Live data from Hacker News

Timeline Scan – AI fixes the dates on your scanned photos

timelinescan.com

1–10 of 35 posts

Re: Timeline Scan – AI fixes the dates on your scanned photos

#2
Scanned photos all show up on the day you scan them. Timeline Scan estimates when each photo was actually taken and writes it into the file’s EXIF, so your archive sorts chronologically in Immich, Google Photos, or Apple Photos (or by folders if you’re one of those people). I increased the trial to 50 photos; try it out and let me know what you think!

Re: Timeline Scan – AI fixes the dates on your scanned photos

#4

Scanned photos all show up on the day you scan them. Timeline Scan estimates when each photo was actually taken and writes it into the file’s EXIF, so your archive sorts chronologically in Immich, Google Photos, or Apple Photos (or by folders if you’re one of those people). I increased the trial to 50 photos; try it out and let me know what you think!

Based on what? Each image individually? Or does it try to cross-reference images within the collection and with events in your life, etc?

Re: Timeline Scan – AI fixes the dates on your scanned photos

#5
OCRing handwritten dates and printed timestamps seems useful, but how is “AI” supposed to know when a photo is taken just by looking at it?

At least the scan date is a real piece of data that could be useful. This seems like it would cause more harm than good by polluting the data with nonsense, unless the added dates are clearly labeled as estimates

Re: Timeline Scan – AI fixes the dates on your scanned photos

#6

Scanned photos all show up on the day you scan them. Timeline Scan estimates when each photo was actually taken and writes it into the file’s EXIF, so your archive sorts chronologically in Immich, Google Photos, or Apple Photos (or by folders if you’re one of those people). I increased the trial to 50 photos; try it out and let me know what you think!

Based on what? Each image individually? Or does it try to cross-reference images within the collection and with events in your life, etc?

vibes

Re: Timeline Scan – AI fixes the dates on your scanned photos

#7
> Google Cloud (Gemini Enterprise): AI date extraction. Photos are sent to Gemini Enterprise solely for date extraction and are not used to train Google’s models. Microsoft PhotoDNA: child-safety hash scanning (see “Child safety scanning”).

Technical background.

Re: Timeline Scan – AI fixes the dates on your scanned photos

#8
The problem I have is that there's no way to embed an "uncertainty" into EXIF metadata in a standard way. I just want some photos to be "Summer 1987" or "February 1976" or even "1981-1983"... but I _have_ to invent some complete timestamp down to the second and then just rely upon captions or comments.

But I generally know the dates far better than any AI could guess (based on ages of the individuals I know).

Re: Timeline Scan – AI fixes the dates on your scanned photos

#9

OCRing handwritten dates and printed timestamps seems useful, but how is “AI” supposed to know when a photo is taken just by looking at it? At least the scan date is a real piece of data that could be useful. This seems like it would cause more harm than good by polluting the data with nonsense, unless the added dates are clearly labeled as estimates

Yeah, seems like snake oil with a dash of malarkey.

Re: Timeline Scan – AI fixes the dates on your scanned photos

#10

Scanned photos all show up on the day you scan them. Timeline Scan estimates when each photo was actually taken and writes it into the file’s EXIF, so your archive sorts chronologically in Immich, Google Photos, or Apple Photos (or by folders if you’re one of those people). I increased the trial to 50 photos; try it out and let me know what you think!

Based on what? Each image individually? Or does it try to cross-reference images within the collection and with events in your life, etc?

It does both. Each image and then neighbors. Usually you scan photos that are printed in related-date order. So it does look at neighboring photos to date.

You can tag faces and add a birthdate; so sort of. Like it'll recognize a birthday party photo and then if it's tagged with that person in the picture, it will date it on their birthday.

Post reply on HN