Live data from Hacker News

The Productivity Mirage

frantic.im

91–100 of 164 posts

Re: The Productivity Mirage

#91

The best artist I talked to in-person still uses Photoshop CS6. (And a Wacom without a display).

If it ain't broke, don't fix it. This is also why e.g. Java or Python isn't going anywhere anytime soon; they're fine, but there's armies of software developers who are well-versed in them. Newer languages may be "better" (by whatever measure), but experience trumps novelty.

Re: The Productivity Mirage

#92

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Did your AI post this comment? It seems to be getting downvoted so I'm wondering if the productivity is positive in this case or negative? The same happens with AI clearing your backlog

Nah the AI would have used proper grammar.

This is why AI will never replace human commenters.

...unless they are instructed to use poor grammar.

Actually I'm surprised they do use good grammar given how much poor grammar would be in their datasets. But that's probably why they don't just blindly train these things on internet comments.

Re: The Productivity Mirage

#93
post #81

There's an "expert trap" in here I think, at least this is something I experience. When you are good at something, it's a lot less effort to draw on that stuff, and you usually get instant easy positive feedback from non-experts. So, for an engineer, that's code and tools and the like, but also productivity systems and other abstract thinking modes that are useful in programming. On the flipside, actually thinking ab…

Just the other day I found out about a study that measured coding productivity. They compared CLI tooling to simple actions. The CLI users _felt_ more productive, but they were not.

Then again, the question is, if the simple action needs to be changed, how hard will that be?

Re: The Productivity Mirage

#94

Not entirely what's the point of the article is, because with AI I can clear my backlogs way faster than without it. How is this *not* real productivity gain?

The article isn't about AI though, it's about developers and their extensive coding setups being beaten by a guy in a plain editor. You're not personally under attack.

Re: The Productivity Mirage

#95

This is so important. I've seen so many fellow technologists (and I've skated this myself) obsess about their setup to the point that they're spending more time on that than the actual thing they're building. The whole "90% of my time as a coder is spent typing, so I should optimise my ability to type fast" is so, well, wrong. 90% of our time should be spent thinking, and most of that reading.

Occasionally it spills out to the codebase with the phenomenon of the Senior Linter Developer.

Re: The Productivity Mirage

#96

There's a bubble where VC backed companies are not producing anything that people are really using or paying for. So to justify their valuation they instead try to show just how productive they are. Surely if they are this busy and productive they must be worth something? (This could also explain the hype around AI which is all about "productivity/how" and nothing about "what") This article compares these kinds of co…

Not sure it’s a bubble so much as a story as old as time… signal hacking. Always has happened and always will

Re: The Productivity Mirage

#97

I do agree with the author, in spirit. Not necessarily the possible implication that winning hackathons requires you to not have OPPD (obsessive productivity personality disorder) :) I mean the "possible" indication that you have to be a non-productivity-chasing savant to be a great coder/etc. I stopped at this line > he was responsible for shipping Facebook Groups and wondered how can this be a compliment in any sha…

You need to see the facebook part in context, back then it was actually a hot place to be, the company and the platform, and devs were dedicated to leave a mark. Zuck was also perceived as the nerd buddy that disrupted the industry. Well until people found out he is a lizard.

Re: The Productivity Mirage

#99
Wait, where is the half of the article where he explains what Bob is doing differently ? I'm pretty sure everyone else in the hackathon was working on something "that mattered" (although, it's facebook, so "what matter" mean "putting more people in front of ads sprinkled with cat pictures while setting personnal data to dystopian law enforcement", or something like that.)

Re: The Productivity Mirage

#100
post #44

I think it's a false dichotomy. A good craftsman cares deeply about their tools. But the tools are a means to an end, not a toy. I have a bunch of small productivity tools I made to match my workflows: tiny shell scripts and functions, custom Emacs functions and settings, small tools to control windows placement, etc. Cumulatively I spent many days building and adjusting it. But when I need to jump into a task, thing…

I think you forgot to explain the false dichotomy part.

3rd paragraph
Post reply on HN