Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: Palmier Pro – Open-source macOS video editor built for AI

github.com

21–30 of 47 posts

Re: Show HN: Palmier Pro – Open-source macOS video editor built for AI

#21

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It makes sense! We are still early in experimenting the pricing and would want to reduce user's overhead in thinking about pricing/credits as much as possible.

I get that too! Rooting for y'all, it looks amazing and I'll definitely grab a month once I have enough ideas enough :)

Just wanted to chime in to specify that credits are only for the AI generation and built in chat features. The editor is free to use if you connect it to your existing agents!

Re: Show HN: Palmier Pro – Open-source macOS video editor built for AI

#22
Nice project. I’m building a similar project. It’s open source too.

https://github.com/DonkeyUseCorp/Donkey

It’s mostly a web app with a native swift companion app to access local resources like TTS, file storage and video rendering.

I arrived at the same conclusion as you; every app should have AI chat. Just give it full access to the app like a real user. I found that users prefer talking to the AI when editing vs clicking around.

Re: Show HN: Palmier Pro – Open-source macOS video editor built for AI

#23

This looks great! Have you thought about dropping the 'subscription'-part and 'just' selling credits instead? Here's my thinking as a SaaS founder: when I launch a product, I don't need a video every month. So a monthly pricing makes me do this little calculation every time: "do I need a video this month? nah. Then I'll wait. I lose the early-bird price, but I still net out cheaper." And since there's no yearly optio…

I feel the same way too. I also open sourced a video editor. It's free to use and you can buy credits whenever you want to access AI specific features.

Re: Show HN: Palmier Pro – Open-source macOS video editor built for AI

#25

I've been following Marcos's youtube channel and it's so great to see that they've finally found their thing. Looks like an awesome product that people actually want. Well done.

From a struggling bootstrapper, could you please elaborate:

> it's so great to see that they've finally found their thing

Re: Show HN: Palmier Pro – Open-source macOS video editor built for AI

#27
Great project! have you considered giving the agents code-based video rendering like MoviePy or Remotion? Since LLMs are mostly trained on texts and code maybe for edits use code based approach and for complex scenes fallback for seedance, elevenlabs mcp or connectors

Re: Show HN: Palmier Pro – Open-source macOS video editor built for AI

#28

This looks great! Have you thought about dropping the 'subscription'-part and 'just' selling credits instead? Here's my thinking as a SaaS founder: when I launch a product, I don't need a video every month. So a monthly pricing makes me do this little calculation every time: "do I need a video this month? nah. Then I'll wait. I lose the early-bird price, but I still net out cheaper." And since there's no yearly optio…

I feel the same way too. I also open sourced a video editor. It's free to use and you can buy credits whenever you want to access AI specific features.

What's the name of it?

Re: Show HN: Palmier Pro – Open-source macOS video editor built for AI

#29
> Most work in the editing workflow is more mechanical than creative.

I really disagree with this. Maybe once you start producing videos with a formula, it's true. But if you stop to think about it, a lot of things that people consider gruntwork hide little decision in them that subtly influence the creative process.

A lot of tech-minded people don't understand this about art but after editing tens of thousands of photos and over 300 videos, I can't say that there is much mechanical in the process. By automating parts of the process with AI you do hide some of the subtle decisions that might even be subconscious and therefore it still destroys creativity.

I'm sad when someones makes a product like this. Because what happens is that creativity is claimed as something important when really in the long run it is just suppressed for the sake of more efficiency.

I don't expect many people to care to understand this because there's $$$ in front of them and technologically-minded people get a dopamine hit from tech but that's the way it is and you can't hide from that truth. Sooner or later such things as this will be seen as an immense folly.

Post reply on HN