I found these hilarious!
I was ROFL over some of the mistakes the AI made. Parts of it was amazing, other parts were amazingly off.
$100 AI Music Video: Claude Fable 5 vs. GPT-5.6 Sol
531–540 of 581 posts
Re: $100 AI Music Video: Claude Fable 5 vs. GPT-5.6 Sol
#532Earlier quoted context omitted.
Lots of the shots in white and nerdy are literally showing what the lyrics are describing, is there another level to them with references I’ve missed?
It's Riding Dirty but it it's about a guy who does anything but. It's a song about how white people find black culture cool but are themselves stereotypically uncool. It's a song about nerd culture and celebrating that, wherein a white nerd makes the same kinds of boasts that black rappers do in their music, but about nerd stuff. It's layered, as any good parody has to be, with cultural references. When Al mows the l…
There’s two sides to what you’ve said - I’d forgotten lots of the things like trying to lock the car doors, which is an additional point although the scene is still pretty direct.
The other things you’re saying are about the song and storytelling there which is not relevant here. We’re talking about the translation from the song and lyrics to a video. The things I’d remembered about the video were very direct translations from the lyrics, because the lyrics are very clear and to the point.
> Al mentions that his rims don't spin not because the rims of the car in the frame aren't spinning but because he's a nerd and why would a nerd have spinning rims?
Right, a thing in the lyrics.
Re: $100 AI Music Video: Claude Fable 5 vs. GPT-5.6 Sol
#533Like most of this stuff, it's obviously impressive technology compared to what existed a few years ago. But the end product has zero artistic value. It's a grey goo of the average of every concept picked up from the concept of the song. A talented creative with a vision could make something more interesting and enjoyable in an afternoon with a $0 budget.
As much as I don't want jobs taken away by AI, a creative person with a vision that would usually required $1 million budget, could create such a video using AI by being very specific in what they require which would not be a " grey goo of the average of every concept " eg. "scene 32, same 2 characters from the previous scene, now dressed in the garb of Egyption middle kingdom high priests, though with cat faces, dan…
I find video models very hard to steer. They can output amazing "shiny" things quickly, but if you want something very specific, you may need to spend days on it. It is not like sitting down with an artist and seeing how they make the exact changes you need in real time while also ensuring artistic cohesion.
AI is obviously very useful, but perhaps not in the way people think. Two aspects I would like to see improved are instruction following and providing relevant feedback.
Re: $100 AI Music Video: Claude Fable 5 vs. GPT-5.6 Sol
#534Re: $100 AI Music Video: Claude Fable 5 vs. GPT-5.6 Sol
#535Earlier quoted context omitted.
It's Riding Dirty but it it's about a guy who does anything but. It's a song about how white people find black culture cool but are themselves stereotypically uncool. It's a song about nerd culture and celebrating that, wherein a white nerd makes the same kinds of boasts that black rappers do in their music, but about nerd stuff. It's layered, as any good parody has to be, with cultural references. When Al mows the l…
There’s two sides to what you’ve said - I’d forgotten lots of the things like trying to lock the car doors, which is an additional point although the scene is still pretty direct. The other things you’re saying are about the song and storytelling there which is not relevant here. We’re talking about the translation from the song and lyrics to a video. The things I’d remembered about the video were very direct transla…
I feel like people are being purposely obtuse here. OK. If you want to believe that satire and parody only consist of blindly showing things mentioned in the lyrics in order to imply that these AI generated videos are equivalent in art and skill to what Wierd Al does, I won't even try to stop you.
But most people are going to understand the difference between the two and see that argument for the reach that it is.
Re: $100 AI Music Video: Claude Fable 5 vs. GPT-5.6 Sol
#536Well if AI destroys bad music videos by making them cost $25, I say it's a win. What will be left will be seriously scripted productions.
Re: $100 AI Music Video: Claude Fable 5 vs. GPT-5.6 Sol
#537Re: $100 AI Music Video: Claude Fable 5 vs. GPT-5.6 Sol
#538Re: $100 AI Music Video: Claude Fable 5 vs. GPT-5.6 Sol
#539Earlier quoted context omitted.
I would really love to see examples of creatives using modern AI/LLMs to make quality art, and it feels like this should be happening, but I can't think of any examples yet. Maybe there's so much low-effort slop that the good works are lost in the noise. Or maybe most artists don't use AI on principle. I would love to see examples if anyone has any. I saw a few things on r/AIVideos that I sort of liked, but I wouldn'…
Look up a Kenneth Anger or Maya Deren film. You probably won't be impressed and these are legendary figures in experimental film making either. There is no audience or market for what these tools would be good for. These videos in the examples are laughable uncreative trash to me but so are big budget super hero human slop. The main constraint with AI art is that I think the models have been overfit to a very narrow…
I don't think you can make the absolute statement that there is no audience or market for these tools. I enjoyed watching all of these videos. They are far from banal crap. They are deranged. They are not intentionally deranged, it is limitation of the tool. If a video artist were to employ these tools not to save effort, but instead to create an aesthetic it would be proper and good use. Just like non-AI video editors or color grading tools.
Re: $100 AI Music Video: Claude Fable 5 vs. GPT-5.6 Sol
#540Earlier quoted context omitted.
As much as I don't want jobs taken away by AI, a creative person with a vision that would usually required $1 million budget, could create such a video using AI by being very specific in what they require which would not be a " grey goo of the average of every concept " eg. "scene 32, same 2 characters from the previous scene, now dressed in the garb of Egyption middle kingdom high priests, though with cat faces, dan…
This is not about jobs taken away by AI. There are not that many jobs for artists to begin with. And OP was not talking about a job. > Your mind is your limit. AI is a tool. Then the companies should start talking about them the same way as they talk about tools. Because when they are pushing for artists replacement by AI, they are not talking about tools. They are trying to make AI into a person while very intention…
Most of the discussions I've read about AI is as a tool. There is a narrative being created that its all about replacing humans. I've not seen that outside of a view influencers.