Live data from Hacker News

What if we made advertising illegal?

simone.org

31–40 of 90 posts

Re: What if we made advertising illegal?

#31

I LOVE this idea and advocate for it in private convos all the time. Banning ads and enabling (micro-)payments for accessing content that is currently ad-supported would be an unimaginable game-changer.

Definitely not. I don't want to pay for every single website I visit for example, it creates a chilling effect overall as to my want of visiting many different sites.

Re: What if we made advertising illegal?

#32
post #30

The best concert I ever went to was one I only knew about from a TV commercial. Somewhere along the way I started blocking ads and commercials aggressively and in hindsight I've noticed that (for example) there's fewer movies/concerts I'm seeing because I've cut off a mechanism for learning what's out there for subjects I'm not in the habit of actively researching. After 30 years I've stopped watching baseball altoge…

> I accidentally let myself get too extreme about deciding that ads are evil. Not surprising I regret that, given the nature of extremism.

Sounds like a good argumentation to consume some cocaine.

Not consuming it at all is just too extreme

Re: What if we made advertising illegal?

#33

I LOVE this idea and advocate for it in private convos all the time. Banning ads and enabling (micro-)payments for accessing content that is currently ad-supported would be an unimaginable game-changer.

Definitely not. I don't want to pay for every single website I visit for example, it creates a chilling effect overall as to my want of visiting many different sites.

1) Not every single site is displaying ads, e.g. Codeberg.org

2) aren't you paying indirectly anyways? (With only a part of the revenue actually landing in the bags of the operator of the site - another part is used to fund Google Chrome and people who design ads)

Re: What if we made advertising illegal?

#34

Cities have banned billboards. Sao Paulo did it, so did parts of London: https://99percentinvisible.org/article/clean-city-law-secret... Hard to quantify the benefits, but I think anyone other than advertisers would say it's a vast improvement. I cannot objectively prove that these cities, public spaces are more beautiful without ads, but all of us know that it is true. Then again you have places like times square wh…

A happy middle ground might be a designated billboard zone (e.g. Times Square), with billboards outside a certain area being outlawed, or restricted by size.

But the Devil is always in the details: how would businesses advertise their presence? A sign is an ad of sorts, and regulations would have to be drawn up for every type of sign that might exist: size, wording, color, etc, lest it be deemed too "advertise-y."

How about mom-and-pop businesses or sole proprietors? Would it be illegal to tack your business card to the local laundromat bulletin board? All these questions, and many more, would have to be answered in the quest to fully (or nearly fully) ban ads.

Re: What if we made advertising illegal?

#35

I despise advertising, but anecdotally, I can think of three ads in the past week that informed me about products I didn’t know existed but would enjoy. I also learned about multiple new games releasing, sporting events that were happening, etc. The claim that ads are not at all informative is incorrect. That being said, I also block as many ads as possible from my life, so the few I actively notice tend to be more n…

You could have a service that lets you look for promotional information, only when you want.

And lets you configure it from a completely random choice of ad, to something tailored for what you're really looking for at the moment (as opposed to the surveillance industry trying to read your mind).

If you steal the idea please give me a slice of the revenue xD (although it would be best if it were not for profit, so that there could be a single one)

Re: What if we made advertising illegal?

#36
post #5
post #2

I used to know one of the great ad execs from Mama Bell and he told me nothing happens in this world until a person decides to trade a dollar for something. How do they decide such things? How do people become aware of what things are available for purchase? Another thing he said was that they knew half of their ad spend was "wasted" on people who would never buy what you have to sell. The feeling I get from the auth…

Flip side of it is - I love not seeing advertisements, of any type. Sponsorblock and uBlock Origin makes YouTube a whole different experience. Locally backed-up or on-demand TV shows are so much more bingeable than the ones on DVR. I love watching livestreams and not being pulled aside for a 30 second sponsored interruption. It makes me giddy with excitement paying for software and media that does not have any advert…

I've almost never used YouTube with ads, and I'd argue that it's instead insane to have long ads breaking your experience so often.

Of course it's a costly service that needs to at least recover the costs, but yeah not with full-screen ads please.

Re: What if we made advertising illegal?

#37

I despise advertising, but anecdotally, I can think of three ads in the past week that informed me about products I didn’t know existed but would enjoy. I also learned about multiple new games releasing, sporting events that were happening, etc. The claim that ads are not at all informative is incorrect. That being said, I also block as many ads as possible from my life, so the few I actively notice tend to be more n…

Every idea taken to extreme becomes unbearable. I ask friends for recommendations on what to read or watch, and I enjoy doing that. But if they would follow me around everywhere and keep suggesting things non stop purely because they make money out of it then they would stop being my friends very quickly.

Re: What if we made advertising illegal?

#40
It'll get replaced with something even more annoying that isn't called advertising but is functionally identical.

People make things then talk about them. It's normal.

A careful read of this piece should show you why advertising was invented in the first place and why it's fundamental to commerce.

Unless you want to go back to buying from your neighbor or buying only what your limited circle of friends can recommend you?

Post reply on HN