Live data from Hacker News

Stolen Buttons

anatolyzenkov.com

121–130 of 168 posts

Re: Stolen Buttons

#121

I may have missed one by looking at this huge dump, but NONE of the "buttons" I saw there actually looked/felt like a button. Something I can feel that I press it down and it gives proper visual feedback, like a little 3D effect. I'm old-school. :)

https://jdan.github.io/98.css/

Nice! That Windows 95/98 GUI design wasn't the most beautiful ever made, but it was quite usable. You never had trouble telling what was what.

Re: Stolen Buttons

#123

When did we stop making buttons that actually look like a button? The bas-relief era of UI design now feels like a golden era, and the early "Aqua" versions of Mac OS X the ultimate evolution. Everything since then feels like we're regressing. The "add comment" button for this comment is literally a solid blue roundrect. It's not even obvious that it's clickable.

The "when" isn't a mystery or gradual in the slightest—we have concrete dates.

The death of the button occurred on October 21, 2010, when Microsoft released Windows Phone 7 to the international market, beginning the Metro UI era.

Apple wouldn't catch up until September 17, 2014, when they unveiled iOS 7, ditching Steve Jobs's beloved skeuomorphism in favor of Jony Ive's signature flat style.

Google followed up on November 12, 2014, with Android 5.0 Lollipop's introduction of Material Design—arguably the least flat of the three, though it wouldn't stay that way forever.

Re: Stolen Buttons

#124

When did we stop making buttons that actually look like a button? The bas-relief era of UI design now feels like a golden era, and the early "Aqua" versions of Mac OS X the ultimate evolution. Everything since then feels like we're regressing. The "add comment" button for this comment is literally a solid blue roundrect. It's not even obvious that it's clickable.

It's all because of "UX designers" who have to justify their continued existence by constantly finding new things to change (break). If computers several decades ago had more than enough power to render button-looking buttons, there's no other excuse for the sad state of UI today.

Re: Stolen Buttons

#125
post #56

I have noticed on occasion websites with a missing button. Now I know what happened. Finally, closure.

It'd be funny if there's a global state shared with everyone who has the button stealer extension installed: so if I stole a button, it'd be missing when you visit the page.

Re: Stolen Buttons

#127

MEMORANDUM FOR THE HEADS OF EXECUTIVE DEPARTMENTS AND AGENCIES SUBJECT: Adversarial Distillation of Frontier UI Buttons The United States leads the world in user interface (UI) technologies. That lead reflects decades of foundational design research, bold aesthetic risk-taking, and millions of hours of front-end development. Our button leadership drives click-through rates, strengthens conversion funnels, and advance…

You forgot to somehow blame it on Biden

Re: Stolen Buttons

#128
post #105

When did we stop making buttons that actually look like a button? The bas-relief era of UI design now feels like a golden era, and the early "Aqua" versions of Mac OS X the ultimate evolution. Everything since then feels like we're regressing. The "add comment" button for this comment is literally a solid blue roundrect. It's not even obvious that it's clickable.

What a button look like to you? Blue roundrect sure says button to me.

Because you never saw a button in your life

Re: Stolen Buttons

#129
post #84

I may have missed one by looking at this huge dump, but NONE of the "buttons" I saw there actually looked/felt like a button. Something I can feel that I press it down and it gives proper visual feedback, like a little 3D effect. I'm old-school. :)

I unironically prefer the UI of old Bootstrap: https://getbootstrap.com/1.0.0/ They may have peaked with 2.0: https://getbootstrap.com/2.0.2/

Wow I totally forgot how great 2 was, how did we regressed from that? The buttons are so satisfying

Re: Stolen Buttons

#130
post #84

I may have missed one by looking at this huge dump, but NONE of the "buttons" I saw there actually looked/felt like a button. Something I can feel that I press it down and it gives proper visual feedback, like a little 3D effect. I'm old-school. :)

I unironically prefer the UI of old Bootstrap: https://getbootstrap.com/1.0.0/ They may have peaked with 2.0: https://getbootstrap.com/2.0.2/

I love those versions, they were really innovative at the time.
Post reply on HN