Live data from Hacker News

Destroying a Community with a Gigantic "Clogged Vacuum Cleaner"

gizmodo.com

1–10 of 72 posts

Re: Destroying a Community with a Gigantic "Clogged Vacuum Cleaner"

#2
another link: https://futurism.com/artificial-intelligence/data-center-noi...

This particular datacenter was retrofitted into an existing industrial building, there was some sort of industrial metalworking factory there previously. Structure dates to 1972.

The houses are basically right across the street from it. The noise does sound annoying as hell. This seems like a basic failure in local permitting/zoning to allow something this noisy without a significant empty buffer zone to any residences.

edit: it's here: https://www.google.com/maps/place/Dowagiac,+MI+49047,+USA/@4...

Re: Destroying a Community with a Gigantic "Clogged Vacuum Cleaner"

#4
post #2

another link: https://futurism.com/artificial-intelligence/data-center-noi... This particular datacenter was retrofitted into an existing industrial building, there was some sort of industrial metalworking factory there previously. Structure dates to 1972. The houses are basically right across the street from it. The noise does sound annoying as hell. This seems like a basic failure in local permitting/zoning to allo…

wait, what was the sound from the industrial metalworking factory like?

Re: Destroying a Community with a Gigantic "Clogged Vacuum Cleaner"

#5
post #4
post #2

another link: https://futurism.com/artificial-intelligence/data-center-noi... This particular datacenter was retrofitted into an existing industrial building, there was some sort of industrial metalworking factory there previously. Structure dates to 1972. The houses are basically right across the street from it. The noise does sound annoying as hell. This seems like a basic failure in local permitting/zoning to allo…

wait, what was the sound from the industrial metalworking factory like?

It was likely quieter on average and likely not working during the night.

BTW, I grew up a few blocks away from a steel foundry, and it typically was emitting a low humming noise. It faded into the background and was not a problem. We could hear loud clangs from time to time, but not at night.

Re: Destroying a Community with a Gigantic "Clogged Vacuum Cleaner"

#6
post #4
post #2

another link: https://futurism.com/artificial-intelligence/data-center-noi... This particular datacenter was retrofitted into an existing industrial building, there was some sort of industrial metalworking factory there previously. Structure dates to 1972. The houses are basically right across the street from it. The noise does sound annoying as hell. This seems like a basic failure in local permitting/zoning to allo…

wait, what was the sound from the industrial metalworking factory like?

Presumably much less- the datacenter was apparently not that disruptive until they tore down the trees between it and the homes. The manufacturing facility may not have been 24/7 either

Re: Destroying a Community with a Gigantic "Clogged Vacuum Cleaner"

#7
Can someone explain why the new crop of datacenters are considered to be noisy?. I've been around the Wall Street datacenters in Jersey and they are basically the same as nondescript office buildings surrounded by a fence. The ones running on generators 24/7 are a problem but what is making the rest such an issue?

Re: Destroying a Community with a Gigantic "Clogged Vacuum Cleaner"

#8
post #4

Earlier quoted context omitted.

wait, what was the sound from the industrial metalworking factory like?

Presumably much less- the datacenter was apparently not that disruptive until they tore down the trees between it and the homes. The manufacturing facility may not have been 24/7 either

It likely didn't have the power requirements either. I'm just guessing here, but that sounds a lot like turbine whine. (I've heard them elsewhere, not to mention been around plenty of aircraft) My guess is that they brought one on site like they've done to other facilities to provide on-site power where the local grid isn't sufficient.

The pledge by their CEO to shut down crypto-mining equiptment feels like a deflection to me, because I don't think that's the source of the noise. It's the turbine generator, and switching to AI I don't think will change the power requirements any. We'll see I suppose.

Re: Destroying a Community with a Gigantic "Clogged Vacuum Cleaner"

#10

Can someone explain why the new crop of datacenters are considered to be noisy?. I've been around the Wall Street datacenters in Jersey and they are basically the same as nondescript office buildings surrounded by a fence. The ones running on generators 24/7 are a problem but what is making the rest such an issue?

I wrote this in another reply here, but from this article and others I've read on Space X's/Tesla's datacenters, it's the use of turbine generators that cause that enormous whine sound. (Note how similar it is to a jet engine.) I live in Ashburn, where we have datacenters all over the place. But none of them sound like this. At worst, we get a dull hum, much lower in volume, if the air handlers are working especially hard. But you need to be on top of them to hear that.

Ashburn has the infrastructure however. From what I'm reading, other places don't. So they bring in power on-site, and it seems to be much less regulated.

Post reply on HN