Live data from Hacker News

Korg PS-3300 is back

korg.co.uk

31–40 of 76 posts

Re: Korg PS-3300 is back

#31
post #20

Am I the only one who takes these “legends returns“ for a lack of innovation? Noticed that for a while in triple A gaming. I get it, companies are playing safe, but I don’t want to be sold the same thing over and once again.. Edit: typo

Maybe not. But you are clearly not the audience.

Re: Korg PS-3300 is back

#32
post #11
post #9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

In someways this isn’t that unlike the past. I saw that Pete Townsend has donated his synths to a school in West London. That includes a Yamaha GX-1 and an EMS modular. That’s some of the rarest (and largest) synths ever made and would have cost the equivalent of hundreds of thousands at that time. Not too many muscle in the 1970s would have been able to buy a GX-1.

FYI the current run of Korg PS-3300 sold out in minutes even at £11,000.

The 'current'? They sell out since Korg started this convoluted order "process", wbich isn't even one, since you hear conflicting things in different countries from the 'distributors".

Re: Korg PS-3300 is back

#33
post #20

Am I the only one who takes these “legends returns“ for a lack of innovation? Noticed that for a while in triple A gaming. I get it, companies are playing safe, but I don’t want to be sold the same thing over and once again.. Edit: typo

Toys for rich kids with a lack of talent basically.

I'd argue if they had a lack of talent they would prefer modern and digital alternatives - same/more/better sound and tools to churn out stuff with.

Re: Korg PS-3300 is back

#35
post #5
post #4

Nice, but I guess it's pretty expensive.

Likely around £11,000 I heard. That gives me the same feeling as a concert grand piano or installed pipe organ. I'll never get to own one or probably even touch one but I'm glad they exist for professional musicians to use. Luckily cheap software and hardware synths can give us all a taste of what they're like. This Korg seems more like something for museums or professional studios.

Yeah, you can enter the market of (physical) synthesizers for around £100, or for free via the myriad of online/digital ones.

Things like this aren't for making music (anymore), but for collecting.

Re: Korg PS-3300 is back

#36
post #19
post #12

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Unbelievable. I guess because of a lot of bored software people rather than trained musicians.

Probably some of both, but 11k is extremely reasonable for this. If I understand correctly, it has 3x complete subtractive synths per key (not just 3 oscillators into 1 filter) x 49 keys. A typical analog polyphonic synth has maybe 8 voices. The comparison is more like bulldozer vs. car than BMW vs. Toyota - entirely new capabilities are unlocked

I want to say I agree, but since this is 50 year old tech, wouldn't there be newer mass produced products that do the same thing at a fraction of the price? Even if purely analog it would benefit from economies of scale, miniaturization, etc.

Re: Korg PS-3300 is back

#37

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Toys for rich kids with a lack of talent basically.

I'd argue if they had a lack of talent they would prefer modern and digital alternatives - same/more/better sound and tools to churn out stuff with.

They don't need to churn out stuff. They just want to show off what they possess.

Re: Korg PS-3300 is back

#38
post #28

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Toys for rich kids with a lack of talent basically.

If it's purchased as an idle showpiece toy, then sure talent is optional. There will be a few old school Brian Eno adjacent types who'll want one to make noise with ... and some talent will be requisite to avoid sounding like a bag of cats being poked with a stick.

I, for one, specialize my sonic practice in immersive cat-yowl soundscapes…

Re: Korg PS-3300 is back

#39

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'd argue if they had a lack of talent they would prefer modern and digital alternatives - same/more/better sound and tools to churn out stuff with.

They don't need to churn out stuff. They just want to show off what they possess.

You're exactly right. Let me support you by adding some examples:

- Look Mum No Computer: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLluPQLh1xzlLcJd9CbAxE...

- Caught in Joy: https://www.youtube.com/@CaughtInJoy

They just show their stuff, and what they can do with these. No talent, just show. /s

Re: Korg PS-3300 is back

#40
post #14

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> £11,000 > That gives me the same feeling as a concert grand piano or installed pipe organ. I think you might need to increase the number by an order of magnitude or more to get into the ballpark of [new] concert grand pianos and installed pipe organs.

It must be understood that, unlike grand pianos, the building containing an installed pipe organ is integral to its operation and sound, so their costs, construction and maintenance are inextricably linked for the lifetime of the instrument.

Unless, of course, Cameron Carpenter is involved:

https://archive.is/DQQq0

https://www.marshallandogletree.com/opus8

…though it was in fact maintenance costs that did in the I.T.O., may it rest in peace…

> “It travels in a 53-foot truck,” he says. “It has workshop and carpenter facilities that travel with the organ at all times. It has a massive accoutrement of spare parts. And it has two sound systems.”

> The system is controlled by a bank of computers running software built on Linux, the open-source operating system.

> Maintenance costs are not inconsiderable.

> “Big computer mainframes don’t like to be turned off,” Carpenter says.

Post reply on HN