Live data from Hacker News

Darktable

darktable.org

11–20 of 183 posts

Re: Darktable

#11
post #9

https://github.com/aurelienpierreeng/ansel

I haven't heard of either, but have been hoping for a replacement for Aperture for years. Having no knowledge of the history here, reading the `ansel` github page sounds like the developer has some animosity towards `darktable`. Does anyone have any experience with both? Or more knowledge of the history here?

There's also RawTherapee, which I found more usable than Darktable for reasons I don't recall.

Re: Darktable

#12
post #10
post #6

See also: https://ansel.photos/en/

Ansel is what Darktable 4.0 could have been if it didn’t die of feature creep . Between 2020 and 2023, Darktable has suffered massive code additions of peripheral features, often ill-coded, poorly designed and penalizing usability, performance and maintenance. Too many workarounds failed to fix bugs, but layered new problems on top of legacy code : welcome in maintenance nightmare. They got beef!

Right?! And the rest of the README continues like that. Must be some juicy history here

Re: Darktable

#15
I highly recommend people try out Capture One. After using Lightroom for years, switching to Capture One a few years ago felt like someone turned the lights on. Far and away the best photo and media mangement software I've ever used by at least two orders of magnitude, and reasonalbe license cost and generous free tier.

Re: Darktable

#16
Darktable is fantastic, and their darktable-cli is really clutch as a photographer turned SWE.

If coming from lightroom or the likes it does take some dedicated learning to adapt to the "Darktable" ways of doing things. Deceptively similar UI, yet very different approaches and naming.

Darktable is however, bad at photograpy organization and collections. Something Lightroom shines at.

Built many processes around it for my own post-processing needs.

Re: Darktable

#17

Ditched Adobe Lightroom 10+ years ago in favour of Darktable and never looked back. It was the first FOSS software, which showed me how green the grass can get.

Pretty sure Darktable only supports openCL and not Metal for MacOS.

OpenCL is unsupported for M1/2/3/4/5, which makes RAW file processing, batch workflows, basically everything, unusably slow.

Unless something has changed in the past few months, Darktable is dead on MacOS with no fix in sight.

Re: Darktable

#18

I highly recommend people try out Capture One. After using Lightroom for years, switching to Capture One a few years ago felt like someone turned the lights on. Far and away the best photo and media mangement software I've ever used by at least two orders of magnitude, and reasonalbe license cost and generous free tier.

Private equity owed proprietary Mac and Windows exclusive. No thanks.

Re: Darktable

#19
this was my main way of managing and processing my RAWs for years until i started using DxO PhotoLab. darktable is an excellent way to learn how to start editing IMO because it simplifies settings a bit less than other tools, is free, and from my experience has better denoise/tone mapping modules out of the box than RawTherapee. for my needs the library/lightroom was also very intuitive and lightweight.

Re: Darktable

#20
post #13

https://github.com/aurelienpierreeng/ansel

Is the last release on GitHub from 2022 or is it me?

Not just you - from ansel.photos:

>Ansel has not published a stable release yet and there is no ETA for one : a new release is published when the list of all bugs have been cleared, so we know the software and stable. So far, Ansel only publishes revisions, which are intermediate states of the sourcecode.

Post reply on HN