Live data from Hacker News

Tell HN: Old Reddit Now Requires Login

news.ycombinator.com

11–20 of 35 posts

Re: Tell HN: Old Reddit Now Requires Login

#12
post #9

Can confirm that this started happening today. > Log in to use old Reddit > To keep Reddit safe, accounts are required to access old Reddit. Log in, or continue without an account on reddit.com. I don't participate in Reddit conversions and only use old.reddit.com to browse some specific subreddits as a guest.

That sounds like just the kind of risky behavior that was a huge threat to Reddit! Glad they did something about checks notes people browsing from the open web.

Re: Tell HN: Old Reddit Now Requires Login

#14

Isnt this going to decrease a massive amount of traffic from Google searches and whatnot?

the regular reddit.com can still be accessed without a login, but that's the bloated webapp with tons of ads and tracking and takes dozens of MB to load over hundreds of network requests.

Re: Tell HN: Old Reddit Now Requires Login

#15

Isnt this going to decrease a massive amount of traffic from Google searches and whatnot?

the regular reddit.com can still be accessed without a login, but that's the bloated webapp with tons of ads and tracking and takes dozens of MB to load over hundreds of network requests.

Forgot I had auto redirects setup. So lame

Re: Tell HN: Old Reddit Now Requires Login

#17
post #9

Can confirm that this started happening today. > Log in to use old Reddit > To keep Reddit safe, accounts are required to access old Reddit. Log in, or continue without an account on reddit.com. I don't participate in Reddit conversions and only use old.reddit.com to browse some specific subreddits as a guest.

It's been 9 days that way for myself but I visited their log on would be required announcement page 20 days ago, so my IP / fingerprint was probably mapped and thus first to be flagged. I noted at least one other comment at HN confirming they too had struck a request to log in the same day I found old.reddit effectively walled off. It's rare I find myself landing at reddit by way of a search, most times it is by way of following an interesting post from HN.

The new reddit site only serves me the OP of a thread (Probably my fault, my configuration I have blocked a couple of intrusive PII gathering services disguised as APIS and a bunch of other sites with intrusive scripts ) -- it's the comments where the value is at so reddit is now totally useless to me - I suppose I should get around to adding the site to my growing deny list.

Edit: clarity.

Re: Tell HN: Old Reddit Now Requires Login

#20
post #19

First I made a userscript that auto-redirects me to old.reddit, then they did this. So now I have my userscript fetch the .json version of the url, and render a minimal hackernews style UI instead of the bloated normal site.

Mind sharing the script? I am certainly not logging in just so they can track me better.
Post reply on HN