Live data from Hacker News

Firefox Containers Preview

blog.mozilla.org

111–120 of 136 posts

Re: Firefox Containers Preview

#111
Please tell me they didn’t break something crucial to my workflow. The containers extension has been languishing for years now. The fact that the first new thing I hear about the feature is in a blog post does not bode well.

Re: Firefox Containers Preview

#113
post #19

Multi-Account Containers paired with Container Proxy allows for some really cool setups. I especially like the options to use socks proxies. Hope they will add proper proxy support later.

Same here, probably my most used feature. Really useful if you route all of your traffic through a VPN by default, but you want to selectively route something outside of it. Just route it through a socks proxy running in your homelab.

Re: Firefox Containers Preview

#114
post #19

Multi-Account Containers paired with Container Proxy allows for some really cool setups. I especially like the options to use socks proxies. Hope they will add proper proxy support later.

> the options to use socks proxies I pair it with wireproxy [0]. This way you can assign any Wireguard-capable VPN for specific containers. It's extremely useful. [0] https://github.com/windtf/wireproxy

This is great, previously I was just using every wireguard tunnel as a traditional interface and hosting a socks proxy on the network on the other end.

Re: Firefox Containers Preview

#115

I use profiles for this, I wonder what the tradeoffs are between the two approaches. I've actually been thinking about building some tools to make it easier to create and manage profiles on the fly. For me I really think profiles are better since the boundaries are harder - there's no worry about accidentally hitting the "log in with Google" button and clearly identifying myself to a site or similar, because I read t…

I have been using profiles for years in Chrome/Vivaldi for similar reasons. I do a lot of web app development and this is extremely useful for testing. In fact I have 10 different profiles on one of my setups so that I can easily simulate multiple users accessing the same app and each profile can remember its own passwords, settings, cookies, and session data, etc. Firefox’s MAC seems like it’s not quite as isolated as a separate profile but I can see how it would be useful for end-users who want to have different “identities” in the same profile.

Re: Firefox Containers Preview

#116
Please Firefox, just implement workspaces. I'm tired of 10 windows, that I have created to segregate for each type of browsing, launching at startup and then me accidentally closing one and again having to manually add the tabs back. Don't even need to make it mandatory, just make it optional. Vivaldi has spoiled me with this and it is very hard to switch to another browser that doesn't have it.

Excellent job making containers native. Just go one more step.

Re: Firefox Containers Preview

#117
post #43

I'm curious about Mozilla's seeming shift in strategy (possibly it was awhile ago and I overlooked it): For a long time, with relatively limited (compared to Google and Apple) development resources, they focused on minimizing upkeep and technical debt. They added and maintained features appealing to the vast majority, the non-technical users, and left the rest to extensions. Now I'm seeing geek and power user favorit…

Their previous strategy of being a nominally more ethical Chrome clone was a slow suicide.

Re: Firefox Containers Preview

#118

Please Firefox, just implement workspaces. I'm tired of 10 windows, that I have created to segregate for each type of browsing, launching at startup and then me accidentally closing one and again having to manually add the tabs back. Don't even need to make it mandatory, just make it optional. Vivaldi has spoiled me with this and it is very hard to switch to another browser that doesn't have it. Excellent job making…

There is functionality to reopen the last closed window, and also a keyboard shortcut for it. IIRC, the shortcut is Ctrl+Shift+N (on Windows and Linux).

Re: Firefox Containers Preview

#119

Please Firefox, just implement workspaces. I'm tired of 10 windows, that I have created to segregate for each type of browsing, launching at startup and then me accidentally closing one and again having to manually add the tabs back. Don't even need to make it mandatory, just make it optional. Vivaldi has spoiled me with this and it is very hard to switch to another browser that doesn't have it. Excellent job making…

I'm not a Vivaldi user, but just based off their feature page, you might be interested to check out some of the features/extensions:

1. Firefox's native tab groups [^1]

2. Sidebery's panels (if you don't mind vertical tabs) [^2]

3. Simple Tab Groups [^3]

[1]: https://www.firefox.com/en-US/features/tab-groups/

[2]: https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/sidebery/

[3]: https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/simple-tab-gr...

Re: Firefox Containers Preview

#120
post #102

Containers are really awesome and I thought Mozilla would jump on them. But nothing ever happened they are barebones and there is so much more that could be added. The only thing we have is taking them from an extension to in-browser which changes nothing for the user.

Hopefully this is a signal that they are starting to take it more seriously and will add more futures.
Post reply on HN