied at school, but I'm not sure the solution would be to not let anyone in school talk to me :/

Re: Australia's social media ban has failed

#16

I've said this to every single person who pushed for this. "Imagine you're a teenager, and your parents and government tell you to not do something... What will happen?" The answer is of course that they keep doing it anyhow. But hide it. As an Aussie, and a parent. What I wanted was that the government mandate that in order for your website or app to launch in Australia, that if you want to allow kids between certai…

Won’t kids just make a new secret account that doesn’t belong to the family? Like you said, they will do it anyway

Re: Australia's social media ban has failed

#18

I've said this to every single person who pushed for this. "Imagine you're a teenager, and your parents and government tell you to not do something... What will happen?" The answer is of course that they keep doing it anyhow. But hide it. As an Aussie, and a parent. What I wanted was that the government mandate that in order for your website or app to launch in Australia, that if you want to allow kids between certai…

Nice idea but how are you going to prevent the kids from creating their own parent accounts while preserving people's privacy and without being too invasive?

Re: Australia's social media ban has failed

#19
post #8
post #3

I wish I can promote this to the whole internet. this is not the way to control the internet :)

Anecdotally, all the parents I know and have discussed this with are desperate for this to work. How it should work I'm unsure in the big scheme of it, but we limit access to various things until age 18 here in Australia, and I think this is one long term battle that I believe the tech sector will lose.

Rather than applying more bans, perhaps we should consider ways of living that allow parents to spend time talking to their children. Understanding what their days are like and the problems they face. For me much of this discussion and the excessive demand it takes from parents sounds more like a problem of the society as whole. That we are not having enough time to raise children since both parents are forced to work, best if they do it over 40 hours a week.

Re: Australia's social media ban has failed

#20
post #16

I've said this to every single person who pushed for this. "Imagine you're a teenager, and your parents and government tell you to not do something... What will happen?" The answer is of course that they keep doing it anyhow. But hide it. As an Aussie, and a parent. What I wanted was that the government mandate that in order for your website or app to launch in Australia, that if you want to allow kids between certai…

Won’t kids just make a new secret account that doesn’t belong to the family? Like you said, they will do it anyway

Still better than what we have now.
Post reply on HN