Live data from Hacker News

Gleam Is Now on Tangled

tangled.org

101–110 of 162 posts

Re: Gleam Is Now on Tangled

#101

[flagged]

Not sure how good of a social protocol it is, but I see ATProto/PDS as a possible succesor to solid [1], if they implment the permissioned data access model correctly. Which would certainly have a lot of good usecases, beyond social apps.

[1] solid: https://solidproject.org/about

Re: Gleam Is Now on Tangled

#102
post #51

I'd love to hear why they chose a VC funded forge over e.g. Codeberg. Doesn't really fit the 'friendly language' claim IMO

"being on tangled" really just means "publishing sh.tangled.* atproto records"

the beauty of atproto means that you are in no way tied to the VC funded company behind the web app available at tangled.org. you merely publish your git repository using a protocol that this app will pick up and present with a nice UI

any other app that speaks atproto and looks at those same sh.tangled.* records will be able to access everything in the same way

and even the git repository itself doesn't need to be hosted by tangled the company, you can host your repository yourself. all you need is a server that can speak git, ssh, http and websocket

Re: Gleam Is Now on Tangled

#103
post #84

Picture this: someone “moderates” your bluesky account for some unrelated reason and you’re no longer able to manage your own source codes…

this is like complaining that you can't login anywhere because google banned your gmail account...

Re: Gleam Is Now on Tangled

#104

[flagged]

Wow I had no idea, thank you for your well-reasoned critique! I can tell you're very capable of evaluating the merits of complex socio-technological systems. Your wisdom is unparalleled; now I see we all should just keep using X and GitHub.

GP just created an account to shitpost about ATProto out of desperation, what else can we expect from them. look at the username and account age, XD

Re: Gleam Is Now on Tangled

#105
I have no idea what Gleam or Tangled is, so for me this headline might as well be an article from The Onion satirizing HN. I also refuse to believe any of these two things are large enough, like say Postgres, that one can claim everyone should know it. Surely writing an informative headline for ”hackers in general” can’t be that difficult.

Re: Gleam Is Now on Tangled

#106
post #105

I have no idea what Gleam or Tangled is, so for me this headline might as well be an article from The Onion satirizing HN. I also refuse to believe any of these two things are large enough, like say Postgres, that one can claim everyone should know it. Surely writing an informative headline for ”hackers in general” can’t be that difficult.

If you click on the title, it will tell you more.

Gleam has had many dozens of front page posts here.

Tangled is a niche GitHub alternative, but has also had previous history.

Re: Gleam Is Now on Tangled

#107
post #63
post #58

Earlier quoted context omitted.

They're still on GitHub. This isn't any sort of official transition. It's just now also on this other ATProto-based forge.

So I assume you know that tangled being ATProto-based was the reason for going there? And please explain how it's not a choice when they are still on GitHub.

No, Tangled's ATProto relationship and its social features are just the only differentiating factors.

They mirrored their repo somewhere else. An additional location does not make it less friendly.

Re: Gleam Is Now on Tangled

#108
post #84

Picture this: someone “moderates” your bluesky account for some unrelated reason and you’re no longer able to manage your own source codes…

this is like complaining that you can't login anywhere because google banned your gmail account...

And we don’t complain about that because nobody uses “sign in with google” for mission critical stuff. It’s absolutely a choice to tie all your things to a single corp.

Re: Gleam Is Now on Tangled

#109
post #84

Picture this: someone “moderates” your bluesky account for some unrelated reason and you’re no longer able to manage your own source codes…

This regularly happens with Microsoft's GitHub. You can also opt to not use Bluesky for authentication.

Re: Gleam Is Now on Tangled

#110
post #92
post #84

Picture this: someone “moderates” your bluesky account for some unrelated reason and you’re no longer able to manage your own source codes…

If this is a concern you can just migrate to a different PDS

Apparently, that’s not enough. You will also need your own “app view” which means you will be self hosting an over engineered forge with social features you can’t use… so why go that road to begin with is beyond me tbh.
Post reply on HN