Live data from Hacker News

Photos of items from families in different countries with different incomes

gapminder.org

1–10 of 64 posts

Re: Photos of items from families in different countries with different incomes

#3
It's interesting that $14000/month is "rich" on this website, and some people earning $100/month actually own houses.

Meanwhile people making $50000/month in San Francisco can't afford a house because half of it is taxed away and housing is astronomically expensive.

Re: Photos of items from families in different countries with different incomes

#4
post #3

It's interesting that $14000/month is "rich" on this website, and some people earning $100/month actually own houses. Meanwhile people making $50000/month in San Francisco can't afford a house because half of it is taxed away and housing is astronomically expensive.

I promise you that someone in SF making $50k/month can comfortably afford a very nice house.

Re: Photos of items from families in different countries with different incomes

#5
post #4
post #3

It's interesting that $14000/month is "rich" on this website, and some people earning $100/month actually own houses. Meanwhile people making $50000/month in San Francisco can't afford a house because half of it is taxed away and housing is astronomically expensive.

I promise you that someone in SF making $50k/month can comfortably afford a very nice house.

I promise you not. Houses here cost $2M+ for something livable and $1M for something with mold and other safety issues.

When half that $50K gets taxed, half of what's remaining has to be saved up for retirement in a place that deeply discriminates against age, you don't have much left to save up for buying a $2M house.

Re: Photos of items from families in different countries with different incomes

#6
post #3

It's interesting that $14000/month is "rich" on this website, and some people earning $100/month actually own houses. Meanwhile people making $50000/month in San Francisco can't afford a house because half of it is taxed away and housing is astronomically expensive.

If your net pay is $7000 per month you absolutely can afford to own a house, you're just being fussy about the house you want.

Re: Photos of items from families in different countries with different incomes

#7
post #3

It's interesting that $14000/month is "rich" on this website, and some people earning $100/month actually own houses. Meanwhile people making $50000/month in San Francisco can't afford a house because half of it is taxed away and housing is astronomically expensive.

If your net pay is $7000 per month you absolutely can afford to own a house, you're just being fussy about the house you want.

You're not going to save up for a $1-2M house very fast on $7000/month, when you also have to live off that $7K, pay rent, pay medical bills, and save up for retirement expenses.

Re: Photos of items from families in different countries with different incomes

#8
post #5
post #4

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I promise you that someone in SF making $50k/month can comfortably afford a very nice house.

I promise you not. Houses here cost $2M+ for something livable and $1M for something with mold and other safety issues. When half that $50K gets taxed, half of what's remaining has to be saved up for retirement in a place that deeply discriminates against age, you don't have much left to save up for buying a $2M house.

Ok, I made my other comment before seeing this but I find it very difficult to believe you can't find something reasonable for far less.

Re: Photos of items from families in different countries with different incomes

#9
post #3

It's interesting that $14000/month is "rich" on this website, and some people earning $100/month actually own houses. Meanwhile people making $50000/month in San Francisco can't afford a house because half of it is taxed away and housing is astronomically expensive.

You have it backwards. Housing is astronomically expensive in San Francisco precisely because there are so many people with high incomes bidding against each other.

When you have a highly inelastic supply (constrained by zoning laws, density limits, and geographical boundaries), prices rise to the maximum margin of what the highest-income buyers are capable of paying.

Regarding taxes: Since taxes apply to all local high-earners equally, it doesn't change their relative purchasing power against one another in the local housing market. If taxes were suddenly halved, that extra liquidity would be priced into the next bidding war, driving home prices even higher.

Re: Photos of items from families in different countries with different incomes

#10
post #5

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I promise you not. Houses here cost $2M+ for something livable and $1M for something with mold and other safety issues. When half that $50K gets taxed, half of what's remaining has to be saved up for retirement in a place that deeply discriminates against age, you don't have much left to save up for buying a $2M house.

Ok, I made my other comment before seeing this but I find it very difficult to believe you can't find something reasonable for far less.

Nah it's the reality here. I'd say minimum income to safely own housing here is $100K-150K/month. OR cash already saved for the home, in which case income doesn't matter.

Yes, lots of households make that much, especially people at e.g. Nvidia with unvested appreciated RSUs.

Yes, the US economy is that badly fucked.

And the people on mortages were brainwashed into buying something they can't afford, and in for a foreclosure disaster when the economy corrects.

Post reply on HN