Live data from Hacker News

Schools are adding pepper-spraying drones to help combat active shooters

washingtonpost.com

31–40 of 118 posts

Re: Schools are adding pepper-spraying drones to help combat active shooters

#31
post #13
post #4

Genuinely impressed the lengths they’ll go to in the US order to avoid doing something about guns. Next stop - magic incantations to bestow bulletproof status on schoolkids

"Thoughts and prayers". It's always "thoughts and prayers" and invoking an inaginary "good guy with a gun". Can it get much more magical/mystical/performative than that?

Given an active shooter threats, what is the solution if not a good guy with a gun?

Re: Schools are adding pepper-spraying drones to help combat active shooters

#32
post #4

Genuinely impressed the lengths they’ll go to in the US order to avoid doing something about guns. Next stop - magic incantations to bestow bulletproof status on schoolkids

Pretty easy to make glib comments like that. How do you propose the problem be addressed? The Constitution as written makes banning guns a non-starter. So amending the Constitution is step 1, and a big step it is. 3/4 states ratifying is a non-trivial threshold. And then what? There are already more guns than people in the US. Going to confiscate them all? Good luck.

Even Australia, the poster child for instituting draconian restrictions in response to tragedy, has vast numbers of illegal (and legal) weapons still in civilian hands. So clearly that isn't the answer.

So I want to know what your easy solution is.

Re: Schools are adding pepper-spraying drones to help combat active shooters

#34
post #13

Earlier quoted context omitted.

"Thoughts and prayers". It's always "thoughts and prayers" and invoking an inaginary "good guy with a gun". Can it get much more magical/mystical/performative than that?

Given an active shooter threats, what is the solution if not a good guy with a gun?

Why are you assuming active shooter threats need to exist to begin with? There’s only one country it regularly happens in.

Re: Schools are adding pepper-spraying drones to help combat active shooters

#35

The real question here isn't "why are we sacrificing the education of the next generation to buy tools that make us feel safe but (logically, statistically) will only prevent one in a million child deaths?" ... the answer to that is a Simpsons meme ("won't someone think of the children?"). The real question is ... who is stoking the irrational fear in the first place, and how do they benefit by doing so?

What are you talking about? Schools are targets for shooters. Sad but certainly not fake.

Re: Schools are adding pepper-spraying drones to help combat active shooters

#36
post #4

Genuinely impressed the lengths they’ll go to in the US order to avoid doing something about guns. Next stop - magic incantations to bestow bulletproof status on schoolkids

You could ban guns completely and you’d still have to deal with active shooters. There are 500M guns in the USA. Those dont just disappear. Its idiotic not to harden targets. The best way to do that’s debatable, but schools should be hardened.

They should give every student a gun at this point (/s because I feel like someone would agree with me).

Edit: everyone should also wear a bulletproof vest at minimum. Desks should be equipped with reactive armor to defend against anti-tank warheads. A Phalanx C-RAM will be installed on the roof next to the AC units.

Re: Schools are adding pepper-spraying drones to help combat active shooters

#37

This idiotic idea that must have come from a Gemini chat session will backfire in a real incident. Of course the perpetrator will know about the drones and be prepared for them, e.g. with a face mask. Conveniently for them, the pepper spray will confuse and incapacitate their targets, leading to more casualties. If you're going to accept not being able to take guns away from the perpetrators, the only thing that will…

Whether they will be effective or not I dont know. But something tells me you dont know more about this than the people deploying them.

Re: Schools are adding pepper-spraying drones to help combat active shooters

#40
post #13

Earlier quoted context omitted.

"Thoughts and prayers". It's always "thoughts and prayers" and invoking an inaginary "good guy with a gun". Can it get much more magical/mystical/performative than that?

Given an active shooter threats, what is the solution if not a good guy with a gun?

Ever see Takeshi's Castle?
Post reply on HN