Publishers consider opting out of Google as search traffic declines
1–10 of 24 posts
Re: Publishers consider opting out of Google as search traffic declines
#2the era of wide spread 'global' web is over.
llm crawlers - all they do is take. they craw your content. then give it to users in distilled form in the form of 'A.I overview' or summarized content.
incentives to contribute are gone genuine original content are gone. soon enough majority of the content will be llm generated, it not already.
the original content will either be in closed communities e.g discord, mailing lists. hence 'local'
maybe video will survive but text/images - no.
Re: Publishers consider opting out of Google as search traffic declines
#3the era of wide spread 'global' web is over. llm crawlers - all they do is take. they craw your content. then give it to users in distilled form in the form of 'A.I overview' or summarized content. incentives to contribute are gone genuine original content are gone. soon enough majority of the content will be llm generated, it not already. the original content will either be in closed communities e.g discord, mailing…
You'll need something to replace it first. And so many things depend on Google's monopoly, hell, you can't pay taxes in my country without Google's monopoly.
At this point, this will simply destroy publishers' business entirely. Which won't stop some of them, but the rest will see what happens and run back to Google.
(needed for identification to fill out online taxes which is the only option left)
Re: Publishers consider opting out of Google as search traffic declines
#4the era of wide spread 'global' web is over. llm crawlers - all they do is take. they craw your content. then give it to users in distilled form in the form of 'A.I overview' or summarized content. incentives to contribute are gone genuine original content are gone. soon enough majority of the content will be llm generated, it not already. the original content will either be in closed communities e.g discord, mailing…
You'll need something to replace it first. And so many things depend on Google's monopoly, hell, you can't pay taxes in my country without Google's monopoly. At this point, this will simply destroy publishers' business entirely. Which won't stop some of them, but the rest will see what happens and run back to Google. (needed for identification to fill out online taxes which is the only option left)
How in the (excuse my French) f*ck is your government allowing google to login to do your taxes?? And it is the ONLY option??? I’m flabbergasted, honestly.
Re: Publishers consider opting out of Google as search traffic declines
#5This feels like a move that might backfire, especially for the journalists at said publications. It's already harder to research niche topics than it used to be, given how much info is stuck in login only walled gardens like Discord (or things like social media posts and Google Docs shared on said services), and a lot of outlets tend to get their info from each other as well. You can't effectively investigate everything on your own, and keeping up with a huge list of other outlets and journalists on a site like Twitter would be hell. How do they plan to learn from other outlets and publishers when considering what to cover here?
Also RIP anyone who likes doing their own research I suppose. I've always found it useful to compare different publications' coverage of a trending story when trying to figure out what the true story is here, and that feels like it'll only get significantly more difficult to do if everyone ops out of Google or other search engines.
Re: Publishers consider opting out of Google as search traffic declines
#6They should opt out of Google. What they are doing here in open daylight is insane. They stole the entire internet to train their models and are now shoving AI overviews down everyones throat. Clicks to publishers were already decreasing over the last years even without AI, but 2026 is showing what the future will look like, zero clicks from Google, because they dont care. Google got what it wanted and is now racing to AGI spending all its cash on datacenters, not caring about all the casualties along the way. Google, on its current trajectory, is truly evil in my opinion.
I'm really not a fan of regulation, but someone has to step in and have Google seperate its products, search should be free of AI overviews imo.
Re: Publishers consider opting out of Google as search traffic declines
#7Very brave of publishers to hold their own content hostage against Google search. That's certainly one noble way to die.
Re: Publishers consider opting out of Google as search traffic declines
#8One step closer to Google deprecating search and just becoming an AI chatbot. By the way, most smaller publishers have already effectively left Google, they don't try to improve their SEO at all, and just promote their content on social media.
Re: Publishers consider opting out of Google as search traffic declines
#9Earlier quoted context omitted.
You'll need something to replace it first. And so many things depend on Google's monopoly, hell, you can't pay taxes in my country without Google's monopoly. At this point, this will simply destroy publishers' business entirely. Which won't stop some of them, but the rest will see what happens and run back to Google. (needed for identification to fill out online taxes which is the only option left)
How in the (excuse my French) f*ck is your government allowing google to login to do your taxes?? And it is the ONLY option??? I’m flabbergasted, honestly.
It's not Google login, it's the Google authenticator being the only practical 2-factor option to login to government services (still annoying, but less so than trying to get one of those calculators that cost 30 euros and haven't been in stock since COVID)
Re: Publishers consider opting out of Google as search traffic declines
#10Earlier quoted context omitted.
How in the (excuse my French) f*ck is your government allowing google to login to do your taxes?? And it is the ONLY option??? I’m flabbergasted, honestly.
It's not Google login, it's the Google authenticator being the only practical 2-factor option to login to government services (still annoying, but less so than trying to get one of those calculators that cost 30 euros and haven't been in stock since COVID)
There's lots of apps that do TOTP, if that's what you're using it for.