Live data from Hacker News

Introducing selfie for sign-in: a new way to access your Google Account

blog.google

31–40 of 117 posts

Re: Introducing selfie for sign-in: a new way to access your Google Account

#31
post #10

The fact that most people will love this is depressing.

I wonder. I know a lot of people who hate this kind of thing, but because they don't want to be "tinfoil hat oddballs" they just keep quiet.

I think it would be nice to applaud or support people who think this way.

Instead of ridiculing these folks, or using semi-apologist "you're not the target market" type comments, it would be nice to say "good for you" or support them in some other way.

Re: Introducing selfie for sign-in: a new way to access your Google Account

#32

Your Google Account holds a lot of valuable information, from cherished photos to important emails and documents. Stuff like this is why I and many other people are going out of our way to make this no longer the case.

"Be a shame if you couldn't access them any more...

Verify identity to continue"

Re: Introducing selfie for sign-in: a new way to access your Google Account

#33
I'm surprised how fast this came from the whole "give us your hand" bullshit with reCaptcha not being that long ago.

https://docs.cloud.google.com/recaptcha/docs/hand-gesture-ve...

"Google analyzes one or more videos of a user's hand as they perform various actions or gestures. The video is processed to extract hand landmark data, which includes 21 hand-knuckle coordinates."

Re: Introducing selfie for sign-in: a new way to access your Google Account

#34
This already exists and is called FaceID and doesn't have the same privacy risks since the face check is done locally to allow the user to use the passkey to authenticate.

>Your selfie video is encrypted at rest

All data nowadays is encrypted at rest. That doesn't really matter since someone stealing a hard drive from Google with your information on it will never happen. The more likely risk is Google decrypts it and then sends it somewhere it shouldn't go and potentially trained into some AI system.

Re: Introducing selfie for sign-in: a new way to access your Google Account

#35
post #25

If there were a Doomsday Clock for how close we are to "please drink verification can" ( https://files.catbox.moe/eqg0b2.png ), scientists would now move it to 3 minutes to midnight.

We're zero minutes away from "some scammer said they were google and I had to show them my butthole to login".

Re: Introducing selfie for sign-in: a new way to access your Google Account

#36

Meanwhile google has been locking out and closing the gmail accounts of people, myself included, that signed up before a phone number was required. If you don't log into your account for ~a year or so they will lock it and demand you log in. Which you can do, and you can even input the 2FA code, but it still won't let you log in because it says "there's not enough information to prove this is your account" despite ha…

> The only way to prevent deletion is to add a completely new, never before there phone number.

Just happened to me. They "confirmed" it was me by getting a phone number they'd never seen before, that didn't belong to the false name on the account, and that I'd refused to give them for like 20 years. If anything, the fact that I eventually agreed to give them a phone number under duress was evidence that it wasn't me.

> despite logging in literally dozens of times.

Despite logging in literally thousands of times. I went in and deleted almost everything. Email now considered harmful. I'll feel better once they're locking me out of an empty account.

The problem is that everything in life requires a persistent email address, and hates email addresses that aren't on a whitelisted domain. The choice is between having some major provider, or not being able to pay your taxes online or log into your health insurance website. The fence is closing.

Re: Introducing selfie for sign-in: a new way to access your Google Account

#39

Your Google Account holds a lot of valuable information, from cherished photos to important emails and documents. Stuff like this is why I and many other people are going out of our way to make this no longer the case.

It's funny because different people would interpret this sentence differently.

If you have high level understanding of the tech behind it, this feels like a threat. But if you don't, this sounds like an honest message from someone who genuinely wants to protect you.

A regular user log into Google account and see their photos today. Tomorrow they log in and see the photos again. And they would assume this system will always work like this.

Re: Introducing selfie for sign-in: a new way to access your Google Account

#40
post #35
post #25

If there were a Doomsday Clock for how close we are to "please drink verification can" ( https://files.catbox.moe/eqg0b2.png ), scientists would now move it to 3 minutes to midnight.

We're zero minutes away from "some scammer said they were google and I had to show them my butthole to login".

Scammer?

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49028284

Post reply on HN