Live data from Hacker News

Introducing the New Yahoo Mail

ycorpblog.com

41–50 of 78 posts

Re: Introducing the New Yahoo Mail

#41
post #22
post #11

I'm really sorry to say, but: too late. Literally 99% of those I know used to be a Yahoo Mail user (Y! Messenger still biggish in Romania, though loosing ground quickly to social networks), but a big part of them are using GMail now. Big, ugly ads and an "anti"-spam engine that makes SpamAssassin look good; what's there to come back to? Plus everyone has a smartphone/tablet now and what's that without a Google/GMail…

I was very reluctant to switch from Yahoo to Gmail in the first few years of Gmail. But eventually I did it, and couldn't believe how much better Gmail was at spam filtering than Yahoo - like an order of magnitude better. I never looked back. Recently I stopped using Yahoo Messenger, too, because they've been adding a lot of nonsense to it lately.

I had a long chat with an engineer from the Yahoo spam team about why Gmail was better, and this was his take: When Gmail started off in beta, the mail filters were amazing. They were trained with a large corpus of Google's employee mail, skewing everything to a technical subject matter and a tightly knit network of contacts.

When Gmail hit general availability, the quality of filters was not what average users expected. Things would get flagged simply because Grandma was not in the trusted circle of silicon valley.

Eventually they bought Postini, both to boost corporate email business, but also to source a spam filter that had been battle tested across large consumer mail installs.

Re: Introducing the New Yahoo Mail

#43
Anyone here who uses Yahoomail? Just curious. I stopped using them long back when they charged for some features while GMail still had them for free. Anyway, could anyone let us know how the new version is? I think my account has been deactivated due to inactivity (another irritating 'feature').

Their homepage doesn't clearly explain what has gotten better, and if it all, it is better than GMail. So would love to hear some feedback!

Re: Introducing the New Yahoo Mail

#44
Still no archive button, still get spam, folders are mutually exclusive... Has nobody learned from GMail?

EDIT: Just unsure about what they added... looks like a standard webmail interface?

Re: Introducing the New Yahoo Mail

#46
Went to mail.yahoo.com to check my mail there (for the first time in months.)

The landing page had nothing to do with mail and everything to do with piles of crap that Yahoo wants me to look at.

Congratulations Marissa, that's the last time I'll even bother looking when you say "Look! We've changed."

Next.

Re: Introducing the New Yahoo Mail

#47
post #44

Still no archive button, still get spam, folders are mutually exclusive... Has nobody learned from GMail? EDIT: Just unsure about what they added... looks like a standard webmail interface?

Hmm... I've learned from GMail. I choose a mail interface with a clear delete (instead of the nebulous "archive") and the ease of mutually exclusive folders instead of the lack of specificity of overlapping tags, and I got just as much spam in Gmail as I did in Y!.

So, I guess lots of folks have learned from GMail... that GMail is not really right for everyone. If you love tags, cool, but there's something to be said for email that works like one expects email to work.

Wouldn't mind better searching in Y! mail, however; Google did do a good job with that, not surprisingly.

Re: Introducing the New Yahoo Mail

#48
post #42

They need to rebrand Yahoo Mail. Like MS did with Hotmail -> Outlook. Nobody wants to have @yahoo.com. That's embarrassing in 2012. Or 2006 for that matter.

Really? By "nobody" you mean us, right? Most people still use yahoo and hotmail. [1]

[1] "Yahoo! Mail was the second largest web-based email service with 310 million users as of October 2011, and the most popular webmail service in the United States" - http://news.cnet.com/8301-13772_3-20114975-52/microsoft-aimi...

Post reply on HN