Live data from Hacker News

Traders are increasingly betting against SpaceX just weeks after IPO

ft.com

21–30 of 32 posts

Re: Traders are increasingly betting against SpaceX just weeks after IPO

#21

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Seems odd that they don't discuss a common reason to short a stock this was extensively discussed BEFORE the IPO. That is why it was overpriced. > This is just one way (of many) in which the market factors future events into today's price, which is sort of the whole point. nope. the market transferred $80B to Elon Musk from the people that got scammed.

Musk's shares are locked up for a year.

and? Are you implying that Elon doesn't own the 80B spacex got from the IPO?

Re: Traders are increasingly betting against SpaceX just weeks after IPO

#22

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Musk's shares are locked up for a year.

and? Are you implying that Elon doesn't own the 80B spacex got from the IPO?

I am implying that because it is true. SpaceX owns the $80B. Elon owns stock in SpaceX.

The IPO was a primary offering in which SpaceX issued new shares and received the proceeds. If Elon had personally sold shares, the prospectus would have identified him (or other selling shareholders) in a secondary offering. It doesn’t.

Re: Traders are increasingly betting against SpaceX just weeks after IPO

#23
post #3

Seems odd that they don't discuss a common reason to short a stock: you expect it to go down, without any real opinion on the business. In this case there is going to be a ton of new float fairly soon. It's a pretty safe bet that this will depress the price. So the natural trade is to sell now (short), and buy later (cover the short). That effectively moves the future price drop to "now", which is likely what we see.…

> Seems odd that they don't discuss a common reason to short a stock: you expect it to go down, without any real opinion on the business.

The reverse is true for meme stocks as well. You can buy a stock because you expect it to go up without any real opinion on the business.

Though we all know the opinion on the business. Great science project, bad business.

Re: Traders are increasingly betting against SpaceX just weeks after IPO

#24
post #3

Seems odd that they don't discuss a common reason to short a stock: you expect it to go down, without any real opinion on the business. In this case there is going to be a ton of new float fairly soon. It's a pretty safe bet that this will depress the price. So the natural trade is to sell now (short), and buy later (cover the short). That effectively moves the future price drop to "now", which is likely what we see.…

> Seems odd that they don't discuss a common reason to short a stock: you expect it to go down, without any real opinion on the business. The reverse is true for meme stocks as well. You can buy a stock because you expect it to go up without any real opinion on the business. Though we all know the opinion on the business. Great science project, bad business.

We all know that but people will attack you with „nobody can get a payload to the orbit cheaper”. Yeah, nobody can, and there’s limited need for that.

Re: Traders are increasingly betting against SpaceX just weeks after IPO

#25

They expect locked up shares to hit the market in August and tank the price

They also see one of the most ridiculously overvalued stocks of all time and want to collect easy money.

Only if the market is rational

Re: Traders are increasingly betting against SpaceX just weeks after IPO

#26
post #7

"Just weeks" Weeks is an enormous amount of time now actually. The majority of plays in what people do with stocks is actually very short term. People aren't the kind of Berkshire buy and hold-ers anymore. If you look it up 60% of options volumes on the S&P 500 is 0 days to expiry. Literally gambling if it goes up and down this day. Btw its not just the US that's like this. South Koreas 2x single stock ETF debacle an…

And on the other hand, there's a whole movement (in niche terms, though) of people going "just add to an S&P 500 ETF for 50 years and forget about everything else".

Substitute "target date fund" for "S&P 500 ETF" and that describes most retirement accounts... Not exactly niche.

Re: Traders are increasingly betting against SpaceX just weeks after IPO

#27
post #3

Seems odd that they don't discuss a common reason to short a stock: you expect it to go down, without any real opinion on the business. In this case there is going to be a ton of new float fairly soon. It's a pretty safe bet that this will depress the price. So the natural trade is to sell now (short), and buy later (cover the short). That effectively moves the future price drop to "now", which is likely what we see.…

Not to mention that folks that are ‘locked up’ probably had a bank/hedge fund engineer hedges until they can get out

Re: Traders are increasingly betting against SpaceX just weeks after IPO

#28

Earlier quoted context omitted.

and? Are you implying that Elon doesn't own the 80B spacex got from the IPO?

I am implying that because it is true. SpaceX owns the $80B. Elon owns stock in SpaceX. The IPO was a primary offering in which SpaceX issued new shares and received the proceeds. If Elon had personally sold shares, the prospectus would have identified him (or other selling shareholders) in a secondary offering. It doesn’t.

> Elon owns stock in SpaceX.

He also owns SpaceX management and its assets.

Re: Traders are increasingly betting against SpaceX just weeks after IPO

#29
post #3

Seems odd that they don't discuss a common reason to short a stock: you expect it to go down, without any real opinion on the business. In this case there is going to be a ton of new float fairly soon. It's a pretty safe bet that this will depress the price. So the natural trade is to sell now (short), and buy later (cover the short). That effectively moves the future price drop to "now", which is likely what we see.…

Matt Levine pointed out to a likely culprit, and it indeed has nothing to do with the business outlooks.[0]

SpaceX sold only 5% of their stock in the IPO. Earliest lockups will start to [partially] expire in mid-August, bringing in further 7% of SpaceX stock to market. If you expect the market to be flooded with >2x volume of supply, you can either sell right now before the price drops even further or hold and wait for the business fundamentals catch up with pricing expectations.

0: https://bloom.bg/4f7pFnd

Re: Traders are increasingly betting against SpaceX just weeks after IPO

#30
post #29
post #3

Seems odd that they don't discuss a common reason to short a stock: you expect it to go down, without any real opinion on the business. In this case there is going to be a ton of new float fairly soon. It's a pretty safe bet that this will depress the price. So the natural trade is to sell now (short), and buy later (cover the short). That effectively moves the future price drop to "now", which is likely what we see.…

Matt Levine pointed out to a likely culprit, and it indeed has nothing to do with the business outlooks.[0] SpaceX sold only 5% of their stock in the IPO. Earliest lockups will start to [partially] expire in mid-August, bringing in further 7% of SpaceX stock to market. If you expect the market to be flooded with >2x volume of supply, you can either sell right now before the price drops even further or hold and wait f…

Yes, that’s what the parent comment meant by “there is going to be a ton of new float fairly soon”
Post reply on HN