Live data from Hacker News

Vancouver PD website features Quick Escape button that wipes itself from history

vpd.ca

91–100 of 156 posts

Re: Vancouver PD website features Quick Escape button that wipes itself from history

#91
post #52

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The former should forward to the latter.

Agreed. If the content isn't really designed for the wide world, the www hostname seems to be self-defeating, or at least describing the wrong thing.

So how do you agree? You're saying the opposite they said.

Re: Vancouver PD website features Quick Escape button that wipes itself from history

#92

I've implemented quick exit/escape buttons for a few organisations over the years and have spent a bit of time thinking about the limitations. This pattern is definitely better than most and it is refreshing seeing they put some resources into it. In my professional experience, organisations often chose the "a link to another site like google is fine" option to save money and time while still getting to boast about t…

Indeed this is mostly performative by the police because the user would switch apps, turn off the phone screen, or any other easier way as you describe.

Re: Vancouver PD website features Quick Escape button that wipes itself from history

#93

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That and they dont want butt dialing 911 to be easy

Quickly press the power button 5 times if you have an android phone and see what happens. This has got to be the absolutely worst idea ever and it's enabled by default!

It asks you in first-time set up if you want it. 'Yes' might be the default selected option, but it's not like opting out requires you knowing about it and going looking for it.

Re: Vancouver PD website features Quick Escape button that wipes itself from history

#94
post #83
post #35

The gov.uk Design System calls this the "Exit a page quickly" pattern [1], with an associated component [2]. It can be activated by clicking the Shift key three times. There's this nice blog [3] that explains why they chose Shift instead of other keys, and also gives a nice overview of the pattern. [1] https://design-system.service.gov.uk/patterns/exit-a-page-qu... [2] https://design-system.service.gov.uk/components/…

This is nice but how, as a user, do you learn it exists?

They do explain this:

> Interruption page

> Create a page to explain Exit this page to users.

> You must show this page after the start point of your service, but before the page where the user will see the Exit this page button for the first time.

> On longer services, you might need more than one interruption page.

Re: Vancouver PD website features Quick Escape button that wipes itself from history

#95
Isn't this exactly why browsers implemented "private mode"?

Why don't they inform users about how to properly use private mode, which works with any website, instead of rolling their own solution, which the user has to learn just for that one website?

Re: Vancouver PD website features Quick Escape button that wipes itself from history

#96

Isn't this exactly why browsers implemented "private mode"? Why don't they inform users about how to properly use private mode, which works with any website, instead of rolling their own solution, which the user has to learn just for that one website?

Private mode assumes you choose in advance. If you are suddenly approached, you can trigger the quick exit without any prior planning and it can be done inconspicuously.

Re: Vancouver PD website features Quick Escape button that wipes itself from history

#97

Isn't this exactly why browsers implemented "private mode"? Why don't they inform users about how to properly use private mode, which works with any website, instead of rolling their own solution, which the user has to learn just for that one website?

Because most users aren’t computer savvy and victims in a hurry probably don’t have time for a lesson.

On top of that, informing users requires them to open up the website in the first place… leaving it in… the history.

Re: Vancouver PD website features Quick Escape button that wipes itself from history

#98
post #84
post #71

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This would also leave intact cookies, local/session storage, indexeddb, caches. All of which abusers do actually check, when controlling their victims.

I'm sure 99% don't? Unless your abuser is a CS major

Have fun exploring the list of things we've caught abusers actually using. [0] Or don't. Reading and keeping your soul intact aren't compatible.

I am 100% sure that some do, thanks to firsthand life. And any doing it, is enough to get people dead, even if 99% don't. And yes, CS majors can be abusers, too.

[0] https://www.esafety.gov.au/key-topics/domestic-family-violen...

Re: Vancouver PD website features Quick Escape button that wipes itself from history

#99

Isn't this exactly why browsers implemented "private mode"? Why don't they inform users about how to properly use private mode, which works with any website, instead of rolling their own solution, which the user has to learn just for that one website?

They could be in a situation where that’s not available such as a child’s phone with parental controls or a managed work device that has it locked out.

Re: Vancouver PD website features Quick Escape button that wipes itself from history

#100
I like that this treats as a UX problem not just a technical one. The challenge is making sure people know the feature exists before they need it. An escape mechanism isn't very useful if you only discover it after you're already in a stressful situation.
Post reply on HN