Live data from Hacker News

Dupes took over the world

vox.com

1–10 of 137 posts

Re: Dupes took over the world

#5
post #2

With decreasing quality of branded products, there's less to distinguish them from dupes. https://ledger.worseonpurpose.com/

Cool website! Some examples I was aware of before:

https://ledger.worseonpurpose.com/brands/dr-martens

https://ledger.worseonpurpose.com/brands/corningware

Re: Dupes took over the world

#6
post #4

For the vast majority of human existence 'dupe culture' was the norm. So far this is just a tiny 200 year abberation.

The centralisation is abnormal. Used to have one blacksmith in each village making clone horseshoes and earning a living. Now there's one company in South Korea that makes all the world's horseshoes and earns a million livings while each village has minus one living. And the guy who invented the horseshoe is sleeping under a bridge.

Re: Dupes took over the world

#7
> When Deckers, the company behind fleece-lined UGG boots, recently took Quince to court over its lookalike boots, it tried to bar Quince from referencing “dupe culture” at trial.

> The bid failed, confirming that “dupes” and “dupe culture” — a commercial ecosystem built around providing consumers cheaper alternatives to name-brand products — are cultural phenomena here to stay.

> The trial focused on whether Quince’s shearling boots that really, really look like UGGs violated the existing patent for the design. And in a twist, the jury ruled that yes, Quince had copied the UGG design — but the patent over the UGG boot should not have been issued in the first place because the design was too generic to protect. The ruling opened the door for Quince and any other brand to make a similar-looking boot, opening up a new frontier for “dupe culture.”

UGG itself is a company that operates by abusing intellectual property laws.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ugg_boots_trademark_dispute

Re: Dupes took over the world

#9
post #2

With decreasing quality of branded products, there's less to distinguish them from dupes. https://ledger.worseonpurpose.com/

Cool website! Some examples I was aware of before: https://ledger.worseonpurpose.com/brands/dr-martens https://ledger.worseonpurpose.com/brands/corningware

I didn't know WMF got acquired and is doing some heavy restructuring. If the quality reduces that would be really sad to see

https://ledger.worseonpurpose.com/brands/wmf

Re: Dupes took over the world

#10
post #7

> When Deckers, the company behind fleece-lined UGG boots, recently took Quince to court over its lookalike boots, it tried to bar Quince from referencing “dupe culture” at trial. > The bid failed, confirming that “dupes” and “dupe culture” — a commercial ecosystem built around providing consumers cheaper alternatives to name-brand products — are cultural phenomena here to stay. > The trial focused on whether Quince’…

Seems wild to me they would be still suing to protect that patent in 2026 (or 'recently') – cheap Primark clones seemed to be the standard footwear of (female) teens & pre-teens in the 00s. (And they absolutely called them 'UGGs'.) That ship has long since sailed.
Post reply on HN