Live data from Hacker News

Indian scientists produce most detailed 3D atlas of the human brainstem

bbc.com

21–28 of 28 posts

Re: Indian scientists produce most detailed 3D atlas of the human brainstem

#21
post #9

> The researchers have made the atlas freely available online fuck yes. finally someone not gatekeeping lifesaving technologies so they can make shit ton of money out of it.

I believe this is how most publicly funded research and some private research institutes work. This research was conducted by a public Indian university (IIT Madras). Which, by the way is literally more selective than IVY league universities

Me hiring a PA is literally more selective than that. Only one person can qualify.

Re: Indian scientists produce most detailed 3D atlas of the human brainstem

#22
post #9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I believe this is how most publicly funded research and some private research institutes work. This research was conducted by a public Indian university (IIT Madras). Which, by the way is literally more selective than IVY league universities

Me hiring a PA is literally more selective than that. Only one person can qualify.

I should have clarified that I was defining selectivity as the ratio between applicants and accepted candidates. Getting in this school requires someone to be among the top 250k takers of a specific exam (JEE main) typically, it’d be taken by around 1.5 million students. If one is among those 250k, one can choose to do the advanced test.. which in 2025 was cleared by 56 880 students .. from which, 18,188 students were admitted.

And yes, if you have more than .. 84 candidates, your process would be more selective. However, I think the fair comparison would be .. say .. the MIT?

On the same year, the MIT got 29,282 applications and admitted 1,324 students

So if you apply to the MIT you’re more than 3 times likelier to get accepted.

Re: Indian scientists produce most detailed 3D atlas of the human brainstem

#23
post #11
post #9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I believe this is how most publicly funded research and some private research institutes work. This research was conducted by a public Indian university (IIT Madras). Which, by the way is literally more selective than IVY league universities

Doesnt matter how selective they are if the Budget of 1 MIT is $5 Billion while the budget of all 23 IIT is less than $1 Billion. There is a reason why so many Indian scientists move out of India.

[flagged]

Re: Indian scientists produce most detailed 3D atlas of the human brainstem

#24
post #22

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Me hiring a PA is literally more selective than that. Only one person can qualify.

I should have clarified that I was defining selectivity as the ratio between applicants and accepted candidates. Getting in this school requires someone to be among the top 250k takers of a specific exam (JEE main) typically, it’d be taken by around 1.5 million students. If one is among those 250k, one can choose to do the advanced test.. which in 2025 was cleared by 56 880 students .. from which, 18,188 students wer…

Not a fair comparison. IITs are a bottleneck given there aren't better (in terms of reputation and outcome) schools here. And plenty more apply simply because it's a rite of passage for every Indian kid. I'd guess less so for MIT given kids pre-reject themselves.

Speaking anecdotally, of course.

Re: Indian scientists produce most detailed 3D atlas of the human brainstem

#26
post #11
post #9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I believe this is how most publicly funded research and some private research institutes work. This research was conducted by a public Indian university (IIT Madras). Which, by the way is literally more selective than IVY league universities

Doesnt matter how selective they are if the Budget of 1 MIT is $5 Billion while the budget of all 23 IIT is less than $1 Billion. There is a reason why so many Indian scientists move out of India.

I'm not sure what point you're making, but if anything, that makes this MORE impressive not less, if they can do great work with little resources.

Re: Indian scientists produce most detailed 3D atlas of the human brainstem

#28
post #22

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Me hiring a PA is literally more selective than that. Only one person can qualify.

I should have clarified that I was defining selectivity as the ratio between applicants and accepted candidates. Getting in this school requires someone to be among the top 250k takers of a specific exam (JEE main) typically, it’d be taken by around 1.5 million students. If one is among those 250k, one can choose to do the advanced test.. which in 2025 was cleared by 56 880 students .. from which, 18,188 students wer…

> So if you apply to the MIT you’re more than 3 times likelier to get accepted.

That's based on numbers only, not reach or desirability. It's like saying India must be the best place in the world to live because it has the largest population.

Post reply on HN