Live data from Hacker News

1,741 "informed" consents with one click? GDPR complaint filed

noyb.eu

11–20 of 110 posts

Re: 1,741 "informed" consents with one click? GDPR complaint filed

#11
post #8

Still wondering how "freely given, informed, specific and unambiguous" is fulfilled by "sure you can opt-out of tracking - by buying a premium subscription. Also, here are our 589 'partners' that all claim legitimate interest" but here we are.

Europe doesn’t enforce the law. Cookie banners are similarly pointless.

Re: 1,741 "informed" consents with one click? GDPR complaint filed

#12
Every law is made under some assumptions about the scale of things. For example, judiciary procedures were designed assuming certain number of active cases. Citizen services and bureaucracy around them is designed assuming some amount of work and staff size. Look at the US immigration / green card processes.

The designers of GDPR would have not expected thousands of partners sharing the data collected in a single click. The next review of the legislation would probably pick it up.

Re: 1,741 "informed" consents with one click? GDPR complaint filed

#13
post #6

I've seen similar on some android apps I think, where it will ask you if you consent to sharing data with partners or something similar. When you say no there's a huge list of partners you have to disable one by one, it's probably 15 minutes of work to go through them all. I can't think of an example app right now, but usually it's on first install or something like that. Not sure GDPR applies to apps though.

GDPR absolutely applies to apps, it applies to all manner of electronic and non-electronic means of data collection and processing.

The G stands for General, and the EU means it.

Re: 1,741 "informed" consents with one click? GDPR complaint filed

#14
post #8

Still wondering how "freely given, informed, specific and unambiguous" is fulfilled by "sure you can opt-out of tracking - by buying a premium subscription. Also, here are our 589 'partners' that all claim legitimate interest" but here we are.

Legitimate interest does not exist and is a loophole in the law which should be killed. You can challenge it but the authorities who should handle that are grossly underfunded.

Re: 1,741 "informed" consents with one click? GDPR complaint filed

#16
post #8

Still wondering how "freely given, informed, specific and unambiguous" is fulfilled by "sure you can opt-out of tracking - by buying a premium subscription. Also, here are our 589 'partners' that all claim legitimate interest" but here we are.

Europe doesn’t enforce the law. Cookie banners are similarly pointless.

They are useful as a deterrence system, can't decline in one click? I'm out thanks.

Re: 1,741 "informed" consents with one click? GDPR complaint filed

#17
My Samsung TV which I bought 8 years ago now suddenly asks me if it's okay they share data with their over 200 partners. They have the nerves to headline this with "protect your privacy". Generally not a big fan of EU policing but I wish somebody sued them over this.

> Improving Your Experience and Protecting Your Privacy on Samsung TV Plus

> Samsung and our 264 partners use information about you and your device in order to provide, analyse and improve the Samsung TV Plus app. This includes the processing of personal data such as unique IDs for personalised advertising.

Re: 1,741 "informed" consents with one click? GDPR complaint filed

#19
post #17

My Samsung TV which I bought 8 years ago now suddenly asks me if it's okay they share data with their over 200 partners. They have the nerves to headline this with "protect your privacy". Generally not a big fan of EU policing but I wish somebody sued them over this. > Improving Your Experience and Protecting Your Privacy on Samsung TV Plus > Samsung and our 264 partners use information about you and your device in o…

If I got a dollar for every person suckered into buying Samsung products…

But to stay on topic: never! connect your tv to the internet. My LG has been offline for around 5 years now after automatically installing unwanted apps. Since then, I run everything via an Apple TV 4K which works way better than LGs own software does anyway.

Re: 1,741 "informed" consents with one click? GDPR complaint filed

#20
post #17

My Samsung TV which I bought 8 years ago now suddenly asks me if it's okay they share data with their over 200 partners. They have the nerves to headline this with "protect your privacy". Generally not a big fan of EU policing but I wish somebody sued them over this. > Improving Your Experience and Protecting Your Privacy on Samsung TV Plus > Samsung and our 264 partners use information about you and your device in o…

[deleted]
Post reply on HN