Live data from Hacker News

The Corporate Creep of Plex: Why it may be time to move to Jellyfin

reprodev.com

31–40 of 110 posts

Re: The Corporate Creep of Plex: Why it may be time to move to Jellyfin

#31

Jellyfin 12 should be able to use a Plex media library using Plex naming conventions, no renaming required. This will reduce the switching workload, and you can run both services at the same time whilst trying out Jellyfin.

Huh. I was able to run Plex alongside Jellyfin on my library no issues.

Re: The Corporate Creep of Plex: Why it may be time to move to Jellyfin

#32
post #7

As someone who was late to the game, I never even considered Plex and have been totally satisfied with Jellyfin. Is there anything better about Plex?

* Accelerated TV support - Jellyfin sometimes struggles to play media that plex has no problem with. This is across an old Apple TV and an oldish LG tv.

* general Tv support - no Jellyfin app on Samsung TVs (at least older ones)

* General challenges to get things to start - it never worked for me out-of-the-box

* slightly weird sign in flows because it’s all self-hosted (have to first install a mobile app to make signing in on TV app smoother unless you happen to have your computer and TV side by side)

* weird issues with things suddenly stopping to work: DLNA was working but without any changes I can think of on my end it no longer works

* weird dlna support - at least with iOS VLC it didn’t work smoothly - like VLC sometimes wouldn’t see the announcement or something and I’d have to reset. Could be a VLC issue but don’t recall similar problems with Plex

So basically Plex is a smoother, easier to use experience that typically “just works” without issues.

Re: The Corporate Creep of Plex: Why it may be time to move to Jellyfin

#33
The corporate creep was already felt when years ago they released the PlexAmp audio player. Good player but to display lyrics you have to open the menu and select “Show Lyrics”, two clicks every time. Every time, for every track. When the next track is playing lyrics display is automatically turned off. It is not remembered either, you go back to previous track and have to click click them menu gain. This is because they have to pay a licence and rather save $100 per month by inconveniencing their user base. you see, it’s extra work to click the menu every time so you won’t be viewing lyrics. Profit! And no, if your file already has lyrics that doesn’t matter, you still have to open to view it every time, for each track.

Re: The Corporate Creep of Plex: Why it may be time to move to Jellyfin

#35
post #7

As someone who was late to the game, I never even considered Plex and have been totally satisfied with Jellyfin. Is there anything better about Plex?

Plex has better client support. But Jellyfin being open source client support is catching up quickly.

Re: The Corporate Creep of Plex: Why it may be time to move to Jellyfin

#36
post #34

Does jellyfin offer intro/outro skipping like plex pass does? And hardware accelerated transcoding? The only thing keeping me on plex is my lifetime plex pass, and family inertia.

yes (through a plugin), and yes (if you set it up)

Re: The Corporate Creep of Plex: Why it may be time to move to Jellyfin

#37
post #25

I would absolutely love to cut to jellyfin, but for the TV integration. Last time i looked samsung TV's (which most of my fam use) dont have a decent client. Has that changed?

Check here: https://github.com/jellyfin/jellyfin-tizen/issues/222#issuec...

hmmm looks like its heading in the right direction.. very promising.

Re: The Corporate Creep of Plex: Why it may be time to move to Jellyfin

#38
post #28
post #8

Should an Emby premiere user consider moving to Jellyfin?

I have found Emby to be a nice middle ground between Plex and Jellyfin. It has more polish and refinement than Jellyfin but doesn't have the obtrusive ads and whatnot that Plex offers. Client support is also great. Jellyfin is still quickly gaining ground but Emby is still my media server of choice for now.

>Jellyfin but doesn't have the obtrusive ads and whatnot that Plex offers

I'm a Plex user who's been thinking about trying Jellyfin out, largely in response to some recent UI changes I dislike but... what Plex ads? I don't have any on my android apps, on Roku installs, or on my parent's SmartTV, and none of my other users have ever mentioned any ads to me. (If I was seeing ads, Jellyfin would become "take some time off work and get it working now".)

I know I've disabled everything except my own libraries, so it's possible there's a setting somewhere that allows them, but if so, I disabled it so long ago I honestly don't remember ever seeing any. Are other Plex users seeing ads? Was it after a recent update that I may have skipped, maybe?

Re: The Corporate Creep of Plex: Why it may be time to move to Jellyfin

#40
I tried to evaluate Jellyfin recently but dropped it pretty quick. Live (OTA) television is barely a thought (seems to be acknowledged that no dev uses it), and you have to figure out a source for guide data. I have complaints with Plex's implementation, but it's a lot smoother than Jellyfin.
Post reply on HN