Live data from Hacker News

How to Do Great Work (2023)

paulgraham.com

41–50 of 76 posts

Re: How to Do Great Work (2023)

#41
post #33

In work, once you remove all that is unnecessary, wrong, and bad. Then what you are left with must be greatness.

What an empty and depressing world it would be if that was true.

If you let a manager, accountant, or politician decide what 'unnecessary', 'wrong', and 'bad' are. Then I would agree. But if you let an artist decide those things, then I think it would be fine.

Re: How to Do Great Work (2023)

#42

> At 7 it may seem excitingly ambitious to build huge things out of Lego, then at 14 to teach yourself calculus, till at 21 you're starting to explore unanswered questions in physics. Is this supposed to be relatable?

It used to be relatable, for nerds (like me.) Now the second two are 45 minute chat sessions in the eyes of most, I suppose.

Re: How to Do Great Work (2023)

#43
post #40

It's a nice post, with a lot of valuable insights. There is one that I disagree with though: "Never abandon the root node". There are plenty of instances that show that in reality this is not what happens, and in fact this is often a necessary step of reinventing yourself if things really aren't working for you. The mid-life crisis is a famous example of this, or even the quarter-life crisis. In some specific psychol…

FWIW existential crises can strike at any part of life, so naming them like that is outdated.

Thanks, I indeed meant existential crises, but it didn't hit me while I was writing.

Re: How to Do Great Work (2023)

#46

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That probably is what it means and I think there's still value in the analysis.

I agree. Though the article mentions work from people like Einstein, Copernicus, Darwin, etc. A far cry from the kind of work Y Combinator funds. It gives the post a comedic air to it. Perhaps if had given some more grounded examples that feel more relevant to the work he's done himself then the article would land more for me.

No one was really willing to fund any of these folks’ work until they were notable

Re: How to Do Great Work (2023)

#47

> At 7 it may seem excitingly ambitious to build huge things out of Lego, then at 14 to teach yourself calculus, till at 21 you're starting to explore unanswered questions in physics. Is this supposed to be relatable?

[deleted]

Re: How to Do Great Work (2023)

#48

When Paul Graham uses a phrase like "great work" I can't help but only consider it as being synonymous to "work that generates a big return for the investor" in his context of Y Combinator

What do you want it to be synonymous to? The people who've managed to do great work without generating large investment returns not that large. Compared to the number of ambitious people presently looking for advice it is small.

Re: How to Do Great Work (2023)

#49
post #48

When Paul Graham uses a phrase like "great work" I can't help but only consider it as being synonymous to "work that generates a big return for the investor" in his context of Y Combinator

What do you want it to be synonymous to? The people who've managed to do great work without generating large investment returns not that large. Compared to the number of ambitious people presently looking for advice it is small.

I disagree. There are millions of local activists that are improving the immediate lives of their communities in real impactful ways that never see the light of day. Starting after school programs or setting up mutual aid stations or community gardens or creating tenant unions, are all things any one of us can do to improve the lives of those around us.

If you're great work only consists of work that generates money, then you're neglecting the entire spectrum of the human experience.

Post reply on HN